Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactCorrosion and Damage Mechanisms · High-temperature damage

What is sulfidation (high-temperature sulfur corrosion)?

·5 sources

Short answer

Sulfidation is the thinning of steel when sulfur compounds in hot hydrocarbon streams react with iron at high temperature. It is found in every refinery that processes crude oil, and carbon steel thins much faster than higher-chromium steels. API RP 939-C is the industry guidance on avoiding sulfidation failures.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

At the 2012 Richmond, California, refinery fire, the 8-inch line that ruptured had 19 thickness monitoring locations, but none on the pipe section that failed 1. That section contained 0.01% silicon by weight and had thinned badly, while the elbow next to it, with 0.16% silicon and a monitoring location, showed far less thinning 1. The release on August 6, 2012, engulfed 19 workers in a vapor cloud before it ignited, and about 15,000 people from nearby communities later sought medical treatment 1.

What causes sulfidation and where does it occur?

Sulfur compounds that occur naturally in crude oil, hydrogen sulfide (H2S) above all, react directly with the iron in steel and form iron sulfide scale, so the wall slowly loses metal 1,5. Because nearly every crude contains sulfur, the US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) describes sulfidation as present at every refinery that processes crude 1. The rate depends on total sulfur content, which sulfur compounds are present, flow conditions and temperature 1. Hot crude fractions barely conduct electricity, so the reaction is a direct chemical one rather than electrochemical, and it usually runs alongside naphthenic acid corrosion 5.

Temperature sets where it happens. OSHA notes severe corrosion in crude unit furnace tubes and towers where metal temperatures exceed 450 °F (about 230 °C) with sour crude, and in thermal cracking units, cokers included, where metal runs between 450 and 900 °F (about 230 to 480 °C) 3. API's catalog notes that the threshold temperature is debated in industry and is set differently for streams with and without hydrogen 4.

  • Crude and vacuum units: preheat furnaces, bottoms exchangers, atmospheric and vacuum towers, vacuum furnaces and side-cut piping 1,3.
  • Thermal cracking and coking: furnaces, soaking drums, lower towers and hot exchangers 3.
  • Hydrogen service: at the 2010 Anacortes refinery the hottest section of a naphtha hydrotreater exchanger was clad with stainless steel to protect against sulfidation 2. API's catalog adds that significant corrosion has been seen in some hydroprocessing fractionation sections at very low sulfur levels 4.

Why does low-silicon carbon steel matter?

Carbon steel with less than 0.10% silicon by weight can corrode up to 16 times faster than carbon steel with more silicon, according to the CSB 1. Older pipe specifications ASTM A53B and API 5L set no minimum silicon, while ASTM A106 requires at least 0.10% 1. Pipe makers began meeting all three specifications at once in the mid-1980s, but the CSB reported that over 95% of the 144 US refineries were built before 1985, so original piping may mix low- and higher-silicon components in one circuit 1.

That mix can hide from the usual way of monitoring a circuit. Thickness points are usually placed on elbows and fittings, where turbulence normally causes the fastest metal loss, yet fittings generally contain more silicon than straight pipe 1. At Richmond, a 2002 radiographic check had shown the failed section thinning, but the result never became a tracked monitoring location and the section was not inspected again 1.

How is sulfidation found?

  • Thickness measurement. Ultrasonic or radiographic wall thickness at monitoring locations. The lines are hot, so measurements are often made only when the unit is down, for example at a turnaround 1.
  • 100% component inspection. To find low-silicon parts, the CSB described inspecting every component in a circuit once, either by laboratory chemical analysis of metal shavings (the most reliable way) or by measuring the thickness of every component after long enough service for rate differences to show 1. Both require finding every weld, usually by removing insulation 1.
  • Material identification. Many portable positive material identification (PMI) instruments cannot measure silicon well enough, while chromium is easy to verify in the field 1.

What did investigators recommend?

The CSB found that steels with at least 9% chromium resist sulfidation better and avoid large rate differences between components of one circuit, and called them an inherently safer choice 1. It recommended that API revise RP 939-C, RP 571, API 570, RP 578 and RP 574 so that users identify carbon steel circuits that may contain low-silicon components and either inspect every component or replace the piping with a more resistant alloy 1. API's 2025 catalog lists RP 939-C, Guidelines for Avoiding Sulfidation (Sulfidic) Corrosion Failures in Oil Refineries, in its 2nd edition (January 2019, reaffirmed 2024) 4. Its corrosion-rate curves (modified McConomy curves) are not reproduced here 1,5.

Where integrity problems show up

Where it occurs (unit or equipment)Conditions that drive itHow it is usually foundIn the Library
Crude and vacuum unit furnace tubes, transfer and side-cut piping, towersSour crude above about 450 °F (230 °C) metal temperature; sulfur content and species, flow 1,3Ultrasonic thickness at monitoring locations, often during turnarounds 1What is a crude distillation unit?
Carbon steel circuits with pre-1985 pipeLow-silicon components thinning far faster than neighbors 1100% component inspection: lab analysis of shavings, or thickness of every component 1Richmond refinery fire (2012): what investigators found about sulfidation
Straight pipe between monitored fittingsMonitoring placed on higher-silicon elbows and fittings 1Monitoring locations added on straight runs and on any component found thinning 1What are condition monitoring locations (CMLs)?
Thermal cracking and coker furnaces, drums and hot exchangersSour feed at 450 to 900 °F (about 230 to 480 °C) metal temperature 3Wall thickness measurement 1What is a fired heater?
Hydrotreater exchangers and hydroprocessing fractionationHot hydrogen with H2S, kept low in the feed to limit severe corrosion; corrosion seen at very low sulfur in some fractionation sections 3,4Wall thickness measurement 1What is hydroprocessing (hydrotreating and hydrocracking)?
Alloy piping chosen to resist sulfidationChromium content controls the rate 1Portable PMI confirms chromium; it cannot be relied on for silicon 1What is positive material identification (PMI)?

Sources: CSB Report 2012-03-I-CA, 2015 1; CSB Report 2010-08-I-WA, 2014 2; OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2 3; API 2025 catalog 4.

Common questions

Is sulfidation the same as naphthenic acid corrosion?
No. Sulfidation is attack by sulfur compounds; naphthenic acid corrosion is attack by organic acids in crude. Both occur in hot oil and often together, and laboratory work shows they interact through the scale on the steel.
Is sulfidation the same as sulfide stress cracking?
No. Sulfidation is wall thinning in hot hydrocarbons. Sulfide stress cracking is a form of wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S) damage, which occurs in streams that contain water.
Can a hand-held analyzer find low-silicon pipe?
Not reliably. The CSB reported that many portable PMI instruments cannot identify silicon content adequately, so laboratory analysis or a full thickness survey is used.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Final Investigation Report: Chevron Richmond Refinery Pipe Rupture and Fire (Report 2012-03-I-CA) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
  2. 2.Investigation Report: Catastrophic Rupture of Heat Exchanger (Seven Fatalities), Tesoro Anacortes Refinery (Report 2010-08-I-WA) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
  3. 3.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2: Petroleum Refining Processes · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  4. 4.2025 Publications Catalog (entries for RP 939-C and RP 571) (RP 939-C, 2nd edition, January 2019 (reaffirmed January 2024); RP 571, 3rd edition, March 2020) · American Petroleum Institute (API)
  5. 5.High-Temperature Corrosion by Carboxylic Acids and Sulfidation under Refinery Conditions: Mechanism, Model, and Simulation (P. Jin, W. Robbins, G. Bota), Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 57:4329-4339 · American Chemical Society; author copy hosted by Ohio University, Institute for Corrosion and Multiphase Technology ·