Online vs offline corrosion monitoring
Online corrosion monitoring uses probes or sensors that stay in place and report while the plant runs, intermittently or continuously. Offline monitoring takes samples or readings that are analyzed later, such as coupons weighed after removal or periodic thickness surveys. ASTM G96 covers online electrical and electrochemical methods; coupon methods need the coupon withdrawn.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
A corrosion coupon reports one average over its whole exposure, so it cannot show whether the metal was lost at the start of that period or at the end 3. Coupons usually stay in for months and give no real-time information 2, while an online polarization resistance probe can show a change in corrosion rate within minutes 1. Online probes average too: in a US national laboratory study of tank-bottom sand, a fit to five data points put the coupons' pitting rate at roughly 10 times their surface-average rate, a difference an averaged probe reading does not show directly 4. Each approach answers a different question, which is why the Institute of Corrosion (ICorr) describes trending probes and coupons together 3.
Online vs offline corrosion monitoring at a glance
| Online monitoring | Offline monitoring | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical methods | Electrical resistance (ER) probes, linear polarization resistance (LPR) probes 1; permanently installed ultrasonic sensors 5 | Mass-loss coupons 2; hand-held ultrasonic and radiographic surveys 3,5 |
| How a result is produced | Read electrically in place, without removing the device 1 | Coupon withdrawn, cleaned and weighed in a laboratory 2; survey readings taken at intervals 5 |
| Time resolution | LPR within minutes 1; ER and sensor trends logged intermittently or continuously 1,5 | One average per exposure, often months for coupons 2; months or years between surveys 5 |
| What the number means | ER: cumulative loss of the probe element; LPR: instantaneous general corrosion rate 1; fixed ultrasonic sensor: wall thickness of the asset 5 | Coupon: actual metal loss of a sample 2; survey: wall thickness at each point read 5 |
| Form of attack | Averaged over the element, so pits are not resolved 1,4 | Coupon surface shows general, localized, microbial or erosion attack 3 |
| Conditions | LPR needs a conductive liquid; ER also works in oil, gas and air 2; powered sensors must meet intrinsic safety rules in flammable areas 2 | Coupons can be made of any metal and shape 3; laboratory analysis delays the result 2 |
| Coverage | Point sensors 2 | Coupons are point samples 2; surveys reach many points, but hand-held readings scatter by about 0.25 to 1 mm 5 |
| Data | Digital, easy to pass to computers for analysis 1; wireless links exist 3 | Laboratory reports and survey records |
Sources: ASTM G96 public scope page 1; Wright et al., NETL review, 2019 2; ICorr, 2014 3; Shukla et al., SRNL 4; Gajdacsi, Imperial College London thesis, 2015 5.
When is online monitoring used?
- To catch process upsets early. ASTM G96 describes online electrical and electrochemical methods as an early warning that allows action before significant damage 1.
- To control corrosion inhibitors. A rising rate can signal that more inhibitor is needed 1. ICorr lists alarms for loss of inhibition and tuning of chemical dose rates, with high-resolution ER probes where corrosivity changes quickly 3.
- To track erosion. ER elements made of a corrosion resistant alloy lose metal only by erosion, and ICorr notes their use alongside acoustic sand monitors 3.
- Where manual readings are hard to get. Permanently installed ultrasonic sensors read pipes that would otherwise need insulation stripped, excavation or scaffolding 5.
- Under storage tanks. ER probes placed in the sand pad beneath a tank floor tracked soil-side corrosion and detected inhibitor dosing in a Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) study 4.
When is offline monitoring used?
- To measure real metal loss. A 2019 review by researchers at the US National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) calls coupon weight loss the longest-used method and still the reference for corrosion rate 2.
- To see the form of attack. A coupon can be examined for general corrosion, local attack, microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC) or erosion, and its retrieval allows swabs of scale and bacteria 3.
- To check online readings. ASTM G96 notes that polarization resistance may need calibration against other techniques to give true rates 1.
- To survey many locations. Thickness surveys move between points in a circuit, although a 2003 report for the US Minerals Management Service (MMS) called manual grid readings tedious and of limited accuracy 6.
How do intrusive and non-intrusive methods fit in?
