Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactCorrosion and Damage Mechanisms · Environmental cracking

HIC vs SOHIC vs SSC: how do hydrogen sulfide cracking forms differ?

·9 sources

Short answer

HIC, SOHIC and SSC are cracking caused by hydrogen entering steel from wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S) corrosion. Hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) needs no stress and runs parallel to the surface; stress-oriented HIC (SOHIC) stacks such cracks through the wall under stress; sulfide stress cracking (SSC) splits hard, stressed steel. NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 covers production materials.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

Steel ordered as resistant to hydrogen-induced cracking is not automatically resistant to its stress-oriented form: a 2022 review published by the US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) notes that such steel can still crack near welds and at high stress 1. The forms also combine: in the amine absorber that ruptured at Romeoville, Illinois, in 1984, killing 17 people, investigators traced cracks that began in hard metal beside a repair weld and then grew through the wall by hydrogen pressure cracking 4,9.

HIC vs SOHIC vs SSC at a glance

All three start the same way: corrosion in water containing H2S produces hydrogen atoms, and H2S keeps them from pairing up at the surface, so many enter the steel 1,2.

HICSOHICSSC
What happensHydrogen gathers at inclusions, forms gas, and gas pressure opens cracks 1Small HIC-type cracks form in stacks and link through the wall 1Absorbed hydrogen embrittles hard steel under tension and a crack runs across it 6,7
Stress neededNo applied stress 1Yes, applied or residual; reported at hoop stress as low as 30% of yield 1Yes, tensile stress 6
Main material factorSulfur and inclusions, center-line segregation, banded microstructure 1Uneven microstructure and local strain; HIC resistance alone is not enough 1Hardness and strength 2,3
How it is usually foundUltrasonic testing for internal in-plane cracks; blisters seen on the surface 2,5Wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing of weld surfaces, plus ultrasonic methods to size depth 2,8Wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing of welds; hardness testing, which can miss very small hard zones 2,3

Sources: Martin and Sofronis (NIST), 2022 1; NIST SP 780 2; OSHA Technical Manual 3; Kazys and others, 2022 5; 30 CFR 250.490 6; Kaley and others, 1996 8.

When does HIC occur?

  • In low- to medium-strength steel with no applied load. The driving force is hydrogen gas pressure inside the crack 1.
  • Where the steel gives hydrogen somewhere to collect. Elongated manganese sulfide inclusions are the most common start points; center-line segregation and banded structures add risk, and banding in steel harder than 300 on the Vickers scale (HV) can matter more than sulfur content 1.
  • When uptake is high. Uptake depends on temperature, pH, solution chemistry and the partial pressures of H2S, carbon dioxide and hydrogen, not necessarily the total pressure 1.
  • Near the surface, as blisters. Small blisters seldom threaten strength because the voids lie parallel to the wall, but they show that hydrogen is entering 2. Failure becomes possible when stepwise cracking cuts the effective wall thickness 1.

When does SOHIC occur?

  • At modest stress. The NIST review cites SOHIC at hoop stress as low as 30% of yield, and notes that stress can cause cracking in conditions too mild to cause HIC alone 1.

When does SSC occur?

  • In hard or high-strength steel under tension. NIST lists high-strength bolts and the heat-affected zones of welds without PWHT as susceptible conditions 2.
  • At small hard spots in welds. The US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) notes that significant cracks can start at very small hard zones that conventional hardness tests do not detect 3.
  • In sour production equipment. US offshore rules require equipment in H2S zones to resist SSC, cite NACE MR0175 for blowout preventer, wellhead and pressure-control equipment, and require welding done in a way that keeps SSC resistance (30 CFR 250.490(p)) 6.
  • Where the environment drives more hydrogen in. pH, temperature and H2S partial pressure all affect hydrogen entry 7.

How is each form found?

Different forms need different methods, and no single one sees everything. In a Materials Properties Council research program on welded plate exposed to H2S, combined ultrasonic methods measured the size, depth and position of HIC, SOHIC and SSC well; automated scans were more repeatable than manual ones; and no single ultrasonic method described the damage fully 8. On refinery heat exchanger steel in 2022, total focusing method imaging resolved cracks close to 0.2 mm, a low-angle time-of-flight diffraction probe suited screening of large areas, and the velocity ratio method missed a thin damaged layer 5.

