Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactInspection, Testing and Monitoring · Corrosion monitoring

Corrosion coupons vs electrical resistance (ER) probes

·6 sources

Short answer

A corrosion coupon is a metal sample weighed before and after exposure for an average rate; an electrical resistance (ER) probe tracks metal loss in place. Coupons need retrieval and laboratory work; ER probes read their element's thinning without removal. Both measure a sample at one point, and US pipeline rules (49 CFR 192.477) accept coupons or equivalent means.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

A clean coupon result does not prove there was no corrosive episode. A coupon reports one average rate for its whole exposure, which a 2019 review by researchers at the US National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) puts at a few months, with no real-time information 1. ASTM's public scope text for its online monitoring guide describes ER readings as a way to spot corrosive process upsets early, without entering the system to pull samples 2. US pipeline rules require coupons or other suitable means wherever gas is corrosive, and wherever liquid lines rely on inhibitors 4,5.

Corrosion coupons vs ER probes at a glance

Corrosion couponElectrical resistance (ER) probe
What it isA small metal piece with a prepared surface, placed in the stream during operation 6A metal element wired so its electrical resistance can be read; the NETL review calls it an "electrical" coupon 1
What it measuresMass lost during the exposure, after corrosion products are cleaned off 1,3The rise in resistance as the element thins, giving cumulative metal loss 1,2
Main resultOne average corrosion rate for the exposure period 1A metal loss trend; the rate is inferred from it 2
Time to a resultAfter retrieval and laboratory analysis; a few months per exposure in the NETL review 1Continuous or periodic readings without removal 2
Form of attackThe cleaned coupon can be examined for pitting as well as mass loss 3Common elements measure uniform corrosion; designs sensitive to local attack are still in research 1
Where it worksMade in the material and shape of interest 1Conductive and non-conductive media, such as produced water, oil, gas and air 1
DataWeighing and records by hand 1Electronic logging, local or remote 1,2
Main limitsSlow; one location; no information inside the exposure 1One location; electronics need upkeep; intrinsic safety rules apply in flammable areas 1
US pipeline rulesNamed in 49 CFR 192.477 and 195.579 4,5Not named; the same rules also allow "other suitable means" (192.477) or "other monitoring equipment" (195.579) 4,5

Sources: Wright et al., 2019 1; ASTM G96 and G1 product pages 2,3; 49 CFR 192.477 and 195.579 4,5; NTSB/PAR-03/01 6.

When are corrosion coupons used?

  • As the reference measurement. The NETL review describes coupon weight loss as the most established and longest-used method, still treated as the standard against which other monitoring methods are judged 1.
  • To see the type of attack. After cleaning, a coupon can be weighed and examined for pits, which ASTM's specimen practice covers 3.
  • To meet US pipeline monitoring rules. Coupons, or other means, check internal corrosion control on corrosive gas lines and inhibitor programs on liquid lines, at least twice each calendar year with no more than 7.5 months between checks 4,5.

When are ER probes used?

  • When readings are needed without entering the system. ER readings come without withdrawing anything, unlike coupons 2.
  • To catch process upsets and steer inhibitor dosing. ASTM's scope text cites early warning of corrosive conditions and signaling when more inhibitor is needed 2.
  • In streams that do not conduct electricity. ER elements work in gas, oil and air, where electrochemical probes such as linear polarization resistance (LPR) need a conductive liquid 1.
  • Where data should be logged or sent remotely 1,2.

What do both methods have in common?

Both are point sensors: they report what happens to a sample at the spot where it is installed, and the NETL review notes that positions are usually chosen from experience, so unusual corroding spots can be missed 1. ASTM's guide adds that a rate from a coupon or a probe element is an average over its surface, so the sample has to be looked at to judge how uneven the attack was 2. Neither measures the wall of the pipe or vessel itself; that is the job of inspection methods such as ultrasonic thickness measurement.

Where integrity problems show up

What it finds wellWhat it can miss or get wrongIn the Library
Coupon: average corrosion rate at its location, and pits seen once it is cleaned 1,3Short corrosive episodes inside a months-long exposure 1What is corrosion monitoring and which methods are used?
ER probe: metal loss trend without removal, early warning of upsets 2Pitting and other local attack on common elements 1What is pitting corrosion?
Both: how corrosive the stream is at the sample point 1Corrosion where liquids collect away from the sample; at Carlsbad, New Mexico, in 2000, liquids gathered at a low point formed by a pipe bend, a section with no coupons 6What is microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC)?
Both: whether an inhibitor program is working 2,5The actual wall of the equipment, which neither measures 1How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work?

Sources: Wright et al., 2019 1; ASTM G96 and G1 product pages 2,3; 49 CFR 195.579 5; NTSB/PAR-03/01, 2003 6.

Common questions

What is a corrosion coupon?
A coupon is a small metal sample with a carefully prepared surface, placed in a pipeline or vessel while it operates to measure corrosion rate or to check that corrosion control works. Its mass loss over the exposure gives an average rate.
Can ER probes replace coupons?
They answer different questions. The NETL review still treats coupon weight loss as the reference measurement, while ER probes give a trend without removal, and US rules accept other suitable means alongside coupons.
How is an ER probe different from an LPR probe?
An ER probe measures accumulated metal loss on its element and infers a rate. An LPR probe uses an electrochemical measurement to estimate the corrosion rate at that moment, within minutes, but needs a conductive liquid and may need calibration against other methods.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Corrosion Sensors for Structural Health Monitoring of Oil and Natural Gas Infrastructure: A Review (R. F. Wright et al.), Sensors 19(18):3964 · MDPI, via PubMed Central ·
  2. 2.ASTM G96-90(2018), Standard Guide for Online Monitoring of Corrosion in Plant Equipment (Electrical and Electrochemical Methods) (product page, Scope and Significance) (G96-90 (reapproved 2018), marked historical on the ASTM store) · ASTM International
  3. 3.ASTM G1-03(2017)e1, Standard Practice for Preparing, Cleaning, and Evaluating Corrosion Test Specimens (product page, Scope and Significance) (G1-03 (reapproved 2017), editorially corrected; marked historical on the ASTM store) · ASTM International
  4. 4.49 CFR 192.477, Internal corrosion control: Monitoring · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  5. 5.49 CFR 195.579, What must I do to mitigate internal corrosion? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  6. 6.Pipeline Accident Report: Natural Gas Pipeline Rupture and Fire Near Carlsbad, New Mexico, August 19, 2000 (NTSB/PAR-03/01) · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)