# What is carburization?

> Carburization is the uptake of carbon by a metal exposed at high temperature to hydrocarbons, coke or other carbon-rich gases. Carbon diffuses inward and forms carbides, leaving the metal harder, less ductile and prone to cracking. It is a main life-limiting damage mechanism for the tubes of ethylene cracking furnaces.

- Label: Fact
- Type: Explainer
- Published: 2026-11-13T15:18:43+09:00
- By: Jun Zhong
- Researched and drafted by: Beacon's AI newsroom
- Checked by: Jun Zhong on 2026-11-13
- Topics: Refining
- Canonical: https://beacon.winda.ai/library/carburization/

## Why does it matter?

A 2004 study for the US Department of Energy (DOE) found that carburization forces ethylene producers to replace furnace tubes and fittings every 2 to 7 years, because the carbon that diffuses into the metal leaves it brittle and liable to fracture [1]. The same study put the cost of replacing furnace tubing at about $200 million a year for ethylene producers, citing estimates from 2000 and 2004 [1]. A study of centrifugally cast HK-40 cracking tubes called carburization the most damaging factor in setting tube life [2].

## How does carburization happen?

Inside a cracking furnace, hydrocarbons and steam flow through coils at very high wall temperatures, and coke builds up on the inner wall between decoking runs [1][4]. That coke layer favors carburization [4]. Carbon then moves into the metal by diffusion, driven by the difference in carbon content between the surface and the interior and speeded by temperature [5]. This is the same process that heat treaters use on purpose to harden the surface of steel parts [5].

Heat-resistant tube alloys keep carbon out mainly with a tight, adherent oxide scale, and carburization begins where that scale spalls off [2]. Inside the metal, the carbon combines with chromium to form chromium carbides, which pulls chromium out of the surrounding metal [2]. The carbides take up extra volume and change thermal expansion, so cracks can open in both the carburized inner layer and the unaffected outer layer [2].

## What does it do to a furnace tube?

- **Brittleness.** Tubes and fittings become brittle and susceptible to fracture [1].
- **Loss of ductility.** A 0.4C-35Cr-45Ni-Nb coil removed after five years at 1,125 °C (2,057 °F) showed many carbides formed from the process side and a clearly shorter range of plastic deformation, with little corrosion and no sign of creep [4].
- **Magnetism.** As chromium leaves the matrix to form carbides, the carburized metal becomes magnetic; Saori and Ohta found that the loss of matrix chromium sharply raised magnetic permeability, and that HP alloy reacted to a smaller chromium loss than HK-40 [2].
- **Interaction with creep.** In ethylene heater tests, alloys were judged by both creep growth and carburization [3]. In a 2018 reformer tube failure in Japan, the lessons drawn included that carburized and coked inner surfaces change both thermal stress and creep damage [6].
- **A severe form.** Metal dusting, which a 2011 review calls a catastrophic kind of carburization, breaks metal down into dust and leaves pits [7].

## Which alloys resist it?

More chromium and silicon raise carburization resistance, with chromium doing most to keep the oxide film tight and adherent [2]. Tungsten, molybdenum and niobium also help, because they stay in the chromium-depleted layer below the surface and lower how much carbon it can dissolve [2].

Cast HK-40 (0.4C-25Cr-20Ni) has been widely used for ethylene cracking tubes, alongside HP-type alloy (0.5C-25Cr-35Ni) [2][3]. Newer 0.4C-35Cr-45Ni-Nb alloy is described as highly resistant to carburization and metal dusting [4]. A 1998 field test compared six centrifugally cast alloys in an ethylene pyrolysis heater, plus an aluminized tube in a second heater [3].

