# What is creep damage?

> Creep damage is slow, permanent deformation and cracking of metal held under load at high temperature, even at stresses below the yield strength. Over time, cavities form at grain boundaries, link into cracks, and the part bulges or ruptures. API RP 571 describes refinery damage mechanisms; API Std 530 covers the wall thickness of fired heater tubes.

- Label: Fact
- Type: Explainer
- Published: 2026-11-13T09:26:54+09:00
- By: Jun Zhong
- Researched and drafted by: Beacon's AI newsroom
- Checked by: Jun Zhong on 2026-11-13
- Topics: Refining
- Canonical: https://beacon.winda.ai/library/creep/

## Why does it matter?

On 18 August 2018, process gas leaked from a cracked reformer tube in the hydrogen production unit of a refinery in Japan, and three more tubes were found damaged [1]. The wall around the leak had not thinned; examiners found bulging and intergranular cracks growing from the inner surface, and the case record classes the failure mode as creep [1]. Earlier inspections had relied on visual, dimensional and wall thickness checks plus destructive tests, and none had shown the damage building up [1]. The record comes from the accident database of Japan's High Pressure Gas Safety Institute (KHK), summarized in the European hydrogen incident database (HIAD) [1].

## How does creep damage metal?

Below its yield strength, a metal normally springs back when the load comes off. Once it is hotter than roughly 0.4 of its absolute melting temperature, atoms move fast enough that the metal keeps deforming slowly under a steady load, and that time-dependent deformation is creep [2]. Higher temperature and higher stress both speed it up [2]. Lead creeps noticeably at room temperature for this reason, while nickel does not [2].

Under a constant load, creep strain usually grows in three stages. In primary creep the rate falls, in secondary creep it is roughly steady, and in tertiary creep it rises toward rupture, often as cavities open inside the metal [2]. Grain boundaries are fast diffusion paths and weak points under creep, and every crack in the 2018 reformer tube ran along grain boundaries [2][1].

This is why design changes in the creep range. The US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) notes that below it, the bursting pressure of a vessel tracks the tensile strength of its steel, while above it strength also depends on how long the load acts [3]. Fired heater tubes are therefore sized for a design metal temperature: the new tubes in a heater at Martinez, California, had a design temperature of 1,120 °F (604 °C) and normally ran up to 780 °F (416 °C) [4].

## Where does creep occur in oil and gas plants?

- **Fired heater tubes.** The tube wall is sized to hold the process pressure up to a design temperature, using API Std 530 (7th edition, April 2015, with addenda in 2019 and 2021); the standard includes an annex describing a way to estimate a heater tube's remaining life [4][7]. API RP 573 (4th edition, 2021) covers inspection of fired boilers and heaters [7].
- **Steam reformer tubes in hydrogen plants.** In the 2018 case, the temperature difference between the inner and outer surfaces created large thermal stresses, and each start-up and shutdown added creep damage [1].
- **Ethylene cracking furnace coils.** A 1998 field test of six centrifugally cast tube alloys in an ethylene pyrolysis heater was started because standard HP-40 radiant tubes showed unusually high creep growth [5].
- **Boiler superheater tubes.** Long-term overheating, also called creep, is a more common boiler tube failure than short-term overheating [8].

## What makes creep damage faster?

- **Temperature.** Creep rates follow the speed of diffusion, which climbs steeply as temperature rises [2].
- **Stress.** Internal pressure is one source; through-wall thermal stress was the dominant one in the 2018 reformer tubes [1].
- **Deposits inside the tube.** Coke insulates ethylene furnace tubes, so firing rises until the tube wall temperature reaches its limit [6]. The KHK lessons add that coke, oxide and carburized layers on the inner surface change both thermal stress and creep damage [1].
- **Scale and metal loss.** The UK National Physical Laboratory (NPL) notes that thick scale and metal loss lead to overheating [9].
- **Uncertain material data.** In the 2018 case, the creep data for the tube alloy belonged to the maker and were not public [1].

## How is creep damage found?

Creep damage can be hard to detect. After the 2018 leak, the KHK lessons were that sampling inspections had missed the damage and that full-length, full-coverage non-destructive examination improves remaining-life estimates; the plant moved to full-length eddy current measurement combined with laser measurement of tube deformation [1].

