What happens after an in-line inspection run?
After an in-line inspection (ILI) run, the reported anomalies are reviewed, ranked by urgency, and the most severe are excavated, examined and repaired. US rules (49 CFR 192.933 for gas, 195.452(h) for liquids) give operators 180 days to decide whether a condition threatens integrity, then set immediate, scheduled and monitored categories.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
In May 2015 a crude oil pipeline ruptured near Refugio State Beach in Santa Barbara County, California, at a corrosion anomaly that a 2012 inspection had sized at 45% of the wall; after the failure, the deepest point measured 89% 1. The Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) found that the inspection data did not meet the tool's published depth accuracy, and that the operator's own procedure, which added 10% to called depths, would have put the 2012 call at 55%; the anomaly was not excavated 1. About 2,934 barrels of heavy crude were released, about 500 of them reaching the Pacific Ocean 1.
What are the steps after the tool comes out?
| Step | What happens | Where the rule sets it |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Final report | The tool data are analyzed and anomalies reported; API Std 1163 covers qualification, reporting, verification and validation of ILI systems 6 | Operators must follow API Std 1163, ASNT ILI-PQ and NACE SP0102 (192.493, 195.591) 5 |
| 2. Qualified review | Reported sizes are evaluated with tool tolerance, detection threshold and sizing accuracy in mind, unless measured directly 4 | 192.712(e)(1); 195.452(c) and (f)(8) 3,4 |
| 3. Discovery | The operator gathers enough information to decide whether each condition threatens integrity, no later than 180 days after the assessment, or notifies PHMSA 2,3 | 192.933(b); 195.452(h)(2) |
| 4. Prioritize | Each condition is placed in a repair category with a deadline 2,3 | 192.933(c), (d); 195.452(h)(4) |
| 5. Reduce pressure if needed | Gas: no more than 80% of the operating pressure at discovery, or a level based on predicted failure pressure; liquid: at least 20% if no suitable calculation method exists 2,3 | 192.933(a)(1); 195.452(h)(4)(i) |
| 6. Excavate and examine | The anomaly is measured in the ditch; cracks must be examined with technology validated for tight cracks, such as phased array ultrasonic testing (PAUT) 2 | 192.933(e) |
| 7. Repair and record | Cut out and replace the pipe, or use a repair shown by engineering tests to restore serviceability; keep analysis records for the life of the pipeline 4,8 | 192.713; 192.712(g) |
| 8. Feed back | Compare tool calls with field results, update growth estimates and set the next assessment 3,4,11 | 192.712(e)(1); 192.939; 195.452(j) |
Sources: 49 CFR 192.493, 192.712, 192.713, 192.933, 192.939, 195.452, 195.591 2,3,4,5,8,11; API 2025 catalog 6.
How are anomalies ranked for repair?
For segments in high consequence areas (HCAs), the gas rule and the liquid rule sort conditions into categories that do not line up one to one 2,3:
| Category | Gas transmission, 192.933(d) 2 | Hazardous liquid, 195.452(h)(4) 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Immediate (reduce pressure or shut down until repaired) | Predicted failure pressure at or below 1.1 times maximum allowable operating pressure (MAOP); metal loss over 80% of nominal wall; dent on the upper two-thirds with metal loss, cracking or a stress riser, unless analysis clears it; crack plus metal loss deeper than 50% of wall | Metal loss over 80% of nominal wall; predicted burst pressure below maximum operating pressure (MOP); dent on the top of the pipe with metal loss, cracking or a stress riser, or deeper than 6% of diameter |
| Scheduled | One year: for example, metal loss with predicted failure pressure below 1.39 times MAOP (Class 2) or 1.50 times (Class 3 and 4); smooth top dents deeper than 6% of diameter, unless analysis clears them | 60 days: top dents deeper than 3% of diameter; bottom dents with metal loss, cracking or a stress riser. 180 days: for example, general corrosion over 50% of wall, a confirmed crack, corrosion along a seam weld |
| Monitored | Less severe dents and seam or crack conditions; repaired if expected to reach a one-year condition before the next assessment | No monitored list; any other condition that could impair integrity must be evaluated and scheduled as appropriate |
| Evaluator's judgment | Any anomaly the designated evaluator judges to need immediate action | Same |
Sources: 49 CFR 192.933 and 195.452, current eCFR text 2,3.
