Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactAsset Integrity Management · Pipeline integrity

ASME B31G vs RSTRENG: how is corroded pipe assessed?

·9 sources

Short answer

ASME B31G and RSTRENG both predict the pressure at which corroded pipe would fail; B31G uses maximum depth and length, RSTRENG the depth profile. A 2009 review for the US pipeline regulator, PHMSA, found RSTRENG the more accurate against burst tests. US pipeline rules (49 CFR 192.712, 195.452) accept both.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

Two methods accepted by US rules can give the same corrosion patch different failure pressures, and that number decides whether pipe is repaired, run at lower pressure or left in service 3,6. A 2009 review for the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) compared the methods with recorded burst tests 1. Using actual material properties, the methods based only on depth and length became more likely to overpredict failure pressure as corrosion got deeper; using specified minimum properties and a safety factor, all of them gave safe operating pressures below every recorded burst pressure 1. Under 49 CFR 192.933, a predicted failure pressure at or below 1.1 times the maximum allowable operating pressure (MAOP) makes a gas pipeline metal loss anomaly an immediate repair condition 6.

ASME B31G vs RSTRENG at a glance

Modified B31G sits between the two. It came from the same 1989 research project as RSTRENG but, like the original B31G, needs only depth and length 1,2.

ASME B31G (original)Modified B31GRSTRENG (effective area)
What it isASME manual for evaluating metal loss in pressurized pipelines and piping 7Revised depth-and-length criterion from American Gas Association (AGA) project PR-3-805, 1989 1,2Profile-based method and software from the same AGA project 2,4
Corrosion inputMaximum depth and overall axial length 1Maximum depth and overall axial length 1Depth or remaining-wall readings at even spacing along the pipe axis, a "river bottom" profile 1,2
How the shape is treatedReplaced by an idealized curved area for short flaws and a more conservative assumption for long ones 1One shape assumption for all lengths, with revised strength and bulging terms; less conservative overall than the original 1,2Failure pressure is calculated for every sub-length of the profile and the lowest value kept 1
Accuracy against burst tests (2009 review)More likely to overpredict as depth increases, with actual properties 1Same trend as B31G 1Least scatter of the methods reviewed 1
Typical useScreening and ranking in-line inspection calls 1Ranking calls when only length and maximum depth are reported 1Detailed assessment when an accurate profile exists 1
Edition named in US rulesASME/ANSI B31G-1991, reaffirmed 2004 4Not named separatelyPR-3-805, 22 December 1989 4
Current publisher edition2023, on stabilized maintenance 7Not applicable1989 report 4

Sources: PHMSA review (2009) 1; Kiefner and Vieth (1990) 2; 49 CFR 192.7 and 195.3 4; ASME product page 7.

When is ASME B31G used?

  • To screen and rank anomalies after an in-line inspection. The 2009 review concluded that B31G and Modified B31G can continue to serve this purpose 1.
  • When only overall length and maximum depth are known, as in many inspection summaries 1.
  • To calculate temporary pressure reductions. For liquid lines in high consequence areas, 49 CFR 195.452(h) requires the reduction to be calculated with the referenced methods, which include B31G and RSTRENG 5.
  • Beyond pipelines. ASME states that the manual applies to piping systems within the B31 code family, including B31.4, B31.8, B31.11 and the pipeline part of B31.12 7.

When is RSTRENG used?

  • When the corroded area has been profiled, for example by depth readings taken at regular intervals in the ditch 2.
  • To remove excess conservatism. Its developers described the original B31G as overconservative and built RSTRENG and the modified criterion to bring predictions closer to burst test results 2.
  • For higher-strength pipe. The 2009 review suggested RSTRENG for grades above X65 because, with specified minimum properties, its predictions stayed below recorded failure pressures for machined defects in pipe up to grade X100 1.

Its developers found it better at predicting ruptures than leaks, which the 2009 review links to the underlying equation not working well for very deep defects 1.

What do both methods leave out?

