Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactCorrosion and Damage Mechanisms · Environmental cracking

What is corrosion fatigue?

·5 sources

Short answer

Corrosion fatigue is cracking caused by cyclic stress acting together with a corrosive environment. The environment lets cracks start and grow at lower stress and after fewer cycles than in dry air, and can remove the fatigue limit below which steel would otherwise last indefinitely. In oil and gas it is reported in deaerators, sucker rods and offshore steel.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

After serious deaerator vessel failures in 1982 and 1983, a National Association of Corrosion Engineers (NACE) task group surveyed industry and found cracking in over 30% of 84 vessels; surveys in individual industries reported 42% and 50% 1. Corrosion fatigue appeared to be the main mechanism of crack formation and growth, and cracking was generally limited to welds in vessels without post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) 1,2. Deaerators remove oxygen from boiler feedwater in refineries, chemical plants, power stations, pulp and paper mills, hospitals and schools 2.

How does corrosion fatigue work?

Ordinary fatigue cracking comes from cyclic stress, either mechanical, such as pressure cycling, or thermal, from repeated temperature changes; cracks usually start at high-stress spots such as changes in shape and welds 1. Corrosion fatigue adds a corrosive environment. Cyclic straining is thought to break the protective surface film, corrosion then speeds up at the bare metal, and failure comes at lower loads and in less time than in a benign environment 3.

Two features set it apart from fatigue in air 3,4:

  • No safe stress level. In a corrosive environment the stress below which a metal would last indefinitely is lowered or disappears, so there is no fatigue limit 3. No metal is immune to some loss of fatigue resistance in a corrosive environment 3.
  • Mutual damage. Corrosion pits reduce the section and concentrate stress, which speeds fatigue cracking; fatigue cracks in turn break through protective layers and open fresh sites for corrosion, so the two damages do not simply add up 4.

The cracks are brittle in appearance and mostly transgranular (through the grains), like many stress corrosion cracks, but usually unbranched; corrosion often widens the crack after it forms 3. For carbon and low-alloy steels, the US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) names hot water with small amounts of dissolved oxygen as an environment that speeds fatigue crack growth 1.

Where does corrosion fatigue occur in oil and gas?

  • Deaerators and feedwater storage vessels. These carbon steel vessels run up to about 2.1 MPa (300 psi) and 150 °C (300 °F), with walls generally under 25 mm (1 in) 1,2. Water hammer was the only design or operating factor that correlated with cracking 1,2.
  • Sucker rods in pumping oil wells. Rods work in brines of varying corrosivity, so the same rod can last differently from well to well 5. In tests to 20 million cycles, the endurance limit of one rod steel fell from 72 MPa in distilled water to 49 MPa in formation water and 30 MPa in an environment simulating hydrogen sulfide (H2S) 5.
  • Offshore and marine steel structures. Structures built for cyclic loads often sit in aggressive environments, and a 2022 study notes that design codes had no codified procedure for fatigue checks of steel under ongoing corrosion 4.
  • Vessels whose duty changes. Changes in production schedules or flow routing can raise cyclic stressing enough that a benign condition becomes critical 1.

How is corrosion fatigue found?

For deaerators, the recommendations prepared by the Technical Association of the Pulp and Paper Industry (TAPPI), the National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors and NACE all called for special attention to the internal surface of every weld and heat-affected zone, using wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing (WFMT) 1,2. TAPPI and NACE also set inspector qualification levels and reinspection intervals graded by condition: repaired vessels, vessels with unrepaired indications and crack-free vessels 2.

Once cracks are found, fracture mechanics is used to judge whether they can stay in service 1. For one group of deaerators, cracks running across the weld were judged acceptable at low pressure stresses, while cracks parallel to the weld were repaired at any stress; NIST notes this result applied to that group only 1.

How is corrosion fatigue controlled?

The measures listed by the Association for Materials Protection and Performance (AMPP) work on either side of the mechanism 3:

  • Lower the cyclic stress. Remove or reduce cyclic stresses and stress concentrations, shape critical sections well, and avoid rapid changes of load, temperature or pressure 3.
  • Avoid vibration. Avoid designs that produce or transmit vibration, and raise natural frequency to avoid resonance 3.
  • Weaken the corrosion side. Use a more resistant material or make the environment less corrosive 3.

For sucker rods, surface hardening that leaves compressive residual stress, anti-corrosion varnishes or enamels and corrosion inhibitors are used; the compressive stress decayed over three years of well service 5.

Where integrity problems show up

Where it occurs (unit or equipment)Conditions that drive itHow it is usually foundIn the Library
Deaerators and feedwater storage vesselsWater hammer; hot feedwater; welds without PWHT 1,2WFMT of all internal welds and heat-affected zones 1,2What is oxygen corrosion in water systems?
Welds and shape changes in cyclically loaded vesselsPressure or temperature cycling, start-stop operation, leaking valves 1Inspection focused on welds and high-stress regions 1,2What is mechanical and vibration fatigue?
Cracks found at deaerator weldsCrack orientation to the weld and stress level 1Fracture mechanics assessment 1How are crack-like flaws assessed for fitness-for-service?
Sucker rods in pumping wellsFormation brine; H2S causing hydrogen uptake 5Fatigue tests of rods in well fluids; rod condition after service 5Sour service
Offshore and marine steel structuresPitting that concentrates stress under cyclic load 4Corrosion degree estimated from field monitoring and fed into fatigue checks 4What is corrosion monitoring and which methods are used?

Sources: NIST SP 780, 1990 1; OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3 2; Milone and Landolfo, 2022 4; Gara, Fedorovych and Kopey, 2023 5.

Common questions

How is corrosion fatigue different from stress corrosion cracking?
Stress corrosion cracking needs a tensile stress, a susceptible material and an environment that attacks that material. Corrosion fatigue needs cyclic stress, and any corrosive environment reduces fatigue resistance to some degree. Its cracks are usually unbranched, while stress corrosion cracks often branch. See [What is stress corrosion cracking (SCC)?](/library/stress-corrosion-cracking/).
Does steel have a fatigue limit in seawater or process water?
No. AMPP notes that, unlike fatigue in air, corrosion-assisted fatigue has no fatigue limit load.
Is it the same as mechanical fatigue?
It is the same cracking process with an environment added. Fatigue from cyclic stress alone is purely stress related; adding a corrosive environment lowers the stress and time to failure. See [What is mechanical and vibration fatigue?](/library/mechanical-vibration-fatigue/).

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.NIST Special Publication 780, Guidelines for Pressure Vessel Safety Assessment (S. Yukawa) · US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
  2. 2.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  3. 3.Corrosion Fatigue (IMPACT corrosion basics page) · Association for Materials Protection and Performance (AMPP)
  4. 4.A Simplified Approach for the Corrosion Fatigue Assessment of Steel Structures in Aggressive Environments (A. Milone, R. Landolfo), Materials 15(6):2210 · MDPI (open access; full text at PubMed Central) ·
  5. 5.A study of the resistance of sucker rods to fatigue failure (P. Gara, Y. Fedorovych, B. Kopey), Mining - Informatics, Automation and Electrical Engineering No. 3 (555) · AGH University of Krakow (open access, CC BY 4.0)