Sacrificial anode vs impressed current cathodic protection
Both systems make the protected steel the cathode of a circuit, nearly stopping its corrosion; they differ in the current source. Sacrificial (galvanic) anodes of magnesium, aluminum or zinc corrode instead and need no power. Impressed current uses a rectifier to drive larger, adjustable current. US pipeline criteria for both are in 49 CFR 192 Appendix D.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
On December 11, 2012, a 20-inch natural gas transmission line ruptured and burned beside Interstate 77 at Sissonville, West Virginia, destroying three houses 8. The line had a factory-applied coating and impressed current cathodic protection, and readings at the nearest test station, about 100 feet away, had been satisfactory for 10 years 8. Yet more than 30 square feet of pipe was heavily corroded, with over 70% wall loss, because coarse rock backfill had damaged the coating and blocked the protective current 8. Whichever system supplies it, the current protects only steel it can reach 8.
Sacrificial anode vs impressed current at a glance
| Sacrificial (galvanic) anodes | Impressed current | |
|---|---|---|
| Source of current | The natural voltage difference between a more active metal and the steel 1,3 | An external direct current supply, usually a transformer-rectifier fed from the power grid 1,3 |
| Anode materials | Magnesium, aluminum or zinc alloys cast around a steel insert 1 | Low-dissolution anodes: high-silicon cast iron, graphite, mixed metal oxide on titanium, magnetite; scrap steel as a consumable option 1,2 |
| Driving voltage | About 0.5 V for aluminum and zinc, falling to about 0.25 V as the steel polarizes; up to about 1 V for magnesium 1 | Up to about 50 V 1,2 |
| Current output | Small, governed by soil or water resistivity, not normally adjustable 1 | Large and adjustable as the structure changes 1 |
| Reach on a pipeline | "Little and often": NPL gives about 200 m average spacing for magnesium anodes on a well-coated 300 mm pipe, for 8 to 10 years of anode life 2 | About 2 km per installation on poorly coated pipe, 50 km or more on well-coated pipe 2 |
| Power needed | None 1 | Grid power, or solar, wind, thermoelectric or engine-driven generation in remote areas 1 |
| Effect on nearby structures | Less prone to severe interference, so often used in congested or built-up areas 1,2 | Must be designed to limit stray current effects on neighboring structures 1,5 |
| Overprotection | Generally self-regulating 1 | Excessive negative potentials can disbond coatings and embrittle high-strength steels 1 |
| Routine US pipeline checks | Cathodic protection test every calendar year, no more than 15 months apart 5,7 | The annual test plus rectifier checks six times a year, no more than 2½ months apart 5,7 |
| US Army selection rule (1985) | Soil resistivity below 5,000 ohm-cm (50 ohm-m) and current demand below 1 milliampere per square foot 3 | Resistivity or current demand above those values 3 |
Sources: NPL Guides No. 1 and 4 1,2; US Army TM 5-811-7, 1985 3; 49 CFR 192.465 and 195.573 5,7.
When are sacrificial anodes used?
- Small or well-coated structures with low current demand, or to protect a local hot spot 1.
- Congested areas, where an impressed current groundbed could interfere with other buried metal 1,2.
- Large offshore structures, where NPL notes galvanic protection of uncoated platforms has proved cost effective and works from the moment the structure is floated out, without a power supply 1.
- Particular materials and settings. Magnesium suits buried use and aluminum and zinc mainly marine use 1; zinc anodes are used on prestressed concrete pipe because impressed current could embrittle the prestressing steel 2.
When is impressed current used?
- Long pipelines and large, complex structures, including bare or poorly coated ones 1.
- High-resistivity soils, where the small galvanic driving voltage cannot push enough current 1,3.
- Changing demand, because rectifier output can be raised as coatings age or the structure grows 1. In variable waters such as tidal estuaries, output can be controlled automatically from a permanent reference electrode 1.
How is either system checked?