ICorr sorts monitoring a second way: intrusive devices sit in the process stream, and non-intrusive methods work from outside the wall 3. The two axes are independent.
| Intrusive (in the process stream) | Non-intrusive (outside the wall) | |
|---|---|---|
| Online | ER and LPR probes 1,3 | Permanently installed ultrasonic sensors 5; field signature method, which reads voltage patterns from pins attached to the outer wall 6 |
| Offline | Mass-loss coupons 2,3 | Hand-held ultrasonic and radiographic surveys 3,5 |
A common mix-up. "Online" describes how the result is read, not whether containment is broken. Coupons and probes are often pulled from live lines through pressurized access fittings. ICorr states that on-line retrieval is safe provided set conditions are met, including trained two-person teams, back-pressurization and pressure-retaining covers. It also notes that a shutdown-only policy can leave locations unserviced for years 3. ASTM G96 also counts intermittent readings as online, so online does not always mean continuous 1.
Where integrity problems show up
| What it finds well | What it can miss or get wrong | In the Library |
|---|---|---|
| Online ER and LPR: a rise in corrosivity after an upset or a lapse in inhibitor dosing 1,3 | Pits: both report averaged metal loss; in the SRNL sand tests, coupon pitting rates were about 10 times the surface-average rates 1,4 | What is pitting corrosion?, How do corrosion inhibitors work? |
| Offline coupons: actual metal loss and the form of attack, plus scale and bacteria samples 3 | When during the exposure the loss happened 3 | What is microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC)? |
| Online fixed ultrasonic sensors: the wall loss trend of the equipment itself 5 | Thinning between monitored points; probes, coupons and sensors are all point measurements 2 | What are permanently installed ultrasonic thickness sensors? |
| Offline thickness surveys: readings across many points in a circuit 5,6 | Short-term rate changes, hidden by reading scatter of about 0.25 to 1 mm 5 | How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work? |
| Online ER in a tank's sand pad: soil-side corrosion and the effect of an inhibitor 4 | Floor areas the probe does not represent, for example if it sits near an inhibitor dosing point that the floor itself does not benefit from 4 | What is soil corrosion? |
Sources: ASTM G96 1; Wright et al., 2019 2; ICorr, 2014 3; Shukla et al., SRNL 4; Gajdacsi, 2015 5; US Minerals Management Service riser report, 2003 6.
Common questions
- Can coupons be removed without shutting down?
- Yes. ICorr describes on-line retrieval through access fittings by trained teams using back-pressurization, with each location assessed for risk; locations with no service history are serviced during shutdown.
- Do ER probes and coupons give the same rate?
- In the SRNL tests, ER probes measured surface-average rates that matched the coupons, with a possible time lag, but did not capture the deeper pitting. See [Corrosion coupons vs electrical resistance (ER) probes](/library/corrosion-coupons-vs-er-probes/).
- Which standard covers online monitoring?
- ASTM G96 covers online electrical resistance and polarization resistance methods in plant equipment, and contrasts them with coupon methods that require entering the system.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.ASTM G96, Standard Guide for Online Monitoring of Corrosion in Plant Equipment (Electrical and Electrochemical Methods) (product page, Scope and Significance and Use) (G96-90(2018) shown; edition not relied on) · ASTM International
- 2.Corrosion Sensors for Structural Health Monitoring of Oil and Natural Gas Infrastructure: A Review (R. F. Wright et al.), Sensors 19(18):3964 · MDPI, via PubMed Central (authors at the US National Energy Technology Laboratory) ·
- 3.Corrosion Monitoring & Data Trending (2014 Corrosion Awareness Day presentation) · Institute of Corrosion (ICorr), UK ·
- 4.Monitoring Effectiveness of Vapor Corrosion Inhibitors for Tank Bottom Corrosion Using Electrical Resistance Probes and Coupons (P. K. Shukla et al.) · Savannah River National Laboratory, US Department of Energy (SRS scientific and technical information record C2019-13100)
- 5.High accuracy ultrasonic degradation monitoring (PhD thesis, A. Gajdacsi) · Imperial College London (Spiral repository)
- 6.Evaluation of Methods for Detecting and Monitoring of Corrosion and Fatigue Damage in Risers (M. Lozev, B. Grimmett, E. Shell, R. Spencer), final report, Technical Assessment Program project 433 · US Minerals Management Service (now Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement, BSEE) ·