When investigators examined the 1984 absorber, magnetic particle testing showed several hundred cracks near the field repair welds and few near the original welds, ultrasonic testing found widespread internal separation in one shell course, and wall thickness showed no significant loss 4.

Is SOHIC a kind of HIC or a kind of SSC?

The NIST review notes that SOHIC has been described as a mix of HIC and SSC, but that acoustic emission evidence points to a mechanism close to HIC 1. Both agree on its shape: in-plane HIC cracks that stress lines up into a through-wall column 1. Older names such as stepwise cracking, blister cracking and hydrogen pressure cracking all fall under HIC in NACE terminology 1.

Where integrity problems show up

Where it occurs (unit or equipment)Conditions that drive itHow it is usually foundIn the Library
Refinery amine absorbers and vessels repaired by weldingHard, untempered repair-weld zones; hydrogen-charged plate with earlier blisters 4Magnetic particle testing showed several hundred cracks near repair welds; ultrasonic testing showed internal separation 4What is an amine gas treating unit?
Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) storage spheresH2S believed carried over from treating; weld heat-affected zones; higher-strength steels 2,3Wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing; early inspection recommended for spheres in service over 5 years 2,3Sulfide stress cracking
Welds and welded attachments in vessel plateResidual stress and heat-affected zones in wet H2S 8Manual and automated ultrasonic testing with magnetic particle testing, confirmed by sectioning in research tests 8Stress oriented hydrogen induced cracking
Carbon steel heat exchanger shells in refinery serviceHydrogen damage near and away from welds 5Total focusing method and low-angle time-of-flight diffraction; velocity ratio missed thin damage 5Conventional UT vs phased array (PAUT) vs time-of-flight diffraction (TOFD)
Plate and pipe body with inclusionsHydrogen uptake from sour water; no stress needed 1Ultrasonic testing for in-plane cracks; visual check for blisters 2,5Hydrogen induced cracking

Sources: NBSIR 86-3049 4; NIST SP 780 2; OSHA Technical Manual 3; Kaley and others, 1996 8; Kazys and others, 2022 5; Martin and Sofronis, 2022 1.

Common questions

Is hydrogen blistering a fourth form?
It is HIC close to the surface. The NIST review treats blistering and stepwise cracking as the two appearances of HIC.
Does post-weld heat treatment prevent all three?
No. Tempering lowers weld hardness and residual stress, which reduces SSC risk. HIC needs no stress, so its main controls are steel cleanliness and microstructure.
Is SSC the same as hydrogen embrittlement?
SSC is one form of it. The US offshore rule notes that SSC is also known as hydrogen embrittlement, and research reviews explain SSC through hydrogen embrittlement mechanisms. See [What is hydrogen embrittlement?](/library/hydrogen-embrittlement/).

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Hydrogen-Induced Cracking and Blistering in Steels: A Review (M. L. Martin and P. Sofronis), Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 101, 104547 · US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) ·
  2. 2.NIST Special Publication 780, Guidelines for Pressure Vessel Safety Assessment (S. Yukawa) · US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
  3. 3.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  4. 4.NBSIR 86-3049, Examination of a Pressure Vessel that Ruptured at the Chicago Refinery of the Union Oil Company on July 23, 1984 (H. I. McHenry and others) · US National Bureau of Standards (now NIST)
  5. 5.Comparative Analysis of Ultrasonic NDT Techniques for the Detection and Characterisation of Hydrogen-Induced Cracking (R. J. Kazys, L. Mazeika, V. Samaitis, R. Sliteris, P. Merck, Z. Viliunas), Materials 15(13):4551 · MDPI, via PubMed Central (open access, CC BY 4.0) ·
  6. 6.30 CFR 250.490, Hydrogen sulfide · Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR)
  7. 7.A Review of the Factors That Can Increase the Risk of Sulfide Stress Cracking in Thermomechanical Controlled Processed Pipeline Steels (S. Hiew Sze Kei, W. M. van Haaften, T. B. Britton, S. Pedrazzini), Advanced Engineering Materials 25(21) · Imperial College London repository (open access, CC BY)
  8. 8.Research report on ultrasonic characterization and monitoring of cracking in wet H2S service (L. C. Kaley, K. C. Van Scyoc, M. Prager, M. S. Cayard, R. D. Kane), OSTI record 403561 · US Department of Energy, Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)
  9. 9.Potentially Hazardous Amine Absorber Pressure Vessels Used in Refinery Processing (standard interpretation memorandum) · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) ·