# Conventional UT vs phased array (PAUT) vs time-of-flight diffraction (TOFD)

> Conventional UT, phased array UT (PAUT) and time-of-flight diffraction (TOFD) are ultrasonic weld tests that differ in how they find and size flaws. Conventional UT sweeps one fixed-angle beam by hand; PAUT steers many beams from one multi-element probe and stores images; TOFD times sound diffracted from flaw tips, which sizes flaw height closely.

- Label: Fact
- Type: Explainer
- Published: 2026-11-13T15:24:40+09:00
- By: Jun Zhong
- Researched and drafted by: Beacon's AI newsroom
- Checked by: Jun Zhong on 2026-11-13
- Topics: LNG, Pipelines, Refining, Upstream and offshore
- Canonical: https://beacon.winda.ai/library/ut-vs-paut-vs-tofd/

## Why does it matter?

In a UK case described by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), mechanized ultrasonic inspection of site-built liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) vessels sized a weld flaw at 4 mm high, against a largest tolerable flaw of 6 mm [1]. The sizing accuracy of that inspection was about ±2 mm, so the flaw could already have been at the limit, and no allowance for the error had been built into the acceptance criteria [1]. How a technique sizes a flaw, not only whether it finds it, is the main difference between the three methods on this page [1][2].

## Conventional UT vs PAUT vs TOFD at a glance

| | Conventional UT | Phased array (PAUT) | TOFD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Probe set-up | One element on an angled wedge, moved over the surface by hand [6] | One probe with usually 32 to 128 elements, fired with timed delays to steer and focus the beam [3] | Two probes, a transmitter and a receiver, scanned as a pair either side of the weld [1][2] |
| How a flaw shows | An echo reflected back to the probe [6] | Echoes from a range of angles, shown as sector, B-scan and C-scan images [3] | Signals diffracted from the top and bottom tips of a flaw, between a surface wave and the back-wall echo [2] |
| Basis of height sizing | Echo amplitude compared with a reference reflector [3][5] | Mostly amplitude, checked from several angles [3][4] | Time difference between tip signals; about 1 mm for sharp internal flaws [2] |
| Record | None in basic form [7] | Stored data when used with a position encoder [3] | Stored image along the weld [1] |
| Coverage | Hand raster scan; flaws close together can be missed [4] | Sector and linear scans; thick welds needed at least two probe positions from each side in FHWA tests [3][4] | Fast line scan; more probe spacings needed as thickness rises [1] |
| Known weak spots | Flaws skewed to the beam [5] | Large flaws tend to be undersized by amplitude [3] | The region just below the scanning surface needs another technique [1] |
| Operator skill | Method certification by level [1] | Training beyond conventional UT [1][4] | Skilled operators; set-up optimized for the defects of concern [1] |

Sources: HSE COMAH technical measures document [1]; MMS riser study, 2003 [2]; FHWA-HRT-14-074 and 14-075, 2014 [3][4]; FHWA-HRT-04-124, 2005 [5].

## When is conventional UT used?

- **Manual weld examination.** A straight beam first checks the plate beside the weld for laminations, which an angled beam may not return a signal from; an angle beam then covers the root, sidewalls, cap and heat-affected zone [6].
- **Code acceptance by amplitude and length.** The US bridge welding code rates each indication by its echo height against a 1.5 mm side-drilled hole and by its length, using 45, 60 or 70 degree probes [5].
- **Wall thickness.** An ultrasonic reading measures remaining wall at one point, so the positions are chosen to suit the expected corrosion, and corrosion mapping scans extend the readings over an area [1][2]; see [How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work?](/library/ultrasonic-thickness-measurement/).

## When is PAUT used?

- **Weld volume from few probe positions.** One probe sweeps a fan of angles; in mechanized pipeline girth weld inspection, two array probes can replace 12 to 24 single-element probes in one pass [2].
- **Where a permanent record is wanted.** With an encoder, PAUT data can be stored and reviewed later, which FHWA notes was not possible with conventional UT [3].
- **Corrosion mapping.** Array probes, manual or automated, map wall loss in detail [2]. See [Phased array ultrasonic testing](/glossary/phased-array-ultrasonic-testing/).

