Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactEngineering Design and Materials · Materials and welding

Carbon steel vs stainless steel in process service

·9 sources

Short answer

Stainless steel has at least 10.5% chromium, which forms a protective film; carbon steel has little chromium and needs a corrosion allowance or coating. Carbon steel is the usual choice where corrosion can be controlled. Stainless steel is used where it cannot, or for very cold service, but austenitic grades can crack in warm chloride-bearing water.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

Stainless steel is not automatically the safer choice: the UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) reports that the most frequent stress corrosion cracking failures in piping involve austenitic stainless steels in chloride solutions, with trace chlorides enough to cause trouble above 60 °C (140 °F) 4. Carbon steel fails differently. In hot sulfur service the US Chemical Safety Board (CSB) calculated that it corrodes about 120 times faster than 18% chromium stainless steel at 630 °F (about 332 °C) 7, and in amine, wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S), ammonia and caustic service it cracks mainly at welds 6. Each choice brings its own set of damage mechanisms.

Carbon steel vs stainless steel at a glance

Carbon steelStainless steel
CompositionIron with carbon and manganese and little chromium; ASTM A53B pipe, for example, allows at most 0.40% chromium 7At least 10.5% chromium and at most 1.20% carbon by mass (the ASTM A941 definition) 1
How it resists corrosionNo protective film; corrosion in water is handled with an allowance, coatings, inhibitors or cathodic protection 4A chromium-rich passive film; more chromium gives more protection 1
Main typesLow-carbon and carbon-manganese grades, such as SA-516 Grade 70 plate for vessels 5Austenitic, ferritic, martensitic, duplex and precipitation-hardening; austenitic is about two-thirds of output 2
Typical process usesAmine, deaerator and ammonia storage vessels 6; pipeline pipe 9Severe general corrosion 5; liquid oxygen and other cold duty 4; hot sulfur service 7
Cracking it is prone toStress corrosion cracking in hot caustic, nitrates, wet H2S, anhydrous ammonia, amine and hot oxygenated water, mostly at welds 5,6Chloride stress corrosion cracking, worst in standard austenitic grades 3; intergranular corrosion where welding depletes chromium
Low-temperature behaviorTurns from ductile to brittle over a temperature range that, for some grades, includes room temperature 5Austenitic grades stay tough at cryogenic temperatures 1
Magnetism and inspectionFerromagnetic; magnetic particle testing applies 6Austenitic grades are non-magnetic when annealed, so penetrant testing is used 2,6

Sources: SSINA 1,2,3; HSE, 2025 4; NIST SP 780, 1990 5; OSHA Technical Manual 6; CSB, 2015 7; 49 CFR 195.112 9.

When is carbon steel used?

  • Where corrosion is slow and predictable. HSE describes the usual practice as choosing a material that corrodes slowly at a known rate and adding a thickness allowance, because fully resistant materials are often too costly 4. See Corrosion allowance.
  • For common vessel services. OSHA guidance describes deaerator, amine and ammonia storage vessels as usually built from carbon steel grades 6.
  • For pipelines. US rules for new hazardous liquid pipe call for carbon, low-alloy high-strength or alloy steel made to a written specification 9.

When is stainless steel used?

  • Where general corrosion would be severe. A 1990 assessment by the US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) notes that severe general corrosion calls for stainless steels or other corrosion-resistant materials 5.
  • For cold service. HSE lists austenitic stainless among materials suited to liquid oxygen and warns that carbon steels become brittle at low temperatures 4; nickel keeps austenitic grades tough at cryogenic temperatures 1.
  • In hot sulfur service. Sulfidation slows as chromium rises, which is the basis of the CSB comparison above 7. See What is sulfidation?.
  • Where chloride cracking must be avoided. Ferritic grades resist chloride stress corrosion cracking well and duplex grades better than standard austenitic ones 3. See What are corrosion-resistant alloys (CRAs)?.

A common mix-up

Chromium-molybdenum steels are not stainless. They hold less chromium than the 10.5% in the stainless definition 1, and ASME practice calls steels with up to 9% chromium low-alloy steels 5. They also look like carbon steel: at a Texas City, Texas, refinery in 2005, a carbon steel elbow installed where 1.25% chromium steel was required ruptured after about 3 months, and the CSB recommended positive material identification (PMI) to tell such parts apart 8. "Stainless" also covers families that behave very differently in chlorides 3.

Where integrity problems show up

Decision or step at this stageWhat it affects laterIn the Library
Choosing a standard austenitic grade for warm chloride-bearing serviceChloride stress corrosion cracking, possible from trace chlorides above 60 °C 3,4What is chloride stress corrosion cracking?
Choosing carbon steel for amine service with as-welded jointsCracking in or near welds that were not post-weld heat treated 6What is amine corrosion and amine cracking?
Choosing carbon steel for hot caustic service without stress reliefCaustic stress corrosion cracking at welds 5,6What is caustic stress corrosion cracking?
Choosing carbon steel of unknown silicon content for hot sulfur serviceSulfidation rates that vary within one circuit 7What is sulfidation?
Using carbon steel near its transition temperature with as-welded jointsBrittle fracture, which needs a flaw, high stress such as weld residual stress, and low toughness 5What is brittle fracture?

Sources: SSINA 3; HSE 4; NIST 5; OSHA 6; CSB 7.

Common questions

Is stainless steel always more corrosion resistant than carbon steel?
Against general corrosion and rusting, stainless steel is far more resistant because of its chromium film. Against chloride stress corrosion cracking, standard austenitic grades are the weaker choice in warm chloride-bearing water.
Is 9 chrome steel a stainless steel?
No. Stainless steel needs at least 10.5% chromium, and ASME practice treats steels up to 9% chromium as low-alloy.
Why are stainless steel welds inspected differently?
Magnetic particle testing only works on ferromagnetic material, so OSHA guidance points to liquid penetrant testing for austenitic stainless steels.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Alloying Elements · Specialty Steel Industry of North America (SSINA)
  2. 2.Alloy Families · Specialty Steel Industry of North America (SSINA)
  3. 3.Chloride Stress Corrosion Cracking · Specialty Steel Industry of North America (SSINA)
  4. 4.Corrosion / selection of materials (COMAH technical measures) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  5. 5.NIST Special Publication 780, Guidelines for Pressure Vessel Safety Assessment (S. Yukawa) · US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
  6. 6.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  7. 7.Final Investigation Report: Chevron Richmond Refinery Pipe Rupture and Fire · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
  8. 8.Safety Bulletin No. 2005-04-B, BP Texas City, TX Refinery Fire: Positive Material Verification: Prevent Errors During Alloy Steel Systems Maintenance · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
  9. 9.49 CFR 195.112, New pipe · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register