What is metal dusting?
Metal dusting is severe high-temperature corrosion in which iron-, nickel- and cobalt-based alloys break down into a dust of metal, carbon and oxides. It occurs in carbon-rich gases, typically between about 400 and 800 °C, and causes deep pits and heavy metal loss, mainly in hydrogen, syngas, ammonia and methanol plants.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
Metal dusting attacks the stainless steels and nickel alloys chosen for hot, carbon-rich service, not only carbon steel: a 2002 study notes that iron, nickel and cobalt, and the alloys based on them, are all susceptible 3. Avoiding it has shaped plant design. A US Department of Energy (DOE) fact sheet notes that reformer plants have long quenched hot process gas with water from about 800 to 400 °C (about 1,470 to 750 °F) to avoid metal dusting attack, giving up high-grade heat 1. A 2011 review describes the outcome of metal dusting as severe metal loss from process units, with costly maintenance and serious safety issues 4.
How does metal dusting happen?
It needs a gas that is supersaturated in carbon, meaning its carbon activity is above 1, such as mixtures of carbon monoxide and hydrogen 3,5. Sources give the damaging temperature range as about 400 to 800 °C (about 750 to 1,470 °F) 1,5, or 300 to 850 °C in one study of pure metals 3.
In iron and steel, carbon collects at the surface and forms an unstable iron carbide, which then breaks down as graphite grows into it; iron atoms migrate into the graphite and are carried off as fine particles 3. Nickel and cobalt form no such carbide, so their atoms pass into the graphite directly 3. What is left is a deposit of carbon holding metal particles, carbides and oxides 5.
Alloys resist only while a protective oxide scale stays intact. Researchers at Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) found chromium oxide the most protective scale in a reformer environment, while iron-rich spinel oxides could be reduced by carbon 1. Attack starts where the oxide breaks down and grows as pits 1,3.
Where does it occur?
- Hydrogen, ammonia, methanol and syngas production. DOE lists hydrogen production, ammonia synthesis, methanol reforming and syngas production, as well as catalyst regeneration units in the chemical and petroleum industries 2.
- Heat recovery equipment. ANL names waste heat boilers and gas bypass lines in methanol and ammonia reformer plants, along with gas-to-liquids plants 1.
- Steam reforming in general. The 2011 review calls steam reforming the setting where metal dusting is most often met 4.
- Coked furnace coils. Coke on the inner walls of cracking furnace coils favors carburization and metal dusting at service temperatures 6.
What reduces it?
- Alloy chemistry. ANL developed alloys that form a chromium oxide scale; in a laboratory test they stayed smooth for 5,700 hours, while commercial alloys in the same environment developed large pits 1.
- Water vapor and temperature. In tests at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), raising the temperature from 550 to 750 °C generally reduced attack in one gas mixture, and adding water vapor at 650 °C reduced it too; the more highly alloyed specimens kept a thin protective oxide for 5,000 hours at 9.1 atmospheres with 20% water vapor 5.
- Coatings and surface treatments. A 2011 review covered protective coatings alongside ways of changing the surface itself: adding elements that poison the carburizing reaction, alloying the surface layer, and treating it chemically, mechanically or by laser 4.
- Process design. Quenching hot gas through the damaging range avoids it, at a cost in recovered heat 1.
Laboratory rankings need care. With little or no water vapor, ORNL found iron-base alloys less resistant than nickel-base alloys, but the authors note that plant gases can contain up to 40% water vapor at high pressure, and that one plant study reported better results for iron-base alloys 5.
How is metal dusting found?
The sources reviewed for this page describe metal dusting by the damage it leaves, local pits and metal loss under carbon-rich deposits, rather than by a dedicated field inspection method 1,5. In the laboratory, ANL used Raman spectroscopy to tell protective from unprotective oxide scales 1. ORNL notes that a lack of attack in short tests may only reflect the time attack takes to start 5. Pits and wall loss are forms of local metal loss; for the methods used to find those, see What are the main non-destructive testing (NDT) methods in oil and gas?.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hydrogen and syngas plant reformer outlet systems, waste heat boilers and gas bypass lines | Carbon-rich gas held or cooled through about 400 to 800 °C 1,2 | As local pits and metal loss on exposed surfaces; no dedicated field method in the sources reviewed 1 | What are the main non-destructive testing (NDT) methods in oil and gas? |
| Ammonia and methanol reformer plants | Same hot, carbon-rich gas service 1,2 | Seen as pitting and mass wastage of alloy components 1 | Metal loss |
| Cracking furnace coils with coke | Coke on inner walls at high service temperatures 6 | Metallography of tubes removed after service 6 | What is a petrochemical plant? |
| Alloys whose chromium oxide scale fails | Iron-rich oxides reduced by carbon; scale defects 1,5 | Laboratory exposure tests with pit measurement and oxide analysis 1,5 | What is carburization? |
Sources: DOE fact sheets on ANL work 1,2; ORNL, 2015 5; Orlikowski and others, 2021 6.
Common questions
- Is metal dusting the same as carburization?
- It is closely related. Carburization takes carbon into the metal and embrittles it, while metal dusting, which the 2011 review calls a catastrophic form of carburization attack, breaks the metal down into dust. See [What is carburization?](/library/carburization/).
- Does stainless steel resist metal dusting?
- Not reliably. In ANL's tests, Type 310 stainless steel pitted where its surface lacked chromium oxide, and commercial alloys developed large pits in the same environment.
- Why does steam or water vapor help?
- In ORNL's tests, adding water vapor reduced or prevented attack, and the authors note that water vapor is commonly used in plant operation.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Argonne National Laboratory Develops Alloys to Resist Metal Dusting (fact sheet) · US Department of Energy, Industrial Technologies Program
- 2.Development of Materials Resistant to Metal Dusting Degradation (project fact sheet) · US Department of Energy, Industrial Technologies Program
- 3.On the Mechanism of Metal Dusting Corrosion (C. M. Chun, J. D. Mumford, T. A. Ramanarayanan), meeting abstract 1111 · The Electrochemical Society, 201st Meeting
- 4.Metal Dusting Protective Coatings. A Literature Review (A. Agüero and others), Oxidation of Metals 76: 23-42 (repository record and abstract) · INTA (Spanish National Institute for Aerospace Technology) institutional repository ·
- 5.Performance of Chromia- and Alumina-Forming Fe- and Ni-base Alloys Exposed to Metal Dusting Environments: The Effect of Water Vapor and Temperature (A. Rouaix-Vande Put, K. A. Unocic, M. P. Brady, B. A. Pint), Corrosion Science 92 · Oak Ridge National Laboratory, via US DOE Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)
- 6.Investigation of the 0.4C-35Cr-45Ni-Nb Alloy after Service in High-Temperature Steam and Hydrocarbons Environment (J. Orlikowski and others), Materials 14(20):6139 · MDPI, via PubMed Central (open access, CC BY 4.0) ·