What is hydrogen permeation monitoring?
Hydrogen permeation monitoring measures the atomic hydrogen diffusing out through a steel wall, using a hydrogen probe fixed to the outer surface. The hydrogen comes from corrosion or cathodic protection on the other side, and its flux shows how strongly the steel is being charged. ASTM G148 covers the electrochemical permeation technique behind many probes.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
A hydrogen probe that reads little or no flux does not prove the wall is free of hydrogen damage. A 2001 Nordtest report explains that hydrogen collecting in an internal lamination can stay there, building pressure and growing blisters, while little or none reaches the outer surface; it advises checking the wall ultrasonically where each probe sits 1. This matters most in wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S) service. The US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) describes hydrogen from water and H2S entering steel and causing cracking, blistering and embrittlement, with small cracks able to grow stepwise into through-wall cracks 3.
How does a hydrogen probe work?
The method grew out of laboratory work in the 1960s by Devanathan and Stachurski. A thin metal membrane separates two electrochemical cells: hydrogen is generated on one face, and the other face is held at a potential that oxidizes every hydrogen atom arriving there, so the extra current equals the hydrogen flux through the membrane 1. ASTM G148 describes this technique for measuring hydrogen uptake, permeation and transport, mainly in the laboratory, and notes that adapted versions have been used in plants and in the field 2.
On equipment, the steel wall itself becomes the membrane, and the probe sits on its outer face 1. The Nordtest report describes a sealed probe with a palladium lid, an internal counter electrode and an alkaline electrolyte. When hydrogen arrives, current rises within minutes and settles within 10 to 20 minutes; 1 microampere (µA) corresponds to about 1.27 × 10⁻⁷ mL of hydrogen per second, and the usable range is 0.02 to 200 µA 1.
| Probe type | What it measures | Practical notes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clamp-on or patch electrochemical cell | Current from oxidizing hydrogen as it leaves the wall | Needs electrolyte, electrodes, potentiostat and power on site, so set-up takes time | 1 |
| Sealed electrochemical probe | The same current, from a self-contained cell | Pressed on with a seal such as an O-ring and silicone wax; steady in 10 to 20 minutes | 1 |
| Stand-off probe with sealed hood | Hydrogen gathered in a sealed space over a hot wall, with the probe kept at ambient temperature | Equilibrium takes a few hours; the report prefers a hood seal-welded during construction or an outage | 1 |
| Collection under an impermeable patch | Pressure or volume of hydrogen gathered beneath the patch | Indirect measure | 1 |
| Potentiometric or analytical methods | Hydrogen concentration, or gas analysis by chromatography or spectroscopy | Indirect measure | 1 |
The steady flux reflects the difference in hydrogen concentration across the wall and the wall's thickness, so it indicates how much diffusible hydrogen the steel holds 1. ASTM G148 also covers calculating an effective diffusivity and telling reversible from irreversible hydrogen traps 2.
Where is hydrogen permeation monitoring used?
- Sour gas pipelines. A 1998 conference paper, summarized in the US Department of Energy's OSTI database, reports that after a hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) failure on a sour gas line in September 1992, self-powered permeation devices were used to confirm that batch inhibition kept hydrogen below a laboratory threshold for HIC. The authors chose this approach because no inspection technique could then find HIC in a line of that size 4.
- Refinery vessels. The same paper reports very high hydrogen flux on a HIC-damaged refinery vessel despite polysulfide injection; the vessel was replaced 4.
- Tracking process and inhibitor changes. Nordtest describes probes left in place for up to six months to relate flux changes to inhibitor additions, temperature, flow velocity and dewatering 1.
- Laboratory ranking. ASTM G148 lists ranking how aggressive environments are and, combined with cracking tests, finding the hydrogen flux at which cracking starts 2.
- Hot hydrogen service. Stand-off probes keep the sensor cool. In field trials at two Icelandic geothermal plants, reported in 2001, they recorded no measurable flux; laboratory retests suggested internal films had cut hydrogen entry 1.
What can the readings not tell you?
- Whether cracking will occur. The flux tracks diffusible hydrogen, but its link to cracking risk depends on factors hard to measure in the field; Nordtest suggests building that link from service history or laboratory tests 1.
- Hydrogen held in traps. Laminations and blisters absorb hydrogen, lowering the flux at the surface while damage grows 1.
- Conditions a short distance away. Flux can differ between neighboring spots when corrosion is uneven, although thick walls smooth out small differences 1.
- Uptake blocked by scale. Sulfide scale on the inner surface can suppress hydrogen entry, giving no measurable flux even with H2S present 1.
- Readings straight after surface preparation. A freshly ground spot can show a peak and take 40 to 60 minutes to settle, against about 20 minutes on an unprepared surface 1.
Where integrity problems show up
| What it finds well | What it can miss or get wrong | In the Library |
|---|---|---|
| Changes in hydrogen charging after inhibitor, temperature or flow changes 1,4 | Hydrogen trapped in laminations or growing blisters, which lowers the flux reaching the probe 1 | Hydrogen blistering, Hydrogen induced cracking |
| Whether uptake stays below a laboratory threshold for cracking, as in the 1998 sour gas pipeline case 2,4 | The cracks themselves: flux does not locate or size them, so Nordtest pairs probes with ultrasonic checks before and after 1 | What is wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S) damage? |
| Very high flux on a damaged refinery vessel, before its replacement 4 | Uneven hydrogen entry away from the probe position 1 | HIC vs SOHIC vs SSC: how do hydrogen sulfide cracking forms differ? |
| Hydrogen activity on hot walls, with stand-off probes kept at ambient temperature 1 | Uptake suppressed by internal scale or films, giving no measurable flux 1 | What is high temperature hydrogen attack (HTHA)? |
Sources: Nordtest NT TR 474, 2001 1; ASTM G148 public scope page 2; Hay and Rider, 1998, OSTI abstract 4.
Common questions
- Is a hydrogen probe the same as an H2S gas detector?
- No. A permeation probe measures hydrogen leaving the steel wall, not gas concentrations in the surrounding air.
- Is ASTM G148 a field method?
- It is written mainly for laboratory use, but its scope notes that the measurements have been made in plants and in the field with suitable adaptations.
- How does this relate to hydrogen embrittlement?
- The diffusible hydrogen that the probe senses is what can embrittle or crack steel, and ASTM G148 notes that permeation data can be combined with embrittlement or cracking tests to find critical flux levels. See [What is hydrogen embrittlement?](/library/hydrogen-embrittlement/).
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Hydrogen Monitoring in Geothermal Plants and Oil and Gas Refineries (C. Christensen, FORCE Institute), NT TR 474, Nordtest project 1499-00 · Nordtest (Nordic Innovation)
- 2.ASTM G148, Standard Practice for Evaluation of Hydrogen Uptake, Permeation, and Transport in Metals by an Electrochemical Technique (product page, Scope and Significance and Use) (G148-97(2018) shown; edition not relied on) · ASTM International
- 3.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- 4.Integrity management of a HIC-damaged pipeline and refinery pressure vessel through hydrogen permeation measurements (M. G. Hay, D. W. Rider), Corrosion 98 conference, abstract record 352581 · US Department of Energy, Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI); paper published by NACE International