# What is brittle fracture?

> Brittle fracture is sudden, fast cracking of a metal with little or no plastic deformation, at stresses that can be well below yield. It needs three things together: a crack-like flaw, high stress at that flaw and low notch toughness, which in carbon steel falls as temperature drops. ASME Section VIII and other codes set toughness rules against it.

- Label: Fact
- Type: Explainer
- Published: 2026-11-14T11:53:52+09:00
- By: Jun Zhong
- Researched and drafted by: Beacon's AI newsroom
- Checked by: Jun Zhong on 2026-11-14
- Topics: LNG, Pipelines, Refining
- Canonical: https://beacon.winda.ai/library/brittle-fracture/

## Why does it matter?

On 2 January 1988, a 4-million-gallon oil storage tank at a terminal in Floreffe, near West Elizabeth, Pennsylvania, split open on the first occasion it was filled to the top after being rebuilt on the site [2]. About 1 million gallons of oil reached the Monongahela River, contaminating the water supply of towns that draw from it [2]. The National Bureau of Standards, now the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), found a brittle fracture that began at a 0.74-inch flaw left by cutting before the rebuild, in shell steel at about 0 °C (32 °F) that was too low in toughness to stop a running crack [2].

## What causes brittle fracture?

NIST describes three conditions that must act together [1]:

| Condition | Where it comes from | At Floreffe, 1988 [2] |
|---|---|---|
| A crack or crack-like flaw | Fabrication flaws in areas not inspected or missed by inspection; cracks grown in service [1] | A flaw from a cutting operation, present before the tank was rebuilt |
| High stress at the flaw | Stress raisers in the geometry and residual stress from welding, especially welds never stress relieved [1] | Residual weld stress plus the load of the oil, close to yield at the flaw |
| Low notch toughness | Low metal temperature, a low-toughness grade, or steel embrittled by heat or service [1] | Steel hardened by cutting and welding next to the flaw, at about 0 °C (32 °F) |

Take away any one and a brittle crack cannot start, or cannot keep running [1]. NIST noted that steel tough enough to arrest a crack lets a tank leak instead of bursting, behavior it described as leak before break [2].

Cracks are dangerous out of proportion to their size: a cracked piece fails at a much lower load than its loss of cross-section alone would suggest, because the stress concentrates at the crack tip [5]. In tension, once the energy released by crack growth exceeds the material's resistance, growth becomes unstable, which is why brittle failures are sudden [5].

## How does temperature change steel toughness?

Carbon and low-alloy steels are tough when warm and brittle when cold, with a transition between the two [1]. For a typical carbon steel this transition spans about 55 °C (100 °F), and for some grades room temperature falls inside it [1]. The steel's physical makeup does not change; only its response to a notch and load does [1].

The Charpy V-notch test measures this. For the Floreffe investigation, NBS broke small notched bars cut from the first two shell courses at six temperatures between 20 °F and 160 °F, and for each one recorded the energy it absorbed, how far it spread sideways and how much of its broken face had failed in shear [2]. At 55 °F and below, every plate absorbed under 10 ft-lb and broke mostly without shear; the steel only became tough at around 100 °F, so a shell at about 32 °F sat well on the brittle side of its transition [2].

## When does brittle fracture happen in service?

- **On first loading or first cold exposure.** NIST notes failures can come after a successful hydrostatic test, because service may be much colder than the test and cracks can form or grow in operation [1]. The Floreffe tank failed on its first full fill after rebuilding [2].
- **When process upsets chill equipment.** At a gas plant in Longford, Victoria, in 1998, loss of warm lean oil chilled a reboiler to about -42 °C (normally about 100 °C), and it fractured when warm oil was reintroduced; 2 people died and the state's gas supply stopped for over 2 weeks, according to a summary by the Institution of Chemical Engineers (IChemE) [3].

NIST cites the World War II Liberty ships that split open and welded tank failures in the 1940s as earlier examples with similar steels, flaws and stresses [2].

## How is the risk assessed?

Codes control toughness at the design stage; NIST pointed to notch toughness rules in ASME Section VIII, Division 1 [1]. In service, guidance from the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) notes that detected cracks can be evaluated with fracture mechanics, and that a safety judgment has to assume the biggest crack an inspection could have overlooked is present, rather than relying on the smallest one the method is able to detect [4]. See [Minimum design metal temperature (MDMT)](/glossary/minimum-design-metal-temperature/) and [How are crack-like flaws assessed for fitness-for-service?](/library/crack-like-flaw-assessment/).

## Where integrity problems show up

| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Field-erected storage tanks, especially rebuilt or relocated ones | Pre-existing flaws, embrittled weld zones, low-toughness shell steel, cold weather at first full fill [2] | Toughness testing of the steel (Charpy and drop-weight tests) and weld examination; at Floreffe the flaw was not caught by weld quality tests [2] | [API 653](/library/api-653/), [Storage tank types](/library/storage-tank-types/) |
| Cold heat exchangers in gas processing | Loss of warm process flow during an upset, then warm fluid reintroduced [3] | Hazard studies that identify low-temperature cases; IChemE notes cold embrittlement is sometimes overlooked [3] | [Hazard and operability study (HAZOP)](/library/hazop/), [MDMT](/glossary/minimum-design-metal-temperature/) |
| Pressure vessels with as-welded seams | Residual stress in welds without PWHT, low temperature, incomplete inspection [1] | Weld examination, then fracture mechanics evaluation of any cracks found [1][4] | [Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT)](/library/post-weld-heat-treatment/), [Non-destructive testing (NDT) methods](/library/ndt-methods-overview/) |

Sources: NIST SP 780 [1]; NBSIR 88-3792 [2]; IChemE [3]; OSHA [4].

## Sources

1. [NIST Special Publication 780, Guidelines for Pressure Vessel Safety Assessment (S. Yukawa), US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)](https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/Legacy/SP/nistspecialpublication780.pdf)
2. [NBSIR 88-3792, Investigation into the Ashland Oil Storage Tank Collapse on January 2, 1988 (J. L. Gross and others), US National Bureau of Standards (now NIST)](https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/Legacy/IR/nbsir88-3792.pdf)
3. [Lessons Learned Database: Deethaniser Reboiler Catastrophic Failure, Longford, Victoria, 25 September 1998 (P. Marsh), Institution of Chemical Engineers (IChemE)](https://www.icheme.org/media/14214/longford-incident-summary-25-sep-98.pdf)
4. [OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines, US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)](https://www.osha.gov/otm/section-4-safety-hazards/chapter-3)
5. [Brittle Fracture (Teaching and Learning Package), DoITPoMS, University of Cambridge](https://www.doitpoms.ac.uk/tlplib/brittle_fracture/index.php)

Published by Winda Beacon (https://beacon.winda.ai).