- **Tube metal temperature.** Thermocouples attached to the outside of heater tubes measure metal temperature in service; infrared cameras give an estimate but need suitable equipment and training [4].
- **Growth and bulging.** Creep growth of tubes and bulging are direct signs of accumulated strain [5][1].
- **Microstructure.** Metallographic examination of removed tubes shows intergranular cracks and an aged structure [1][5].
- **Remaining life.** API Std 530 describes a remaining-life technique for heater tubes [7]; see [What is fitness-for-service (API 579-1/ASME FFS-1)?](/library/fitness-for-service/).

## Where integrity problems show up

| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fired heater radiant and convection tubes | Tube metal temperature near or above design for long periods [4] | Tube metal thermocouples and infrared scans in service [4] | What is a fired heater? |
| Steam reformer tubes in hydrogen plants | Through-wall thermal stress, start-up and shutdown cycles, coke or carburized inner layers [1] | Full-length eddy current with laser deformation measurement; thickness checks alone missed it [1] | What are the main non-destructive testing (NDT) methods in oil and gas? |
| Ethylene cracking furnace coils | Very high coil temperatures, coke and carburization [5][6] | Creep growth and microstructure of removed tubes [5] | [What is a petrochemical plant?](/library/petrochemical-plant/) |
| Tubes thinned by oxidation or corrosion | Thick scale and metal loss raise metal temperature [9] | Wall thickness readings, which did not reveal creep in the 2018 case [1] | [How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work?](/library/ultrasonic-thickness-measurement/) |

Sources: HIAD record of the 2018 KHK case [1]; CSB, 2025 [4]; Hendrix, 1998 [5]; DOE, 2004 [6]; NPL, 2020 [9].

## Sources

1. [Process gases leak in a reformer tube (HIAD 2.0 incident record, based on KHK accident database incident 2018-428), Clean Hydrogen Partnership, Clean Hydrogen Knowledge Hub (European Union)](https://knowledge.clean-hydrogen.europa.eu/hiad/incidents/process-gases-leak-reformer-tube)
2. [Creep Deformation of Metals (Teaching and Learning Package), University of Cambridge, DoITPoMS](https://www.doitpoms.ac.uk/tlplib/creep/printall.php)
3. [NIST Special Publication 780, Guidelines for Pressure Vessel Safety Assessment (S. Yukawa), US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)](https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/Legacy/SP/nistspecialpublication780.pdf)
4. [Investigation Report: Fired Heater Tube Rupture and Fire at Marathon Martinez Renewables Facility, Martinez, CA (No. 2024-01-I-CA), US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)](https://www.csb.gov/assets/1/6/Marathon_Martinez_2025-03-12_ForPublication.pdf)
5. [Comparative performance of six cast tube alloys in an ethylene pyrolysis test heater (D. E. Hendrix), Corrosion 98 conference (record and abstract), US Department of Energy, Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)](https://www.osti.gov/biblio/352590)
6. [Impacts of Condition Assessment on Energy Use: Selected Applications in Chemicals Processing and Petroleum Refining (J. L. Pellegrino, T. M. Carole), US Department of Energy, Industrial Technologies Program (prepared by Energetics Inc.)](https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2013/11/f4/condition_assessment.pdf)
7. [2025 Publications Catalog (entries for RP 571, Std 530 and RP 573) (RP 571, 3rd edition, March 2020; Std 530, 7th edition, April 2015 (with Addendum 1, July 2019, and Addendum 2, December 2021); RP 573, 4th edition, 2021), American Petroleum Institute (API)](https://www.api.org/-/media/files/publications/2025-catalog/2025_pubs%20catalog.pdf)
8. [Over-attemperation and Short-term Overheating in Pendant-type Superheaters (N. Basson, W. F. Fuls), R&D Journal of the South African Institution of Mechanical Engineering 37, 58-69, South African Institution of Mechanical Engineering (open access, CC BY 4.0)](https://rdj.journals.ac.za/index.php/pub/article/view/21)
9. [Corrosion control checklist (Guides to Good Practice in Corrosion Control No. 11), UK National Physical Laboratory (NPL)](https://eprintspublications.npl.co.uk/8621/)

Published by Winda Beacon (https://beacon.winda.ai).