Outside HCAs, other sections set the deadlines. Onshore gas transmission lines that the integrity management subpart does not cover follow the repair criteria of 49 CFR 192.714, added in August 2022; they too rank conditions by urgency, and the line must run below its predicted failure pressure while a repair is made 9. Onshore liquid lines that can take an ILI tool but fall outside 195.452 need a first assessment by 1 October 2029 and another at least every 10 calendar years, and the operator must allow for tool tolerance and unity chart plots, or an equivalent, when it identifies anomalies 10.
Predicted failure pressure for corrosion comes from a remaining strength method such as ASME B31G or RSTRENG 3,4; see ASME B31G vs RSTRENG: how is corroded pipe assessed?.
How are inspection results checked against the pipe?
Each dig is also a check on the tool. The gas rule names unity chart plots, or an equivalent, among the ways to determine uncertainty and verify tool performance 4. Both investigations below turned on this step:
- Santa Barbara County, California, 2015. PHMSA found little documentation comparing field measurements with tool calls, and no record that discrepancies in 2007 and 2012 were taken up with the inspection vendor, as the operator's program required 1.
- Marshall, Michigan, 2010. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found that crack depths from a 2005 run were used without the tool's stated tolerance, and that corrosion beside cracks made the crack tool report them shallower than they were 7.
After Marshall, NTSB asked the Pipeline Research Council International to review tool tolerance, probability of detection and probability of identification, and to give operators a step-by-step model for interacting corrosion and crack threats (P-12-18) 7.
Where integrity problems show up
| Decision | Data it depends on | What goes wrong without it | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Which anomalies to dig | Tool calls adjusted for tolerance and growth | Santa Barbara County, California, 2015: an anomaly called at 45% in 2012 was not dug and failed at 89% 1 | What is in-line inspection (ILI) and pigging? |
| Whether the tool performs as specified | Field measurements compared with tool calls | Same case: vendor data did not meet the published accuracy of plus or minus 10% of wall, 80% of the time 1 | Probability of detection (POD) |
| How cracks are judged against corrosion | Crack tool data and fracture mechanics | Marshall, Michigan, 2010: a lower safety margin for cracks than for corrosion left six crack-like defects in the line from 2005 to the rupture 7 | How are crack-like flaws assessed for fitness-for-service? |
| Whether overlapping threats are combined | Corrosion and crack data from different runs | Same case: no procedure accounted for corrosion next to cracks when building the dig list 7 | What is corrosion fatigue? |
Sources: PHMSA failure investigation report (2016) 1; NTSB PAR-12/01 (2012) 7.
Common questions
- What happens outside high consequence areas?
- Gas transmission lines outside HCAs follow repair criteria in 49 CFR 192.714, added in 2022. Liquid lines that can take ILI tools must be assessed under 195.416, first by 1 October 2029, and conditions found are remediated under 195.401.
- Why is the discovery date important?
- Repair deadlines run from discovery, not from the inspection date, and the rules allow up to 180 days to reach discovery unless the operator shows that is impracticable and notifies PHMSA.
- Does a dig always end in a repair?
- No. Conditions in the monitored category can stay in service and be watched at later assessments, unless they are expected to reach a one-year condition first.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Failure Investigation Report: Plains Pipeline, LP, Line 901, Crude Oil Release, May 19, 2015, Santa Barbara County, California · US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)
- 2.49 CFR 192.933, What actions must be taken to address integrity issues? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 3.49 CFR 195.452, Pipeline integrity management in high consequence areas · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 4.49 CFR 192.712, Analysis of predicted failure pressure and critical strain level · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 5.49 CFR 192.493 and 195.591, In-line inspection of pipelines · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 6.2025 Publications Catalog (entry for Std 1163, In-Line Inspection Systems Qualification) (Std 1163, 3rd edition, September 2021) · American Petroleum Institute (API)
- 7.Pipeline Accident Report NTSB/PAR-12/01: Enbridge Incorporated Hazardous Liquid Pipeline Rupture and Release, Marshall, Michigan, July 25, 2010 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ·
- 8.49 CFR 192.713, Transmission lines: Permanent field repair of imperfections and damages · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 9.49 CFR 192.714, Transmission lines: Repair criteria for onshore transmission pipelines · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 10.49 CFR 195.416, Pipeline assessments · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 11.49 CFR 192.939, What are the required reassessment intervals? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register