Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactAsset Integrity Management · Integrity management systems

Which KPIs measure asset integrity performance?

·9 sources

Short answer

Asset integrity key performance indicators (KPIs) show whether the controls that keep equipment intact are working. Leading indicators track activity, such as safety-critical inspections done on schedule; lagging indicators count failures, such as loss of containment. UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) guidance HSG254 sets out this pairing, and US pipeline rules require integrity program performance measures.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

A low injury rate says little about equipment integrity. Investigating the 2005 Texas City refinery explosion, which killed 15 people and injured 180, the US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) found that a very low personal injury rate had given a misleading picture of process safety, and that mechanical integrity deficiencies had let process equipment run to failure 1. Personal safety measures were the only ones used in the company's safety policy, assurance reports, performance contracts, incentive programs and plant goals 1. Offshore, HSE's 2004 to 2007 asset integrity programme, Key Programme 3 (KP3), likewise found management monitoring tilted toward occupational data at the expense of major hazard warning signs 3.

What is the difference between leading and lagging indicators?

HSG254, written by HSE with the Chemical Industries Association in 2006, sets one of each for every critical risk control system and calls the pair dual assurance 2.

  • Leading indicators are active checks that key activities in a control system are actually being done, such as inspections completed by their due date 2.
  • Lagging indicators come from investigating events that show a control system failed, even when there was no injury, damage or release 2.

The CSB report on Texas City described the same split: leading indicators check that needed actions were taken, lagging indicators show that an outcome was not achieved 1. US guidance for hazardous liquid pipelines sorts integrity performance measures into three groups: activity measures, deterioration measures that show weakening condition despite preventive work, and failure measures such as leak history 7.

Which indicators are used for asset integrity?

IndicatorTypeWhat it showsSource
Percentage of safety-critical inspections completed to scheduleLeadingWhether the inspection plan is being deliveredHSG254 2
Percentage of safety-critical equipment within specification when inspected or testedLeadingWhether equipment meets its performance standardHSG254 2; KP3 3
Percentage of maintenance actions completed within the set timeLeadingWhether faults found are fixedHSG254 2
Safety-critical maintenance backlog, in hoursLeadingOverdue work on barriers; HSE's stated target is zeroKP3 3
Deferrals of safety-critical maintenance, with risk assessmentLeadingWhether degraded barriers are being compensated forKP3 3
Verification findings closed outLeadingWhether independent findings are acted on; used as a cross-industry indicator in the UK by 2009KP3 review 4
Loss of containment where corrosion, wear or damage contributedLaggingWhether the inspection and maintenance system achieved its outcomeHSG254 2
Pipeline activity, deterioration and failure measuresBothProgram activity, weakening condition, leaks and failures49 CFR 195, Appendix C 7

Sources: HSG254, 2006 2; HSE KP3 report, 2007 3; HSE KP3 review, 2009 4; 49 CFR Part 195, Appendix C 7.

How are integrity KPIs set up?

HSG254 sets out six steps: assign a champion and team, decide the scope, identify the risk control systems and set a lagging indicator for each, pick the critical elements of each system and set leading indicators, set up data collection and reporting, and review 2. Three details from HSE's work make the numbers usable:

  • Tolerances. Each leading indicator gets a tolerance that triggers attention from senior management; HSG254 says management, not the person doing the activity, should set it, and every deviation needs follow-up 2.
  • Common definitions. HSE found that "backlog" meant different things across companies, sites and onshore and offshore teams, which made it hard for senior managers to read maintenance status 3.
  • Clean data. Large amounts of spurious data in maintenance systems hid the true backlog and blocked prioritization of critical tasks 3.

HSG254 also notes that a small number of well-chosen indicators is enough; not every part of a control system needs a measure 2.

What do US pipeline rules require?

Gas transmission operators must include a performance plan in their integrity management program 6. Under 49 CFR 192.945, the measures must include the four overall performance measures in section 9.4 of American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) B31.8S and the threat-specific measures in its Appendix A, and the four overall measures go into the annual report to the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) 5. Hazardous liquid operators must have methods to measure whether their program protects high consequence areas, with guidance in Appendix C to Part 195 7,8. See What is pipeline integrity management?.

Where integrity problems show up

DecisionData it depends onWhat goes wrong without it
Choosing what senior managers seeLeading and lagging process safety indicators, not only injury ratesAt Texas City, a low injury rate masked process safety and mechanical integrity problems before the 2005 explosion 1
Defining backlogOne definition across sites, onshore and offshoreDiffering definitions confused senior managers about maintenance status 3
Measuring safety-critical test resultsPerformance standards that can be measuredHSE kept finding standards too vague or broad to verify, which undermines any indicator built on them 4
Setting tolerancesThresholds agreed by managementNo defined point at which slippage reaches senior managers, and deviations go unexamined 2
Measuring pipeline program effectivenessOverall and threat-specific measuresThe operator cannot show whether its program protects high consequence areas, and the federal rule is not met 5
Planning for ageing installationsLeading indicators for ageing and life extensionHSE found too few leading ageing indicators to forecast future problems 9

Sources: CSB Texas City report, 2007 1; HSG254, 2006 2; HSE KP3 report, 2007 3; HSE KP3 review, 2009 4; 49 CFR 192.945 5; HSE Key Programme 4 (KP4) report, 2014 9.

Common questions

Is API RP 754 an asset integrity KPI standard?
American Petroleum Institute (API) Recommended Practice 754, *Process Safety Performance Indicators for the Refining and Petrochemical Industries* (3rd edition, August 2021), covers process safety indicators, of which integrity is one part. In 2007 the CSB had recommended that API and the steelworkers' union create a standard with leading and lagging process safety indicators.
Is an injury rate an integrity KPI?
No. The CSB found that personal injury rates are not a reliable measure of major accident risk, citing lessons from an earlier UK investigation. See [Process safety vs occupational safety](/library/process-vs-occupational-safety).
How many integrity KPIs are enough?
HSG254 recommends a small number of carefully chosen indicators focused on the most critical controls. By 2009, the UK offshore industry had voluntarily developed two cross-industry asset integrity KPIs.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Investigation Report: Refinery Explosion and Fire, Texas City, Texas, March 23, 2005 (Report No. 2005-04-I-TX) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
  2. 2.HSG254, Developing process safety indicators: A step-by-step guide for chemical and major hazard industries (First edition) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) with the Chemical Industries Association
  3. 3.Key Programme 3: Asset Integrity Programme · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Offshore Division
  4. 4.Key Programme 3, Asset Integrity: A review of industry's progress · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Offshore Division
  5. 5.49 CFR 192.945, What methods must an operator use to measure program effectiveness? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  6. 6.49 CFR 192.911, What are the elements of an integrity management program? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  7. 7.Appendix C to Part 195, Guidance for Implementation of an Integrity Management Program (section V, Methods to measure performance) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  8. 8.49 CFR 195.452, Pipeline integrity management in high consequence areas, paragraph (k) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  9. 9.Key Programme 4 (KP4): Ageing and life extension programme · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Energy Division