## How is carburization found?

Because carburized metal turns magnetic, field surveys use electromagnetic methods [2][8]. A 1994 study used a multi-coil electromagnetic induction detector to gauge, without removing the tubes, how far carburization had penetrated the walls of ethylene furnace tubes, and found that it could give misleading readings when the whole wall was carburized [8]. The authors therefore added a variable-frequency metal sorting instrument, dimension and thickness measurements, visual inspection and surface replicas to the field procedure [8]. Metallography and mechanical tests on removed tubes give a direct measure of carbide formation and ductility loss [4].

## Where integrity problems show up

| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ethylene cracking furnace radiant coils and fittings | Coke on the inner wall at very high wall temperatures [1][4] | Electromagnetic surveys of carburized depth, with thickness, dimension, visual and replica checks [8] | [What is a petrochemical plant?](/library/petrochemical-plant/) |
| Cast heat-resistant tubes where the oxide scale has spalled | Carbon reaches bare metal and forms chromium carbides [2] | Rise in magnetic permeability of the carburized layer [2] | [What are the main non-destructive testing (NDT) methods in oil and gas?](/library/ndt-methods-overview/) |
| Fully carburized tube walls | Carburization through the whole wall [8] | Electromagnetic readings can mislead; dimension and thickness checks and replicas added [8] | [How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work?](/library/ultrasonic-thickness-measurement/) |
| Steam reformer tubes in hydrogen plants | Carburized and coked inner surfaces add thermal stress and creep damage [6] | Full-length eddy current with laser deformation measurement [6] | [What is creep damage?](/library/creep/) |
| Coils retired after a set service period | Carbides and ductility loss after years at temperature [4] | Metallography and mechanical tests on removed tubes [4] | [Remaining life](/glossary/remaining-life/) |

Sources: DOE, 2004 [1]; Saori and Ohta [2]; Orlikowski and others, 2021 [4]; HIAD record of the 2018 KHK case [6]; Lin and others, 1994 [8].

## Sources

1. [Impacts of Condition Assessment on Energy Use: Selected Applications in Chemicals Processing and Petroleum Refining (J. L. Pellegrino, T. M. Carole), US Department of Energy, Industrial Technologies Program (prepared by Energetics Inc.)](https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2013/11/f4/condition_assessment.pdf)
2. [Carburization and its prevention in ethylene cracking furnace tubes (M. Saori, S. Ohta), TMS Paper Selection vol. 56 (record and abstract), US DOE Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)](https://www.osti.gov/biblio/5393467)
3. [Comparative performance of six cast tube alloys in an ethylene pyrolysis test heater (D. E. Hendrix), Corrosion 98 conference (record and abstract), US DOE Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)](https://www.osti.gov/biblio/352590)
4. [Investigation of the 0.4C-35Cr-45Ni-Nb Alloy after Service in High-Temperature Steam and Hydrocarbons Environment (J. Orlikowski and others), Materials 14(20):6139, MDPI, via PubMed Central (open access, CC BY 4.0)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8541315/), 2021-10-15
5. [Diffusion (Teaching and Learning Package), University of Cambridge, DoITPoMS](https://www.doitpoms.ac.uk/tlplib/diffusion/printall.php)
6. [Process gases leak in a reformer tube (HIAD 2.0 incident record, based on KHK accident database incident 2018-428), Clean Hydrogen Partnership, Clean Hydrogen Knowledge Hub (European Union)](https://knowledge.clean-hydrogen.europa.eu/hiad/incidents/process-gases-leak-reformer-tube)
7. [Metal Dusting Protective Coatings. A Literature Review (A. Agüero and others), Oxidation of Metals 76: 23-42 (repository record and abstract), INTA (Spanish National Institute for Aerospace Technology) institutional repository](https://digital.inta.es/entities/publication/745707a8-e334-4d89-b9f4-b41d72c1dbcc/full), 2011-03-20
8. [The field measurement of carburization and oxidation of ethylene furnace tubes by multi-technique method (J. Y. Lin, F. C. Chiang, H. Chang, C. C. Su) (record and abstract), US DOE Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)](https://www.osti.gov/biblio/70110)

Published by Winda Beacon (https://beacon.winda.ai).
