Skip to content
Beaconby Winda

What is a bowtie risk analysis?

·7 sources

Short answer

A bowtie risk analysis is a diagram that shows how one hazard can get out of control and the barriers that stand on each path to harm. Threats sit on the left, consequences on the right, and the loss of control, called the top event, forms the knot. It is mainly qualitative and supports safety cases and barrier management.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

A barrier drawn on a bowtie shows that a safeguard is planned, not that it will work. In its 2014 report on the 2010 Macondo blowout in the Gulf of Mexico, which killed 11 people and injured 17, the US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) drew a bowtie in which the blowout preventer (BOP) is the only barrier on both sides of the knot 3. It also found that routine inspection and weekly function tests had not revealed latent faults in the BOP's emergency system, including miswiring and a drained battery in one of its two redundant control pods 3. The CSB's bowtie lists inspection and maintenance among the controls meant to stop a barrier from decaying 3.

What are the parts of a bowtie?

The UK Civil Aviation Authority (CAA), which publishes bowtie guidance, defines the elements below 1. The examples in the third column come from the CSB's Macondo bowtie 3.

ElementWhat it meansOffshore drilling example
HazardSomething with the potential to cause harm 1Oil and gas in the riser above the BOP 3
Top eventThe moment control over the hazard is lost 1A kick that brings hydrocarbons into the riser 3
ThreatsDirect causes that could lead to the top event 1Cement that fails to seal; an inadequate drilling fluid column; a lost circulation event 3
ConsequencesOutcomes that directly cause harm, loss or damage 1Ignited blowout with fire and loss of life; unignited release to the sea 3
Preventive controls (left side)Measures that remove a threat or stop it reaching the top event 1Bottom hole cement and its integrity tests; correct mud density 3
Recovery controls (right side)Measures that lower the chance or severity of a consequence once the top event happens 1Diverter system, emergency BOP systems, ignition controls, evacuation 3
Escalation factorsConditions that weaken a control or make it fail 1; the CSB calls them barrier decay mechanisms 3The BOP fails when needed 3
Escalation factor controlsMeasures that protect a control from its escalation factors 1Inspection and maintenance; design limits found in hazard analysis; crew vigilance 3

How is a bowtie built and used?

The CAA traces the method to a simplified fusion of fault tree and event tree analysis, and notes that the oil and gas industry developed its practical use in the 1990s 4. A team picks one hazard, defines the top event, lists the direct threats and consequences, then adds the barriers on each path and the factors that could defeat them 1. Attributes such as barrier effectiveness, criticality and assurance measures can be added to support a safety management system 1.

UK offshore guidance from the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) describes three uses in risk assessment: documenting the lines of defense in place, supporting a qualitative check for gaps, and informing likelihood estimates for semi-quantitative analysis 2. Numbering each barrier shows which ones serve several threats or several scenarios, which helps judge whether a proposed risk reduction measure would control more than one hazardous event 2. HSE's example bowtie lists plant layout, construction standards, inspection and instrumentation as prevention barriers, and detection, emergency shutdown, active and passive protection, and escape, evacuation and rescue as mitigation barriers 2.

In offshore asset integrity work, the hardware barriers are the safety-critical elements (SCEs), the parts of an installation and its plant designed to prevent, control or limit major accident hazards 5. The Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS) and the Energy Institute published a concept book on bowties in process safety in 2018, describing the method as qualitative risk assessment and barrier management 7.

What can a bowtie not show?

  • How often harm will happen. A bowtie is mainly a qualitative tool 4; HSE describes it as helping to inform likelihood estimates in semi-quantitative analysis 2. Layer of protection analysis (LOPA) is one way to put numbers on a single threat-to-consequence path.
  • Whether each barrier works today. That depends on testing, inspection and maintenance, which is why the CSB's bowtie adds decay mechanisms and their controls 3.
  • Hazards nobody listed. HSE notes that missed hazards are usually the biggest uncertainty in any risk assessment 2.

Where integrity problems show up

Element or stepIntegrity linkIn the Library
Prevention barrier: inspection and construction standardsHSE lists inspection and construction standards as barriers that keep containment from being lost 2What is risk-based inspection (RBI)?
Barrier decay control for hardwareThe CSB's bowtie names inspection and maintenance as the control against the BOP failing when needed; weekly tests missed latent faults 3What are safety and environmental critical elements (SECEs)?
Performance standard for each barrierHSE's offshore inspections found standards that were generic, without measurable criteria such as valve closure time or leak rate 5Performance standard (for safety-critical elements)
Maintenance backlog on barriersHSE treats backlog on SCEs as a measure of how well they work as barriers and sets a target of zero 5Which KPIs measure asset integrity performance?
Recovery barriers: detection and emergency shutdownListed by HSE as mitigation barriers after a release 2What is a safety instrumented system (SIS)?
Ageing installationsHSE's ageing and life extension program calls for reassessing deterioration mechanisms and the barriers to failure of ageing structures against their planned remaining life 6What is asset life extension?

Sources: HSE Offshore Information Sheet 3/2006 2; CSB Macondo report, Volume 2, 2014 3; HSE KP3, 2007 5; HSE KP4, 2014 6.

Common questions

How is a bowtie different from a fault tree or an event tree?
The CAA describes the bowtie as a simplified fusion of fault tree and event tree methods. HSE describes it as showing all the initiators of one scenario on one side and all its consequences on the other, with the barriers in between.
How is a bowtie different from LOPA?
A bowtie maps all the threats, consequences and barriers around one hazard, mostly qualitatively. LOPA takes one cause and consequence pair and estimates whether the independent layers on it reduce the risk enough; HSE notes that bowtie barriers are often called layers of protection.
What is an escalation factor?
It is a condition that can weaken a barrier or make it fail, such as a blowout preventer that fails when needed in the CSB's example. The CAA pairs each one with escalation factor controls, and the CSB calls the same idea a barrier decay mechanism.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Introduction to bowtie · UK Civil Aviation Authority (CAA)
  2. 2.Guidance on Risk Assessment for Offshore Installations (Offshore Information Sheet No. 3/2006) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  3. 3.Investigation Report Volume 2: Explosion and Fire at the Macondo Well (Report No. 2010-10-I-OS) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
  4. 4.History and Use of BowTie · UK Civil Aviation Authority (CAA)
  5. 5.Key Programme 3: Asset Integrity Programme · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Offshore Division
  6. 6.Key Programme 4 (KP4): Ageing and life extension programme · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Energy Division
  7. 7.Bow Ties in Risk Management: A Concept Book for Process Safety (publisher page) · Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS) and Energy Institute, via John Wiley and Sons