Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactProcurement and Supply Chain · Fabrication quality

What is modular construction in oil and gas?

·6 sources

Short answer

Modular construction in oil and gas means building large parts of a plant in a fabrication yard, then shipping, lifting and connecting them at site. Modules range from equipment skids and pipe racks to whole process units. Welding and testing move away from remote or crowded sites, but design must be frozen earlier and modules need heavy transport.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

Building a plant in modules moves much of the work to a yard, but not all of it: civil works, heavy transport and lifting, and the connections between modules still happen at site 1. A 2024 position paper by DECHEMA, the German society for chemical engineering and biotechnology, notes that process and design data must be frozen earlier than for a plant built in place, so late changes cost more 1. It also notes that module interfaces that do not line up are comparatively costly to correct at site, and it recommends choosing between approaches before engineering begins 1.

How is modular construction different from stick-built construction?

In stick-built construction, almost all work happens at the plant site: civil works, equipment setting, field piping, and electrical and instrument installation 1. In modular construction, work moves to a yard or workshop. Module size is set by what can be transported or lifted economically, from container-sized skids to whole plants moved as mega-modules, and a packaged unit is the simplest case 1.

AspectStick-builtModular
Where most work is doneAt the plant siteIn a fabrication yard, then setting and hook-up at site
ScheduleMostly sequential, after the construction permitSite and module work in parallel; module work can start before the permit
Tests before start-upDone on siteRadiography, pressure tests and loop checks can be done in the yard
Design changesPossible later, at rising costDesign data frozen earlier; late changes cost more
Site needsLarge workforce and laydown areaHeavy-haul access, prepared ground and large cranes; less laydown
Construction qualityDepends on the local workforceSteadier yard conditions; judged better
Weight and logisticsLess structural steelMore structural steel, higher logistics cost, possible import duties
InterfacesMisfits seen and fixed as work proceedsRisk of misaligned interfaces between modules

Source: DECHEMA position paper, 2024 1.

Why do oil and gas projects build in modules?

DECHEMA gives three main reasons to move work off site: a remote or harsh site such as deep sea, desert or permafrost; high labor cost at site; and congestion from peak site labor 1. Yard work can also be cheaper because of lower labor rates, higher productivity in controlled conditions and established prefabrication processes, and yards are expected to have better safety performance 1.

Small units can also be repeated. An export terminal at Elba Island, Georgia, liquefies natural gas in 10 small, portable units of about 0.03 billion cubic feet per day each, built in two phases 3,4. In 2019 the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported that they were scheduled to enter service one after another at one-month intervals, at an existing import terminal whose tanks and pipelines they share 3.

What are the trade-offs?

A 2013 Politecnico di Milano thesis, based on the literature and a survey of five Italian engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contractors, listed lower cost and shorter schedule, better quality and safety, and lower social and environmental impact as the main advantages 2. The disadvantages it found were more material, more construction effort and more coordination, because module activities depend on each other and happen earlier in the project 2.

DECHEMA adds that the space inside modules designed for transport can restrict maintenance access 1. On cost, it expects modular construction to save money mainly where site labor is expensive; where labor is cheap, schedule, productivity and safety may be the reasons to choose it 1.

How is quality checked on modules?

Because modules are completed in the yard, many pre-commissioning activities move there too; DECHEMA cites X-ray examination, pressure testing and loop checks 1. The yard therefore produces the weld examination, heat treatment and pressure test records that OSHA lists as inputs to later safety assessment of pressure vessels 5. Under US process safety management rules, a pre-startup safety review must still confirm, before highly hazardous chemicals are introduced, that construction and equipment match the design specifications 6. Yard checks are usually set out in an inspection and test plan.

Where integrity problems show up

Decision or step at this stageWhat it affects laterIn the Library
Fitting equipment into a module sized for transportLimited space inside modules can restrict maintenance access 1How do you design equipment so it can be inspected?
Doing radiography and pressure tests in the yardThose records become part of the baseline for later safety assessment of the equipment 1,5What is weld mapping and weld traceability?; What documents are handed over when a project is completed?
Connecting modules at siteA pre-startup safety review must confirm construction matches the design before hazardous chemicals are introduced 6What is a pre-startup safety review (PSSR)?

Sources: DECHEMA position paper, 2024 1; OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3 5; 29 CFR 1910.119(i) 6.

Common questions

Is a skid the same as a module?
A skid is a small module. DECHEMA treats container-sized skids and packaged units as the smallest forms of modular construction.
How is modular construction different from a modular flexible plant?
Modular construction moves the building of one plant design off site. A modular flexible plant uses standardized functional modules that can be rearranged, reused or moved; DECHEMA puts typical capacities at about 1 to 30 kilotonnes per year.
Does modular construction always cost less?
No. Heavier steel, logistics and possible import duties offset part of the yard savings, and DECHEMA expects clear cost advantages mainly where site labor is expensive.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Cost Engineering for Modular Plants: Position paper for the evaluation of different plant setups, construction, and operational concepts · DECHEMA Gesellschaft für Chemische Technik und Biotechnologie e.V. (working groups Cost Engineering and Modular Plants)
  2. 2.Modularità d'impianto: analisi delle best practices presso i maggiori EPC contractors italiani (P. Androni, master's thesis, abstract page) · Politecnico di Milano (POLITesi) ·
  3. 3.Natural Gas Weekly Update, In the News: Elba Island, the sixth U.S. LNG export terminal, begins commercial operations · US Energy Information Administration (EIA) ·
  4. 4.Natural Gas Weekly Update, In the News: U.S. liquefaction capacity continues to expand · US Energy Information Administration (EIA) ·
  5. 5.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  6. 6.29 CFR 1910.119, Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register