Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactEngineering Design and Materials · Design for integrity

How do you design equipment so it can be inspected?

·9 sources

Short answer

Designing for inspectability means building in the access, openings, drains and monitoring points that later inspection needs. It also means avoiding features, such as dead legs and poorly sealed insulation, that hide damage. For new US gas transmission lines, 49 CFR 192.150 requires a design that lets in-line inspection tools pass through.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

At a Sunray, Texas, refinery in 2007, water collected in a control station that had been left connected but unused for about 15 years, froze, cracked an elbow and released liquid propane at about 4,500 pounds per minute, which ignited 1. The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) found that the idle station formed a dead leg, and that a 2006 drawing update had identified only the dead legs that were obvious to the eye, not ones created by closed valves 1. Three workers were seriously burned and the refinery shut down 2. OSHA's refinery inspections found related gaps, including insulated equipment that was never checked for corrosion under insulation 3.

Which design features make inspection possible?

FeatureWhat it allows laterPublic anchor
Access openings, drains and vents on pressure vesselsInternal examination, and safe draining and venting firstHSE vessel design guidance 4
Piping routed with safe access for operation, inspection and maintenanceReaching lines, supports and welds without improvised accessHSE pipework guidance 5
Free drainage, with no pockets or dead legs in hazardous serviceNo trapped water, condensate or deposits where damage can growHSE 5,6
Weatherproofed insulation, and an inspection program for insulated pipingLess corrosion under insulation, and planned checks where it can occurHSE 5; OSHA 3
Condition monitoring locations at susceptible points such as injection points, mixing points and dead legsThickness trending where thinning is most likelyOSHA, citing API 570 as an example of good practice 3
Pipelines that pass in-line inspection toolsInternal inspection along the full length49 CFR 192.150 for gas, 195.120 for hazardous liquids 7,8
Liquid removal and corrosion monitoring points on new gas transmission linesChecking internal corrosion where it is most likely49 CFR 192.476 9
Relief devices and emergency valves placed where people can reach themTesting, maintenance and safe operation in an emergencyOSHA 3

How do dead legs, insulation and poor access hide damage?

Dead legs. CSB defines a dead leg as piping that stays connected to the process but has no flow through it 1. At Sunray, CSB concluded that water in the propane most likely sank into the idle station and collected there 1. HSE guidance for hazardous fluids calls for piping without dead legs and designed to drain, and for avoiding pockets where corrosive condensate can form 5. OSHA notes that API 570, an example of good practice, places monitoring points at dead legs because they are prone to damage 3.

Insulation. HSE warns that badly installed insulation creates ideal conditions for corrosion and needs weatherproofing against moisture and spills 5. In its refinery emphasis program, begun in 2007, OSHA cited sites that did not inspect for corrosion under insulation, and listed poor design that lets moisture collect and insulation that holds water among the contributing factors 3.

Access. OSHA's inspectors also found relief devices in inaccessible places, a bypass valve that could only be reached by crawling across a pipe rack, and emergency isolation valves placed where operators would be in harm's way 3.

When in a project is inspectability decided?

Mostly during layout and routing in front-end engineering design (FEED) and detailed design, when vessel nozzles, pipe routes, insulation systems and pipeline fittings are fixed 4,5. For US pipelines, the piggability rules apply to each new transmission line and to replacements of line pipe, valves and fittings, with exceptions such as manifolds, station piping, gathering lines and pipe sizes for which no tool is commercially available 7. The hazardous liquid rule has a parallel list 8.

Changes during operation count too. When a gas transmission operator changes a line's configuration, it must assess the effect on internal corrosion downstream and provide for liquid removal and monitoring as needed 9. At Sunray, no management of change review was done when the control station was taken out of service in the 1990s 1. See Concept, pre-FEED, FEED and detailed design: what happens in each phase?.

Where integrity problems show up

Decision or step at this stageWhat it affects laterIn the Library
Leaving unused piping connected instead of removing or isolating itA dead leg where water can collect, freeze or corrode 1,5Dead leg
Insulating without weatherproofing or a way for water to drainCorrosion that stays hidden under the insulation 3,5What is corrosion under insulation (CUI)?
Not defining monitoring locations at susceptible pointsThinning that goes unmeasured; OSHA cited missing ultrasonic thickness testing and uninspected location points 3What are condition monitoring locations (CMLs)?
Building a pipeline with bends, valves or taps that block inspection toolsA line that cannot be inspected internally and needs other methods 7How are unpiggable pipelines inspected?
Omitting access openings or drains on a vesselInternal condition that cannot be examined directly 4How are pressure vessels inspected?
Placing relief devices out of reachTesting and maintenance that are harder to carry out 3What does a pressure relief valve do?

Sources: CSB report on the 2007 Sunray, Texas, refinery fire (2008) 1; OSHA 3918, 2017 3; HSE COMAH technical measures documents (2025) 4,5; 49 CFR 192.150 7.

Common questions

Do all pipelines have to be piggable?
No. The US rules cover new transmission lines and replaced components, and exclude items such as manifolds, station piping, gathering lines and some offshore lines; operators can also petition where it is impracticable.
Can a plant find its dead legs after construction?
Yes, through surveys and management of change. After Sunray, CSB recommended written freeze protection programs that include periodic inspections to find dead legs and rarely used piping where water could collect.
Is inspectability only about checks during manufacturing?
No. A 2026 article in the journal of the American Society for Nondestructive Testing (ASNT) describes inspectability as covering manufacturing examination, in-service monitoring, repair and end-of-life evaluation. The HSE guidance and federal pipeline rules above address the in-service part.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Investigation Report: LPG Fire at Valero-McKee Refinery (Four Injured, Total Refinery Evacuation, and Extended Shutdown), Report No. 2007-05-I-TX · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
  2. 2.Valero McKee Refinery Propane Fire (investigation page and recommendations) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
  3. 3.Process Safety Management for Petroleum Refineries: Lessons Learned from the Petroleum Refinery Process Safety Management National Emphasis Program (OSHA 3918) · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  4. 4.Design Codes: Plant (COMAH Technical Measures Document) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) ·
  5. 5.Design Codes: Pipework (COMAH Technical Measures Document) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) ·
  6. 6.Corrosion / selection of materials (COMAH Technical Measures Document) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) ·
  7. 7.49 CFR 192.150, Passage of internal inspection devices · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  8. 8.49 CFR 195.120, Passage of internal inspection devices · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  9. 9.49 CFR 192.476, Internal corrosion control: Design and construction of transmission line · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register