Process flow diagram (PFD) vs P&ID: what is the difference?
A process flow diagram (PFD) shows what a process does: major equipment, main streams and their flows, temperatures and pressures. A piping and instrumentation diagram (P&ID) shows how the unit is connected and controlled: every line, valve and instrument. US process safety rules, 29 CFR 1910.119(d), list them as separate items.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
A process flow diagram does not replace a P&ID: the process safety management standard of the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) lists them as separate items of process safety information 1. The flow diagram sits under process technology, beside the safe upper and lower operating limits, while P&IDs sit under equipment information, beside materials of construction and relief system design 1. OSHA's 2007 refinery inspection directive asks each site for both the flow diagrams and the P&IDs of the units selected 6.
PFD vs P&ID at a glance
| Process flow diagram (PFD) | Piping and instrumentation diagram (P&ID) | |
|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | What the process does and at what conditions | What is installed and how it is connected and controlled |
| Equipment | Major items; pump capacity and head, compressor power and vessel design pressure and temperature where needed for clarity | Every item, with its tag and specifications such as material and working pressure and temperature |
| Lines | Main process streams and primary lines | Every line, including minor ones, with its size and identification |
| Valves | Main valves needed to understand the process | All valves and their types, including isolation and relief valves |
| Instruments and control | Major components of control loops | Instruments, controllers and how each control loop is built |
| Process data | Flows, temperatures and pressures at key points, often with operating ranges | Generally none; stream flows and compositions stay on the PFD |
| Materials | Shown where needed for clarity | Pipe and equipment materials and insulation |
| Place in 29 CFR 1910.119 | (d)(2)(i)(A): block flow diagram or simplified PFD, under process technology | (d)(3)(i)(B): P&IDs, under equipment information |
| Typical readers | Anyone who needs to understand the process | Piping designers and engineering staff; operators, maintenance and hazard analysis teams |
Sources: 29 CFR 1910.119 and Appendix C 1; university process control text 2; CFIHOS document type definitions, 2024 3; OSHA 3918, 2017 5.
When is a PFD used?
- To understand and explain the process. OSHA's guidance describes the PFD as more complex than a block flow diagram, carrying the main streams and the pressures and temperatures around major vessels, headers and heat exchangers 1.
- To record operating conditions. A university text notes that the PFD tabulates operating conditions, including their normal, minimum and maximum values, which the P&ID leaves out 2. CFIHOS defines the PFD as showing major equipment, primary lines and valves, and operating temperatures, pressures and mass flows 3.
- As process safety information. OSHA requires a block flow diagram or simplified process flow diagram as part of the process technology information 1.
- As a base for materials and damage work. CFIHOS describes material selection diagrams as a layer typically drawn on a PFD or P&ID 3. The American Petroleum Institute (API) catalog notes that API RP 571, on damage mechanisms, includes generic process flow diagrams summarizing the major damage mechanisms expected in typical refinery units (3rd edition, March 2020) 4.
When is a P&ID used?
- For detailed design and purchasing. The P&ID is the basis for equipment and piping design, cost estimates and purchasing, and for control programming 2.
- For hazard analysis and daily work. OSHA lists process hazard analysis, operating and maintenance procedures, work permits, equipment installation and troubleshooting as tasks that an inaccurate P&ID can mislead 5.
- Before start-up. OSHA's guidance expects P&IDs to be complete, with procedures in place and operators trained, before a new process starts 1.
- For inspection planning. OSHA's refinery program directs inspectors to pick injection points from the P&IDs and check how thickness measurement locations are set there 6.
Is a P&ID just a more detailed PFD?
No. The two use similar equipment notation, but each holds data the other omits: the PFD keeps stream flows, compositions and operating ranges, and the P&ID keeps every valve, instrument and minor line 2. Each is a controlled document, so a change to either goes through the site's document control 2. OSHA's guidance frames the levels as block flow diagram, then PFD, then P&ID, with P&IDs suited to the detail that piping designers and engineering staff need 1.
Where integrity problems show up
| Decision or step at this stage | What it affects later | In the Library |
|---|---|---|
| Stream temperatures, pressures and compositions are set on the PFD | They decide which damage mechanisms each unit faces; API RP 571 includes generic PFDs marking the major mechanisms of typical refinery units 4 | What is a damage mechanism review? |
| Materials and piping class breaks are drawn on a material selection layer of the PFD or P&ID | The same layer carries corrosion loop boundaries 3 | What is a corrosion loop?, How are materials selected for oil and gas equipment? |
| Damage susceptibility is documented unit by unit | API RP 970 (2nd edition, April 2023) describes corrosion control documents that record a unit's damage susceptibilities and connect to MOC and hazard analysis 4 | What is corrosion management? |
| Injection points, mixing points and dead legs appear only at P&ID level | OSHA cites API 570 as calling for condition monitoring locations at these points, not only along straight runs 5,6 | What are condition monitoring locations (CMLs)?, Injection point |
| The P&ID is not updated through management of change (MOC) after valves are added | Hazard reviews and start-up checks miss the change; at Geismar, Louisiana (2013), a reboiler isolated from its relief device ruptured 7 | What is management of change (MOC)? |
Sources: API 2025 catalog 4; CFIHOS V2.0, 2024 3; OSHA 3918, 2017 5; OSHA CPL 03-00-004, 2007 6; US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) case study on Geismar, 2016 7.
Common questions
- What is a block flow diagram?
- The simplest of the three. OSHA's guidance describes it as showing major process equipment and the connecting flow lines, with flow rates, compositions, temperatures and pressures only where needed for clarity.
- Which diagram does a hazard and operability study use?
- Hazard analysis teams work from P&IDs, which is why OSHA treats an inaccurate P&ID as a risk to the analysis. See [What is a hazard and operability study (HAZOP)?](/library/hazop/).
- Is there an international standard for these diagrams?
- Yes. ISO 10628-1:2014 covers how flow diagrams for the chemical and petrochemical industry are classified, what they contain and how they are drawn. Many companies also keep their own drafting rules.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.29 CFR 1910.119, Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals (including Appendices B and C) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 2.Chemical Process Dynamics and Controls, 4.1: P&ID General Information (P. Woolf et al., University of Michigan) · LibreTexts Engineering (CC BY 3.0)
- 3.CFIHOS Core Reference Data Library (C-ST-001), document type list (V2.0) · IOGP JIP36, Capital Facilities Information Handover Specification (CFIHOS) ·
- 4.2025 Publications Catalog (entries for API RP 571 and API RP 970) · American Petroleum Institute (API)
- 5.Process Safety Management for Petroleum Refineries: Lessons Learned from the Petroleum Refinery Process Safety Management National Emphasis Program (OSHA 3918-08) · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- 6.CPL 03-00-004, Petroleum Refinery Process Safety Management National Emphasis Program · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) ·
- 7.Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Rupture and Fire, Geismar, Louisiana (Case Study No. 2013-03-I-LA) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
- 8.ISO 10628-1:2014, Diagrams for the chemical and petrochemical industry, Part 1: Specification of diagrams (2014) · International Organization for Standardization (ISO)