What is top-of-line corrosion in wet gas pipelines?
Top-of-line corrosion (TLC) is internal corrosion at the top of a wet gas pipeline, caused by water that condenses on the cooler upper wall. The fresh condensate takes up carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide and organic acids. It occurs in stratified flow, where inhibitor in the bottom liquid does not reach the top.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
Injecting corrosion inhibitor is the standard defense inside wet gas lines, but in stratified flow the inhibitor travels with the liquid along the bottom, leaving the upper wall and the upper part of the side walls unprotected 1,2. Researchers at Ohio University describe the top of the line as the most critical location, because severe localized corrosion can develop there 2. In a well-documented offshore pipeline network off Thailand, corrosion features as deep as 30% to 60% of the original wall were found in the first 500 m of the lines, raising the prospect of derating or replacing whole sections 1.
Why does water condense at the top of the line?
Gas from the reservoir is normally saturated with water vapor 1. As it flows, pressure and temperature fall, mainly because the line exchanges heat with its surroundings and to a lesser degree through expansion cooling (the Joule-Thomson effect) 1. Water then condenses on the cold pipe wall. On the side walls the droplets slide down to the bottom, but at the top they form and stay attached for longer 2.
How much water condenses depends mainly on the temperature difference between the gas and the outside environment 1. Anything that changes heat transfer changes the condensation rate: thermal insulation, concrete weight coating, how deeply the pipe is buried, and whether it sits in soil, air, seawater or a river 1.
Formation water carries salts and bicarbonate that hold its pH above about 5.5 to 6.5, but condensed water has no salt 1. Under typical field conditions, freshly condensed droplets are expected to start at a pH of about 3 to 4.5, from dissolved carbon dioxide (CO2), hydrogen sulfide (H2S) and organic acids such as acetic acid 1.
When does top-of-line corrosion occur?
- Only in stratified flow. TLC needs the gas and liquid to run in separate layers, which happens when gas and water vapor are produced with little or no liquid hydrocarbon; slug or annular flow wets the whole circumference instead 1.
- Sweet (CO2) conditions. The first wetting by fresh condensate gives a high uniform rate that falls as dissolved iron raises the pH and an iron carbonate layer forms. Fresh condensate keeps diluting the iron, so the layer is constantly undermined, localized attack develops beneath it, and the rate cannot reach zero while condensation continues 1. Localized TLC is often seen at gas temperatures above about 70 °C (158 °F); below about 40 °C (104 °F) the iron carbonate layer forms poorly and corrosion tends to stay uniform and low 1.
- Condensation rate. In laboratory tests under static CO2 conditions, the condensation rate had little effect on corrosion at surface temperatures below about 25 °C (77 °F) but mattered much more above 40 °C (104 °F) 3.
- Sour (H2S) conditions. Only a few sour TLC field failures are well documented. All were in stratified, low-velocity flow below 50 °C (122 °F), often with methanol injection, where oxygen ingress may have contributed 1.
How is top-of-line corrosion found and managed?
In documented field cases, in-line inspection (ILI) located the damage. In the first reported CO2-dominated case, an onshore line in Indonesia, ILI showed extensive corrosion on the upper side at three locations where the line crossed a river delta, alternately buried and in contact with flowing water 1. A locally damaged insulation or coating, a "cold spot", is described as the worst case: it is hard to predict and can lead to failure 1.
Management options described in the research literature 1:
- Corrosion-resistant alloy or clad pipe over the hottest first few hundred meters, deliberately left uninsulated so the gas cools quickly; the transition to carbon steel then needs care with galvanic coupling and with corrosive condensate arriving free of corrosion products. 1
- A corrosion allowance set at design where alloy is not used. 1
- Batch inhibitor treatment, whose frequency depends on how long the inhibitor film persists; volatile inhibitors and foam delivery are still being researched. 1
In the US, federal rules set a baseline for gas pipelines. Corrosive gas may not be transported unless its effect has been investigated and steps taken to minimize internal corrosion, and any pipe removed from a line must have its inside surface inspected 4. New onshore transmission lines, and replacement components, installed from 23 May 2007 must, unless that is impracticable or unnecessary, be configured so liquids are less likely to collect, have liquid removal features where they could collect, and allow corrosion monitoring devices 5. Where corrosive gas is carried, coupons or other monitoring means must be checked twice each calendar year, at intervals of no more than 7.5 months 6. PHMSA attributes about 12% of 2013 to 2017 incidents on gas transmission, gathering and hazardous liquid lines to internal corrosion 7.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| First few hundred meters of a hot wet gas line | Hot inlet gas (up to 90 °C in the Thailand network), partial burial, high condensation 1 | ILI: features 30% to 60% of wall in the first 500 m 1 | What is in-line inspection (ILI) and pigging? |
| River or delta crossings, alternately buried and wet | Local change in heat transfer raising condensation 1 | ILI showing upper-side corrosion at three locations 1 | What types of in-line inspection tools are there (MFL, UT, EMAT, geometry)? |
| Spots with damaged insulation or coating | Local "cold spot" condensation 1 | Hard to predict; described as the worst case, leading to failure 1 | What is pipeline integrity management? |
| Sour wet gas lines below 50 °C | Stratified low-velocity flow; methanol injection with possible oxygen ingress 1 | TLC features and leaks reported in field cases 1 | Sweet vs sour corrosion: carbon dioxide vs hydrogen sulfide |
| US gas lines carrying corrosive gas | Corrosive gas; liquids collecting in the line 4,5 | Coupons or other means checked twice a year; inside surface inspected whenever pipe is removed 4,6 | Corrosion coupons vs electrical resistance (ER) probes, What is corrosion monitoring and which methods are used? |
Common questions
- Is top-of-line corrosion the same as CO2 corrosion?
- It is CO2 (or H2S) corrosion in a particular setting: condensing water on the upper wall, with no protective bulk liquid. The underlying reactions are the same as in the bulk water phase, but the setting makes localized attack likely and mitigation harder. See [What is carbon dioxide (CO2) corrosion?](/library/co2-corrosion/).
- Why can't continuous inhibitor injection protect the top?
- In stratified flow, inhibitor dissolved in the bottom liquid does not wet the top of the pipe, and to work an inhibitor must contact the whole inner circumference.
- Does insulating the line help?
- Insulation changes heat transfer and so the condensation rate, but where it is locally damaged the resulting cold spot is described as the worst case. Clad inlet sections are sometimes deliberately left bare so the gas cools quickly.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Top-of-the-line corrosion (M. Singer), Chapter 16 in Trends in Oil and Gas Corrosion Research and Technologies, Elsevier · Ohio University, Institute for Corrosion and Multiphase Technology (author copy)
- 2.A Mechanistic Model of Top-of-the-Line Corrosion (Z. Zhang, D. Hinkson, M. Singer, H. Wang, S. Nesic), Corrosion 63(11) · Ohio University, Institute for Corrosion and Multiphase Technology (author copy)
- 3.An Experimental Investigation of Top-of-Line Corrosion in a Static CO2 Environment (S. S. de Carvalho et al.), Corrosion 77(5), 515-525 (abstract and record) · University of Leeds, White Rose Research Online
- 4.49 CFR 192.475, Internal corrosion control: General · US Government Publishing Office, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR)
- 5.49 CFR 192.476, Internal corrosion control: Design and construction of transmission line · US Government Publishing Office, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR)
- 6.49 CFR 192.477, Internal corrosion control: Monitoring · US Government Publishing Office, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR)
- 7.Fact Sheet: Internal Corrosion · US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)