The same criteria apply to both. For steel under Part 192, Appendix D accepts, among other criteria, a potential at least 0.85 V more negative than a saturated copper-copper sulfate reference cell with current applied, allowing for voltage drops, or at least 100 mV of polarization measured by interrupting the current 6. Hazardous liquid lines use the criteria in NACE SP0169 that 49 CFR 195.571 references 7. NPL adds that steel exposed to sulfate-reducing bacteria needs a more negative potential, about -0.95 V against copper-copper sulfate 1.
Close interval surveys measure pipe-to-soil potential every few feet, either switching the current on and off, after depolarization, or with current on where it cannot be interrupted 8,9. When an annual test station reading on an onshore gas transmission line is low and the cause is systemic, the operator must run such a survey in both directions, at about 5-foot spacing, normally with the current interrupted (49 CFR 192.465) 5. NPL considers a twice-yearly check, including sacrificial anodes, generally sufficient, and notes that about 5% of test posts are damaged each year 2.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coated gas line in rock backfill under impressed current 8 | Rocks damaged the coating and shielded the steel; test station 100 feet away read satisfactory 8 | In-line inspection or pressure testing, which the NTSB concluded would likely have revealed it 8 | Pipe-to-soil potential |
| Foreign pipelines, cables or moored vessels near a protected structure | Protective current picked up and discharged by the other structure corrodes it where it leaves 1 | Interference tests, usually yearly where at risk or after output changes 1; interference surveys on gas transmission lines (49 CFR 192.473) 5 | What is soil corrosion? |
| Rectifier-powered systems | Protection lasts only while amperage and voltage are maintained 5 | Rectifier inspections six times a year, remotely or on site, plus a yearly physical check of remote units (49 CFR 192.465) 5 | Impressed current cathodic protection |
| Galvanic systems as coatings deteriorate | Current demand rises but anode output cannot be raised 1 | Annual potential tests and anode current measured at test posts 1,5 | Sacrificial anode |
| High-strength steels, some corrosion-resistant alloys, prestressed concrete pipe | Excessive negative potential releases hydrogen that can embrittle the steel 1,2 | Potential measurements compared with the limits set for the structure 1 | What is hydrogen embrittlement? |
Sources: NTSB PAR-14/01 8; NPL Guides No. 1 and 4 1,2; 49 CFR 192 Subpart I 5.
Common questions
- Is a galvanic anode the same as a sacrificial anode?
- Yes. Both names describe an anode of a more active metal that corrodes in place of the steel; NPL and the US Army manual use them interchangeably.
- Can both systems protect one structure?
- Yes, with care to avoid interference between them. A temporary galvanic system may protect a new pipeline until power and land access for an impressed current system are settled.
- Do impressed current anodes wear out?
- They dissolve very slowly rather than not at all. NPL describes them as inert or low-dissolution materials, normally buried in carbonaceous backfill that lowers their resistance to earth.
- Does either system protect pipe above ground?
- No. Cathodic protection needs the steel to be surrounded by soil, water or concrete, so it cannot prevent atmospheric corrosion.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Guides to Good Practice in Corrosion Control No. 1: Cathodic Protection (D. W. Harvey) · National Physical Laboratory (NPL), UK
- 2.Guides to Good Practice in Corrosion Control No. 4: Corrosion Control for Buried Pipelines (D. W. Harvey) · National Physical Laboratory (NPL), UK
- 3.TM 5-811-7, Electrical Design, Cathodic Protection (Technical Manual) · Headquarters, US Department of the Army (hosted by the Whole Building Design Guide) ·
- 4.Fact Sheet: Cathodic Protection · US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)
- 5.49 CFR Part 192, Subpart I, Requirements for Corrosion Control (192.455 to 192.473) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 6.Appendix D to Part 192, Criteria for Cathodic Protection and Determination of Measurements · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 7.49 CFR Part 195, Subpart H, Corrosion Control (195.563 to 195.577) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 8.Pipeline Accident Report NTSB/PAR-14/01: Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation Pipeline Rupture, Sissonville, West Virginia, December 11, 2012 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)
- 9.Fact Sheet: Close Interval Survey · US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)