In FHWA tests on bridge butt welds, PAUT found flaws that the fabricators' conventional UT had missed and placed flaws where radiographs showed them [4].

## When is TOFD used?

- **Weld inspection in process plant.** HSE notes that TOFD is quick compared with manual pulse-echo work, gives a hard-copy image and was replacing radiography as a preferred weld method [1].

TOFD signals from crack tips are weak, so sensitivity must be set high, which can lead to false calls [1]. In 2014, FHWA reported mixed views among experts on TOFD for bridge welds, while the US Navy had used it on thick steel pipe [4].

## Is automated UT a separate technique?

No. Automated or mechanized UT (AUT) describes how probes are moved and data recorded, not a new physics. The MMS riser study describes AUT built from single-element probes, phased array probes or both, often with TOFD channels [2]. Once a procedure is tuned, it called AUT very reliable and repeatable [2].

A second mix-up is treating echo amplitude as flaw size. FHWA notes that amplitude also depends on flaw orientation, roughness and shape, and that a flaw skewed 10 degrees from the beam can lose more than 10 dB at the 2.25 MHz frequency typical of code work [5].

## Where integrity problems show up

| What it finds well | What it can miss or get wrong | In the Library |
|---|---|---|
| Lack of fusion, cracks and porosity in thick butt welds, with PAUT from both sides [3][4] | Flaws outside the scan plan; large flaws undersized by amplitude [3][4] | [Phased array ultrasonic testing](/glossary/phased-array-ultrasonic-testing/) |
| Height of planar flaws to about 1 mm, and their growth between inspections, with TOFD [2] | Flaws just below the scanning surface, unless another technique covers that region [1] | How are crack-like flaws assessed for fitness-for-service? |
| Weld flaws facing the beam, in manual UT [5][6] | Skewed flaws; in one study, vertical cracks up to 40% of plate thickness could be accepted in nearly a third of inspections [5] | [Ultrasonic testing](/glossary/ultrasonic-testing/) |
| Flaws in site-built LPG vessel welds, sized by mechanized UT [1] | A sizing error of about ±2 mm left out of the acceptance decision [1] | [What is fitness-for-service (API 579-1/ASME FFS-1)?](/library/fitness-for-service/) |
| Welds in fine-grained ferritic steel [1] | Coarse-grained austenitic and nickel alloy welds without special techniques [1] | [What are corrosion-resistant alloys (CRAs)?](/library/corrosion-resistant-alloys/) |

Sources: HSE COMAH technical measures document [1]; MMS riser study, 2003 [2]; FHWA-HRT-14-074, 14-075 and 04-124 [3][4][5].

## Sources

1. [Inspection/Non Destructive Testing (COMAH technical measures document), UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)](https://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasndt.htm)
2. [Evaluation of Methods for Detecting and Monitoring of Corrosion and Fatigue Damage in Risers (M. Lozev, B. Grimmett, E. Shell, R. Spencer), Technical Assessment Program project 433, US Minerals Management Service (now Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement, BSEE)](https://www.bsee.gov/sites/bsee.gov/files/tap-technical-assessment-program//433aa.pdf), 2003-11-04
3. [Development of Phased-Array Ultrasonic Testing Acceptability Criteria (Phase I), TechBrief FHWA-HRT-14-074, US Federal Highway Administration (FHWA)](https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/research/infrastructure/structures/bridge/14074/index.cfm)
4. [Development of Phased-Array Ultrasonic Testing Acceptability Criteria (Phase II), TechBrief FHWA-HRT-14-075, US Federal Highway Administration (FHWA)](https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/research/infrastructure/structures/bridge/14075/index.cfm)
5. [Lab and Field Testing of AUT Systems for Steel Highway Bridges (FHWA-HRT-04-124), Chapter 2: Background, US Federal Highway Administration (FHWA)](https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/research/infrastructure/structures/04124/02.cfm)
6. [Ultrasonic testing: Weldments (Welded Joints) and Angle Beams (NDE-Ed), Iowa State University, Center for Nondestructive Evaluation](https://www.nde-ed.org/NDETechniques/Ultrasonics/SelectedApps/weldments.xhtml)
7. [OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines, US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)](https://www.osha.gov/otm/section-4-safety-hazards/chapter-3)

Published by Winda Beacon (https://beacon.winda.ai).
