# How are unpiggable pipelines inspected?

> Unpiggable pipelines are lines that cannot take a conventional, flow-driven in-line inspection tool because of their design or operating conditions. They are assessed instead by pressure testing, direct assessment with excavations, guided wave testing over short lengths, or robotic and tethered in-line tools. For US gas transmission lines, 49 CFR 192.921 lists the allowed methods.

- Label: Fact
- Type: Explainer
- Published: 2026-11-14T12:02:06+09:00
- By: Jun Zhong
- Researched and drafted by: Beacon's AI newsroom
- Checked by: Jun Zhong on 2026-11-14
- Topics: Pipelines, Upstream and offshore
- Canonical: https://beacon.winda.ai/library/unpiggable-pipelines/

## Why does it matter?

From 2010 to 2013, in-line inspection (ILI) covered 96% of the assessed mileage of US interstate gas transmission pipelines but only 68% of intrastate mileage, where direct assessment made up 17% against 2% for interstate lines [1]. The US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found direct assessment the weaker method: it addresses corrosion only, examines short sub-segments chosen by the operator and finds far fewer anomalies than ILI [1]. Of five incidents in high consequence areas from 2010 to 2013 that an integrity assessment should have caught, four were on segments assessed by direct assessment, and three of those four had causes other than corrosion [1].

## What makes a pipeline unpiggable?

A conventional smart pig needs a launcher and a receiver, special arrangements of pipes and valves where the tool is loaded and removed, and enough product flow to push it [2]. Lines fall short of this in three ways.

- **Design.** US rules require new and replaced transmission lines to pass instrumented inspection devices, but exempt manifolds, station piping, cross-overs, some offshore lines and pipe sizes for which no tool is commercially available [4]. Lines can also contain internal obstructions such as plug valves, and mitered bends, which robotic tools have been designed to pass [6][7].
- **Operation.** Even where a tool fits, the NTSB lists low pressure, low or no flow, excess debris, scale or wax, and incompatible product as complications that keep operators from running ILI [1]. An industry association cited by the NTSB states that many intrastate lines are their customers' only gas source and cannot be shut down without cutting off supply [1].
- **Setting.** Intrastate lines tend to run through denser urban areas and connect closely to distribution systems, which the NTSB links to their lower ILI use [1]. Offshore, a 2003 report for the US Minerals Management Service (MMS) cited an estimate that only 6% of about 35,000 miles of Gulf of Mexico pipelines, risers included, were piggable [8].

## Which methods are used instead?

| Method | What it covers | Main limits | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pressure test (hydrostatic or spike) | The whole segment; critical seam, corrosion and crack defects are found by making them fail at test pressure | The line comes out of service and is filled with water | [1][3] |
| External corrosion direct assessment (ECDA) | External corrosion: preassessment, at least two complementary above-ground surveys, excavation and direct examination, then post-assessment | Corrosion only; only the excavated spots are examined directly | [1][3] |
| Internal corrosion direct assessment (ICDA) | Internal corrosion where water or other electrolyte would collect, with excavations at the likeliest spots | The dry gas process applies only to normally dry gas; other lines need a separately demonstrated plan | [3] |
| Stress corrosion cracking direct assessment (SCCDA) | Stress corrosion cracking, from excavation data on pipe in similar conditions | Complements ILI or spike testing rather than always replacing them | [3] |
| Excavation and direct examination | Any threat at the dug-up spot, using ultrasonic, phased array, radiographic or magnetic particle methods | Only where the pipe is exposed | [3] |
| Guided wave ultrasonic testing (GWUT) | Internal and external wall loss over roughly 60 to 100 feet from one position, including cased crossings | Detection threshold of 5% of cross-sectional area; not for shorted casings; indications above it need follow-up | [3][5] |
| Robotic and tethered in-line tools | Self-powered robots carrying magnetic flux leakage or remote field eddy current sensors, launched into live lines through hot taps | Short range per launch site; must meet the applicable parts of NACE SP0102 | [4][6][7] |

US rules also allow "other technology" that gives an equivalent understanding of pipe condition, with advance notice to the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) [3].

