What is polythionic acid stress corrosion cracking?
Polythionic acid stress corrosion cracking is intergranular cracking of sensitized austenitic stainless steels and other austenitic alloys. It typically occurs in refinery units handling sulfur-bearing streams, during shutdowns, when sulfide scale reacts with air and moisture to form polythionic acids that attack chromium-poor grain boundaries under stress. NACE RP0170 covers protection during shutdowns.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
Polythionic acid stress corrosion cracking (PTA SCC, also written PASCC) strikes during shutdowns, not in operation 1,3. A 2002 case study described the stainless steel heater coil of a naphtha hydrotreater that had been shut down and restarted several times over about 18 years, then was found extensively cracked after one shutdown; the alkaline neutralizing wash had not been documented or followed properly, and its protective film had been rinsed off with water 1. A 2011 failure analysis of stabilized 347 furnace tubes in a hydrocracker, which failed after a shutdown at nearly 8 years, also pointed to errors in the shutdown procedure 2.
How does polythionic acid cracking happen?
Three things must meet: a sulfide scale, a sensitized austenitic alloy under tensile stress, and air plus moisture 1,3.
- In operation, scale forms and the metal may sensitize. Hydroprocessing units run without oxygen, which favors iron and other metal sulfide scales on hot surfaces 3. Long exposure to heat forms chromium carbides at grain boundaries and leaves the zones beside them short of chromium (sensitization) 3,6.
- At shutdown, acids form. When equipment is opened, oxygen enters with air, and moisture comes from humidity, washing or steaming out; together they turn the sulfide scale into polythionic acids, a family of sulfur acids written H2SxOy 1,3.
- Under stress, cracks follow the grain boundaries. The acids dissolve the chromium-poor zones, and laboratory work with a tetrathionate solution showed the crack tip advancing along grain boundaries as load was applied, so stress matters as well as dissolution 4.
Researchers have debated which sulfur acid does the damage: early work in the 1960s pointed to polythionic acids, another view to sulfurous acid, and a 1984 study to tetrathionic acid as the only one of them that cracks sensitized 304 1.
Which equipment and materials are susceptible?
- Sensitized austenitic alloys. The cracking affects sensitized austenitic stainless steels and other austenitic alloys 3. How much sensitization and stress it takes is not well understood; sensitization proceeds faster at higher temperature and depends on composition 3.
- Hydroprocessing units. Reactor circuit sections often operate in the sensitizing range, and stainless heater tubes can be attacked on both inside and outside surfaces 3.
- Equipment hotter than the process. In the 2002 case the process stream was 330 °C, which seemed too cool to sensitize the coil, but tube metal temperature in the fired heater was about 405 °C 1. Early researchers thought service below 800 °F (427 °C) would not sensitize these steels, yet a 304 flange in a hydrodesulfurizer cracked after about 15.75 years at up to 384 °C 1.
- Stabilized grades under local overheating. Grades stabilized with titanium or niobium, such as 347, resist sensitization 3, but the hydrocracker's 347 tubes sensitized where carbon deposits caused local overheating, which a 2026 review puts at 512 °C 2,5.
How is it found?
- At shutdown, by examination. The hydrotreater coil cracks were found after the unit was shut down, as transverse cracks, some wide open 1; the hydrocracker tubes showed circumferential cracks beneath carbon deposits 2.
- In the laboratory, by confirming the path and the cause. Sections showed cracks starting on the process side and running between grains with some branching; an oxalic acid etch revealed widened grain boundaries typical of sensitized steel, and the inside deposit was about 80% iron sulfide 1. In the 347 case, microstructure and a double-loop electrochemical potentiokinetic reactivation (DL-EPR) test confirmed sensitization 2.
How is it prevented during shutdowns?
Measures described in refinery practice include 3,1:
- Neutralizing. Washing equipment with a soda ash solution before it is exposed to air neutralizes acids and leaves a thin alkaline film; every internal surface must be wetted, and the film reapplied if rain, water washing or mechanical work removes it 3. NACE RP0170 describes soda ash washing and nitrogen purging 1.
- Keeping air out. Equipment that will not be opened can be held under nitrogen, though users have found commercial nitrogen carrying far more oxygen than expected 3.
- Keeping water out. Dried air with a dew point well below the metal temperature can be used, and heater fireboxes can be kept warm with pilots or a portable heater to protect the outside of stainless tubes 3.
- Choosing and treating material. Stabilized grades, a stabilization heat treatment, and heat treatment after forming improve resistance 1,3.
Washing carries its own risk: chlorides in wash water or ammonium chloride salts can cause chloride stress corrosion cracking, so practice includes an inhibitor, a chloride cap, a thorough rinse and drained low points 3.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type 304 charge heater coils in naphtha hydrotreaters | Tube metal about 75 °C hotter than the process; sulfide scale; neutralizing film rinsed off at shutdown 1 | Cracks seen after shutdown; metallography and etching confirmed intergranular cracking in sensitized steel 1 | What is a fired heater? |
| Type 347 furnace tubes in hydrocracker fractionators | Local overheating under carbon deposits; errors in shutdown procedure 2,5 | Circumferential cracks under deposits after shutdown; microstructure and DL-EPR confirmed sensitization 2 | What is hydroprocessing (hydrotreating and hydrocracking)? |
| Hydroprocessing reactor circuits and heater tubes, inside and outside | Sulfide scale from oxygen-free operation; air and water when opened 3 | Risk mapped before the shutdown by identifying where scale and susceptible alloy meet 3 | How is inspection scope set for a turnaround? |
Sources: Lobley, 2002 1; Swaminathan and others, 2011 2; AFPM, 2016 3; Ardila-Parra and others, 2026 5.
Common questions
- How is it different from chloride stress corrosion cracking?
- Polythionic acid cracking needs sensitized steel and sulfur acids and runs between grains. Chloride cracking is driven by chlorides instead, and it is a risk of the wash water used to prevent polythionic acid attack.
- Why does sensitization matter so much?
- Without chromium-poor grain boundaries there is no easy path for the acid.
- Does using 347 stainless steel remove the risk?
- No. It lowers the risk, but 347 tubes have sensitized and cracked where deposits caused local overheating.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Stress Corrosion Cracking: Case Studies in Refinery Equipment (G. R. Lobley), 6th Saudi Engineering Conference, Vol. 5 · King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals (KFUPM), conference proceedings
- 2.Sensitization induced stress corrosion failure of AISI 347 stainless steel fractionator furnace tubes (J. Swaminathan, R. Singh, M. K. Gunjan, B. Mahato), Engineering Failure Analysis 18(8) · CSIR-National Metallurgical Laboratory (NML), Eprints@NML (abstract)
- 3.Q&A, Question 20: When is it appropriate to neutralize austenitic stainless-steel equipment to protect against stress corrosion cracking? · American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM)
- 4.On the mechanism of intergranular stress corrosion cracking of sensitized stainless steel in tetrathionate solution (A. Yonezu, R. Kusano, X. Chen), Journal of Materials Science 48(6):2447-2453 · Lingnan University research repository (abstract)
- 5.Understanding failure in austenitic steels: Key considerations for molten salt storage in CSP applications (S. A. Ardila-Parra, C. Prieto, J. D. Osorio, A. I. Fernández), Journal of Materials Research and Technology 41 · US Department of Energy, Office of Scientific and Technical Information (OSTI)
- 6.Intergranular Corrosion · Association for Materials Protection and Performance (AMPP)