  • Cracks and dents. 49 CFR 192.712 lists B31G and RSTRENG for corrosion metal loss only; dents and mechanical damage need an engineering critical assessment, and cracks need a fracture mechanics model 3.
  • Uncertainty in the inputs. The same section requires operators to account for tool tolerance, detection threshold, probability of detection and sizing accuracy unless the flaw was measured directly 3.
  • Missing records. Pipe properties must come from traceable, verifiable and complete records; otherwise conservative defaults apply, such as assuming Grade A pipe (30,000 psi) 3.
  • Closely spaced flaws. The original B31G had no rule for interaction between nearby anomalies 2.
  • Modern steels. The test database behind B31G, Modified B31G and RSTRENG was dominated by older, lower-strength, lower-toughness steels 1.

Gas transmission rules also send the result back to the pipe: where corrosion leaves less wall than the MAOP needs, the pipe must be repaired, replaced or run at lower pressure, with strength determined under 192.712 9.

Where integrity problems show up

DecisionData it depends onWhat goes wrong without it
Which flaw depth goes into the calculationInspection sizing plus the tool's stated tolerance, or a field measurementMarshall, Michigan, 2010: crack depths from a 2005 inspection were used as reported, without the tool tolerance; NTSB noted this can put predicted failure pressure above the actual one, so defects are not dug 8
Which wall thickness and strength to useTraceable, verifiable and complete pipe recordsSame case: using a tool-reported wall of 0.285 inch instead of the 0.25 inch nominal wall added about 14% to the segment's pressure rating 8
Which method fits the flawAnomaly type from inspection and digsCorrosion methods do not cover dents or cracks; 192.712 requires separate analyses for them 3
Repair, reduce pressure or monitorPredicted failure pressure compared with MAOP or maximum operating pressureGas: at or below 1.1 times MAOP is an immediate repair condition 6. Liquid: a predicted burst pressure below maximum operating pressure is immediate 5
Whether nearby pits act as one flawSpacing of corrosion featuresTreating separate pits as one area is overly conservative; treating them apart may be nonconservative 2

Sources: NTSB PAR-12/01 (2012) 8; 49 CFR 192.712, 192.933, 195.452 3,5,6; Kiefner and Vieth (1990) 2.

Common questions

Is RSTRENG the same as Modified B31G?
No. Both came out of AGA project PR-3-805 in 1989. Modified B31G still works from maximum depth and length, while RSTRENG works through the measured profile.
Which edition of B31G do US rules reference?
ASME/ANSI B31G-1991, reaffirmed 2004, incorporated by reference in 49 CFR 192.7 and 195.3. ASME's own listing shows a 2023 edition.
Is a predicted failure pressure the same as a safe operating pressure?
No. The 2009 review separates the best-estimate failure pressure from a safe operating pressure calculated with specified minimum properties, nominal dimensions and a safety factor. See [Burst pressure](/library/burst-pressure) and [Remaining strength factor](/library/remaining-strength-factor).
Can an operator use a different method?
Yes, if it is equally conservative. A method that could give less conservative results needs advance notice to PHMSA, including comparisons with RSTRENG or B31G and the burst tests used.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.A Review of Methods for Assessing the Remaining Strength of Corroded Pipelines, Report 6781, Issue 6.1 (V. Chauhan, J. Brister), prepared for PHMSA under DTPH56-05-T0003, Project 153 · GL Industrial Services for the US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)
  2. 2.Evaluating pipe, conclusion: PC program speeds new criterion for evaluating corroded pipe (J. F. Kiefner, P. H. Vieth) · Oil & Gas Journal ·
  3. 3.49 CFR 192.712, Analysis of predicted failure pressure and critical strain level · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  4. 4.49 CFR 192.7 and 195.3, What documents are incorporated by reference · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  5. 5.49 CFR 195.452, Pipeline integrity management in high consequence areas · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  6. 6.49 CFR 192.933, What actions must be taken to address integrity issues? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  7. 7.B31G, Manual for Determining the Remaining Strength of Corroded Pipelines (product page) (2023 edition listed (editions 2009, 2012 and 2023 shown); placed on stabilized maintenance) · American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME)
  8. 8.Pipeline Accident Report NTSB/PAR-12/01: Enbridge Incorporated Hazardous Liquid Pipeline Rupture and Release, Marshall, Michigan, July 25, 2010 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ·
  9. 9.49 CFR 192.485, Remedial measures: Transmission lines · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register