## How can a line be made piggable?

- **By design rules.** New and replaced gas transmission pipe must be built to pass instrumented inspection devices in line with NACE SP0102, unless an exemption applies or PHMSA accepts an impracticability petition [4].
- **By reconfiguration.** In 2015 the NTSB recommended that PHMSA require all gas transmission pipelines to be capable of ILI, by reconfiguring them or by new technology, with priority to the highest-risk lines by age, pressure, diameter and class location [1].
- **By new tools.** A research program begun by an industry research group in 2001, with PHMSA co-funding from 2004, produced two robotic platforms, commercialized by 2013: one for 6 and 8 inch lines with a remote field eddy current sensor, and one for 20 to 26 inch lines with a magnetic flux leakage sensor that can negotiate plug valves and mitered bends [6][7]. The smaller robot had a maximum range of 0.6 mile per launch site and a maximum operating pressure of 750 psig [6]. The program's final report states that modifying unpiggable lines was prohibitively expensive in most cases [6].

## Where integrity problems show up

| What it finds well | What it can miss or get wrong | In the Library |
|---|---|---|
| ECDA: coating damage and external corrosion at indications from above-ground surveys [1][3] | Threats other than corrosion, and pipe between excavations; three of four incident segments assessed this way failed from other causes [1] | [What is direct assessment (ECDA, ICDA, SCCDA)?](/library/direct-assessment/), [Coating holiday](/glossary/coating-holiday/) |
| ICDA: internal corrosion where water would first collect in normally dry gas [3] | Lines with water normally present, which fall outside the dry gas process [3] | [What is carbon dioxide (CO2) corrosion?](/library/co2-corrosion/) |
| GWUT: wall loss over tens of feet, including inside casings [5] | Loss below 5% of cross-sectional area, and pipe in shorted casings [5] | [Guided wave testing](/glossary/guided-wave-testing/) |
| SCCDA: cracking at excavations in pipe with similar conditions [3] | Cracks elsewhere in the segment; the rule treats SCCDA as complementary to ILI or spike tests [3] | [What is stress corrosion cracking in pipelines (high-pH and near-neutral pH)?](/library/pipeline-stress-corrosion-cracking/) |
| Robotic ILI: wall loss data along live lines with plug valves and mitered bends [6][7] | Long runs, given the short range per launch site [6] | [What types of in-line inspection tools are there (MFL, UT, EMAT, geometry)?](/library/smart-pig-types/) |

Sources: NTSB Safety Study SS-15/01, 2015 [1]; 49 CFR 192.921 to 192.929 [3]; 49 CFR 192 Appendix F [5]; PHMSA-funded robotics final report, 2013 [6].

## Sources

1. [Integrity Management of Gas Transmission Pipelines in High Consequence Areas, Safety Study NTSB/SS-15/01, US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)](https://www.ntsb.gov/safety/safety-studies/Documents/SS1501.pdf)
2. [Fact Sheet: In-Line Inspections (Smart Pig), US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)](https://primis.phmsa.dot.gov/stakeholder-comms/factsheets/fssmartpig)
3. [49 CFR 192.921 (baseline assessment methods), 192.925 (ECDA), 192.927 (ICDA) and 192.929 (SCCDA), eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-49/section-192.921)
4. [49 CFR 192.150 and 195.120 (passage of internal inspection devices) and 192.493 (in-line inspection of pipelines), eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-49/section-192.150)
5. [49 CFR Part 192, Appendix F, Criteria for Conducting Integrity Assessments Using Guided Wave Ultrasonic Testing (GWUT), eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register](https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-49/part-192/appendix-Appendix%20F%20to%20Part%20192)
6. [Completion of Development of Robotics Systems for Inspecting Unpiggable Transmission Pipelines, final public report, contract DTPH56-10-T-000008 (D. D'Zurko), NYSEARCH/Northeast Gas Association, for the US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) research program](https://primis.phmsa.dot.gov/rd/FileGet/7935/NYSEARCH-DoT-_robotics-final-report_-PUBLIC-022013.pdf), 2013-02-19
7. [Completion of Development of Robotics Systems for Inspecting Unpiggable Transmission Pipelines (research project page, project 353), US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), Research and Development](https://primis.phmsa.dot.gov/rd/projects/353)
8. [Evaluation of Methods for Detecting and Monitoring of Corrosion and Fatigue Damage in Risers (M. Lozev, B. Grimmett, E. Shell, R. Spencer), final report, Technical Assessment Program project 433, US Minerals Management Service (now Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement, BSEE)](https://www.bsee.gov/sites/bsee.gov/files/tap-technical-assessment-program//433aa.pdf), 2003-11-04

Published by Winda Beacon (https://beacon.winda.ai).
