Skip to content
Beaconby Winda

Radiographic vs ultrasonic testing for welds

·10 sources

Short answer

Radiographic testing (RT) images a weld with X-rays or gamma rays, while ultrasonic testing (UT) sends sound into it and reads the echoes. RT is better at volumetric flaws such as porosity and slag; UT is better at planar flaws such as cracks and lack of fusion, and can measure their through-wall height.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

A radiograph can show no crack in a weld that has one. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) inspection guidance states that radiography detects cracks only when they lie close to the direction of the beam, and that tight cracks in thick sections may not show even when properly aligned 1. UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) guidance adds that crack detection depends on how open the crack is and how far the beam is from its plane, and that in many cases cracks will not be found 2. The method chosen therefore limits which flaws a clean weld record can rule out 1,2.

Radiographic vs ultrasonic testing at a glance

Radiographic testing (RT)Ultrasonic testing (UT)
How it worksRadiation passes through the weld; flaws change how much reaches the film or detector 1,3Sound pulses enter the weld; flaws and surfaces send echoes back 2,3
Best atVolumetric flaws: porosity, slag, inclusions 1,2Planar flaws: cracks, lack of fusion 1,2
Weak atTight or misaligned cracks 1,2; laminations are nearly impossible to see 1Flaws not facing the beam 1; coarse-grained austenitic and nickel alloy welds without special techniques 2
Depth and height of a flawNot shown without special techniques 1,3Length and through-wall height can be measured 2
Sensitivity measureImage quality indicator of wires, holes or steps; about a 2% difference in absorption is detectable 1,2Echo height against a reference reflector, such as a 1.5 mm side-drilled hole in the US bridge welding code 4
RecordFilm or digital image kept as a permanent record 1,3None in basic manual form; automated and phased array systems store data 3,5
Field thicknessPortable X-ray tubes limited to about 75 mm (3 in) of steel; higher-energy sources for thicker sections 1A wide range of materials and thicknesses 1
SafetyIonizing radiation: controlled areas, shielding and licensing 2,7,8No radiation; a couplant is usually needed 1
SkillHigh skill for exposure and interpretation 1High skill to set up and interpret 1

Sources: FAA AC 43.13-1B, Chapter 5 1; HSE COMAH technical measures document 2; OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3 3; FHWA-HRT-04-124 and 14-074 4,5; OSHA ionizing radiation pages 7; 10 CFR 34.41 8.

The FAA sums up the trade-off: both methods can find flaws deep inside a part, but radiography works better when flaws are not planar and ultrasonics works better when they are 1.

When is radiographic testing used?

  • New welds where volumetric flaws matter and a film record is wanted. RT shows porosity and slag well and leaves an image that can be reviewed later 1,2.
  • Where a code calls for it. In 2014 the US bridge welding code required RT for complete joint penetration welds under tension and did not yet recognize phased array UT 5.
  • Corrosion under insulation on small pipe. Flash radiography with the beam tangential to the pipe shows external corrosion as changes in the wall profile, normally on pipe up to 12 in (about 300 mm) outside diameter 2.
  • Covered or hidden parts, which the FAA lists among radiography's advantages 1.

When is ultrasonic testing used?

  • Finding and sizing planar flaws, such as fatigue cracks or lack of sidewall fusion, because UT gives the through-wall height that an engineering critical assessment of a flaw relies on 2.
  • Thick sections, where portable radiography is slow or limited by source output 1.
  • Work beside running plant. RT needs a controlled area around the source; HSE describes radiography systems designed to shrink it to about 3 m so nearby work is less affected 2. UT needs no such area.
  • Mechanized and phased array scans. In FHWA bridge weld tests, phased array UT located the same flaws as radiographs and also gave their depth, which radiographs could not 6.

What do people often get wrong?

Two assumptions cause most confusion. The first is that a sharp image means a sensitive test: HSE notes that the image quality indicator shows only the ability to see changes in section or wire size, which relates only indirectly to finding real flaws 2. The second is that UT echo height equals flaw size: FHWA notes that amplitude also depends on flaw type, orientation, roughness and reflectivity 4.

Acceptance rules reflect the physics. HSE gives the example of the UK pressure vessel specification PD 5500, in which radiography allows no cracks, while ultrasonic acceptance limits planar indications by height, length and amplitude 2.

Where integrity problems show up

What it finds wellWhat it can miss or get wrongIn the Library
Porosity, slag and inclusions in new welds, with RT 1,2Tight cracks, cracks off the beam axis and laminations 1,2How is fabrication quality controlled for pressure equipment?
Flaw position along the weld on a radiograph 6The depth of the flaw in the wall 3,6How are crack-like flaws assessed for fitness-for-service?
Wall profile of small insulated pipe, with tangential RT 2Fine detail: contrast and resolution are lower than in normal radiography 2What is corrosion under insulation (CUI)?
Weld flaws in site-built LPG vessels, where manual UT gave the best trial results 2Fabrication hydrogen cracking, which HSE calls very difficult to detect with radiography 2What is hydrogen embrittlement?
Planar flaws and their height, with UT 2Skewed flaws and operator differences; in one study, vertical cracks up to 40% of plate thickness could be accepted in nearly a third of manual inspections 4Ultrasonic testing

Sources: FAA AC 43.13-1B 1; HSE COMAH technical measures document, including its LPG vessel case study 2; OSHA Technical Manual 3; FHWA-HRT-04-124 and 14-075 4,6.

Common questions

Which is safer to use on a live plant?
UT has no radiation hazard. Gamma sources used in field radiography cannot be switched off, only shielded, and OSHA notes that where portable shielding is not practical, procedures should maximize distance from the source. US rules require at least two qualified people present for radiography outside a permanent facility.
Who regulates industrial radiography in the US?
OSHA and the states cover X-ray devices, while the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and its Agreement States cover gamma devices, which use radioactive sources.
Do US pipeline rules require one method?
No. 49 CFR 192.243 accepts any process other than trepanning that clearly shows defects that may affect weld integrity, applied under written procedures by trained, qualified people. See [Radiographic testing](/glossary/radiographic-testing/).

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Advisory Circular AC 43.13-1B, Acceptable Methods, Techniques, and Practices: Aircraft Inspection and Repair, Chapter 5: Nondestructive Inspection (NDI) · US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)
  2. 2.Inspection/Non Destructive Testing (COMAH technical measures document) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  3. 3.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  4. 4.Lab and Field Testing of AUT Systems for Steel Highway Bridges (FHWA-HRT-04-124), Chapter 2: Background · US Federal Highway Administration (FHWA)
  5. 5.Development of Phased-Array Ultrasonic Testing Acceptability Criteria (Phase I), TechBrief FHWA-HRT-14-074 · US Federal Highway Administration (FHWA)
  6. 6.Development of Phased-Array Ultrasonic Testing Acceptability Criteria (Phase II), TechBrief FHWA-HRT-14-075 · US Federal Highway Administration (FHWA)
  7. 7.Ionizing Radiation: Hazards · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  8. 8.10 CFR 34.41, Conducting industrial radiographic operations · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  9. 9.49 CFR 192.243, Nondestructive testing · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  10. 10.Ionizing Radiation: Control and Prevention · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)