Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactOil, Gas and Chemicals Basics · Value chain and segments

What is vertical integration in oil and gas?

·9 sources

Short answer

Vertical integration in oil and gas means one company owning several links of the supply chain, from producing crude oil and gas through transport and refining to selling fuels. Integrated oil companies span upstream, midstream and downstream; independents concentrate on one stage. US tax law also excludes large refiners and fuel retailers from an independent producer's tax benefit.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

A vertically integrated firm is active at every stage of its own supply chain; in oil, that means working in both the upstream and the downstream markets 1. The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) splits the industry into three segments: upstream exploration and production, midstream transport and storage, and downstream refining and marketing 3. An integrated oil company holds a position in all three; the upstream, midstream and downstream page explains what each segment does. This page is about the ownership question: who holds which links, and why.

Which stages can one company hold?

StageWhat it coversIntegrated companySpecialist or independent
UpstreamFinding, drilling and producing crude oil and natural gas 3Produces some of the crude its refineries run, though integrated firms now lean on it less 6An exploration and production company that sells its output 3
MidstreamPipelines, tankers and storage 3Transports its own crude and products 2Midstream firms usually focus on one asset type, such as ships, pipelines or tanks 3
RefiningTurning crude into finished fuels and feedstocks 3Runs refineries supplied partly from its own fields 2A refiner with no fields buys all its crude; several significant US refiners had none in 2004 6
MarketingWholesale and retail sale of fuels to customers 3Sells at retail 2, including through resellers bound to use its brand 5Independent refiner-marketers, which sell fuel but hold no oil reserves 2
PetrochemicalsChemicals such as ethylene and propylene made from refinery and gas streams 9Uses its own crude and feedstocks to make higher-value chemicals 9Chemical producers whose naphtha and ethane feedstocks come from refineries and gas streams 9

Refining sits in the middle of the chain: refiners turn crude into finished products, and marketers carry those products to consumers 3. What happens inside the plant is described in how a refinery works.

How is an integrated company different from an independent one?

The difference is the number of links owned. In its 2012 review of US refining, the Congressional Research Service (CRS) counted five companies among the top ten refiners that covered the whole chain, from producing their own oil to retail sale, while the largest independent refiner and marketer held no petroleum reserves 2.

US tax law gives "independent" a precise meaning. Under 26 U.S.C. 613A, independent producers and royalty owners may claim percentage depletion at 15% on up to 1,000 barrels a day of domestic crude oil, or the gas equivalent 5. The benefit is withdrawn from any taxpayer that sells oil, gas or their products through its own retail outlets or branded resellers, unless those outlets take in no more than $5 million a year, and from any taxpayer whose refineries run more than 75,000 barrels a day on average 5. In tax terms, owning a large refinery or a retail chain is what stops a producer from counting as independent.

Why do oil and gas companies integrate?

Government and academic studies give several reasons, which often act together 1 9:

  • Capturing the value added. Owning refining and marketing lets a crude producer earn the margin on the products as well as on the oil 1.
  • Securing an outlet. A refinery and a retail network in a large consuming market give a producer a reliable buyer for its crude 1.
  • Spreading price risk. Oil prices swing, and profit moves between parts of the chain as markets change, so a company present in several parts can stay profitable through more conditions 1.
  • Upgrading crude. Integration lets a company turn its own crude into petrochemicals that sell for more than the oil 9.
  • Scale. Refineries need large minimum sizes and large sunk costs, and then run for long periods at low average cost 9.

The price-risk argument shows up in company results. In the first quarter of 2015, after crude prices fell, upstream profits of globally integrated oil companies dropped by $28 billion (80%) from a year earlier, while their downstream profits rose by almost $6 billion (95%), the best downstream quarter since the third quarter of 2012 4. Crude fell faster than gasoline and heating oil, which widened the crack spread, the refining margin; downstream earnings were 63% of the combined total that quarter, against an average share of 15% from 2011 to 2014 4.

Analysis

The 2015 numbers also show the limit of the hedge. A gain of about $6 billion against a loss of $28 billion covered roughly a fifth of the upstream fall, and total earnings still ended 54% lower 4. Integration evens out results; it does not cancel the oil price.

What are the trade-offs?

The incentive to integrate has weakened over time. A 2004 staff report by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) concluded that changes in the industry had reduced the pull toward integration across production, distribution and marketing, noting that several significant refiners had no crude production of their own 6. In its 2012 review, CRS described a continuing trend of integrated companies selling refineries or spinning them off, including one fully integrated firm that split into separate upstream and downstream companies 2.

Markets have taken over part of the job that ownership once did. Open trading in intermediate oil can stand in for owning the next stage, which let refiners with no fields enter the business 9. The privately owned international oil companies' share of world refining capacity fell from 26% in 2000 to 14% in 2019, while national oil companies rose from 23% to 33% and other independent refiners stayed near 50% 9.

Analysis

Integration also ties up capital. Refining assets carry large sunk costs and become long-lived capital stock 9, and a company that holds every stage carries that weight alongside its fields and pipelines, through every part of the price cycle.

How does antitrust law treat integration?

Integration has been an antitrust question for more than a century. In the case decided in 1911, the US government alleged that by 1882 the Standard Oil combination had taken control of the pipelines feeding the main refining centers and about 90% of the oil trade, from production and shipping through refining to sales; the Supreme Court largely upheld a decree barring the parent company from controlling 37 subsidiaries 8.

Today the US agencies review mergers that create or extend integration under the Merger Guidelines that the Department of Justice and the FTC issued in December 2023 7. Their main worry is that a combined firm could withhold or worsen access to something rivals need to compete, such as an input or a route to market, which the guidelines call foreclosure 7. The guidelines also weigh the usual defence of such deals, that joining two stages removes a double markup and can lower prices 7.

How do national oil companies fit?

Most national oil companies started upstream, and some have been buying their way downstream 1. Buying refineries and fuel stations abroad gives an exporting country an outlet for its crude and a place in a large fuel market 1. A 2023 study describes national oil companies copying the integration of the private majors by investing in refining in big consuming countries, and one Gulf producer buying refineries abroad to find buyers for its sour crude 9. The wider comparison of state and private companies is on the national vs international oil companies page.

A common mix-up

Vertical integration is often confused with horizontal integration. Vertical integration joins stages that buy from and sell to each other; horizontal integration joins competitors at the same stage, which US merger review judges mainly by how much it raises concentration 7. A second mix-up equates "integrated" with "big": the largest US refiner in 2012 was an independent with no reserves 2.

Analysis

For anyone reading O&G company accounts, the structure explains the pattern of earnings: an integrated company reports upstream and downstream results that often move in opposite directions, while an independent producer or refiner carries one side of that swing alone 4.

Common questions

What is the difference between vertical and horizontal integration in oil and gas?
Vertical integration joins different stages of the chain under one owner, such as a producer buying a refinery. Horizontal integration joins firms at the same stage, such as two refiners merging. US merger guidelines from 2023 judge the first mainly by whether rivals could lose access to a product they need, and the second by concentration among competitors.
Is an integrated oil company the same as an oil major?
Not quite. "Integrated" describes the structure, a company active from production to marketing; "major" describes size. Most majors are integrated, but national oil companies can be integrated too, and some very large refiners own no oil reserves at all.
Do integrated oil companies still produce the crude their refineries run?
Often only part of it. The FTC found in 2004 that integrated companies had come to rely less on their own production and that several significant US refiners produced no crude at all, buying everything they ran.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.The Role of National Oil Companies in the International Oil Market (CRS Report RL34137) · Congressional Research Service (CRS), via EveryCRSReport.com ·
  2. 2.The U.S. Oil Refining Industry: Background in Changing Markets and Fuel Policies (CRS Report R41478, version of 27 December 2012) · Congressional Research Service (CRS), via EveryCRSReport.com ·
  3. 3.Financial Review of the Global Crude Oil and Natural Gas Industry, Upstream 2024 · US Energy Information Administration (EIA) ·
  4. 4.Refiner margins unable to fully offset low upstream earnings for integrated oil companies · US Energy Information Administration (EIA), Today in Energy ·
  5. 5.26 U.S.C. 613A, Limitations on percentage depletion in case of oil and gas wells, subsections (c) and (d) · US Code, via Legal Information Institute (law.cornell.edu)
  6. 6.FTC Issues Staff Report: The Petroleum Industry: Mergers, Structural Change, and Antitrust Enforcement (press release) · US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) ·
  7. 7.Merger Guidelines, Guidelines 1 and 5 and section 2.5 · US Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission ·
  8. 8.Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey v. United States, 221 U.S. 1 (1911) · Supreme Court of the United States, via Legal Information Institute (law.cornell.edu)
  9. 9.D. Tobin, Captive markets and climate change: revisiting Edith Penrose's analysis of the international oil firms in the era of climate change, DOI 10.1080/02692171.2023.2240272 · International Review of Applied Economics (Taylor and Francis), open access, CC BY 4.0, via University College Cork repository ·