What is carbonate stress corrosion cracking?
Carbonate stress corrosion cracking (SCC) is cracking of carbon steel under tensile stress in alkaline water that contains carbonate and bicarbonate. In refineries it is found mainly in fluid catalytic cracking (FCC) overhead and gas recovery systems, at welds without post-weld heat treatment. On buried pipelines, concentrated carbonate-bicarbonate solution causes high-pH SCC.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
Most equipment in an FCC main column and gas concentration unit is already post-weld heat treated (PWHT) because it handles wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S), yet panelists at an American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM) technical Q&A reported that the cracking tends to stay in the piping, since pipe is usually left without heat treatment 1. One refiner described intergranular and base metal cracks in 78 welds of one FCC overhead system and its wet gas compressor, and fitted 18 full-separation clamps to keep the lines in service until their replacement during the following turnaround 1.
What causes carbonate SCC?
Three things combine: susceptible steel, tensile stress and an alkaline water phase rich in carbonate 1,2. In refineries, the susceptible material is carbon steel that was not post-weld heat treated, or was treated poorly 1.
In FCC units. Panelists said ammonium carbonate in the overhead water is believed to be the main contributor 1. Ammonia, which comes from nitrogen in the feed, raises the pH, and anything that adds carbon dioxide (CO2) adds carbonate 1. Two changes were linked to more cracking:
- Hydrotreated feed from high-nitrogen crudes. Hydrotreating removes sulfur much better than nitrogen, so the FCC feed ends up with a high nitrogen-to-sulfur ratio and the overhead water with a high pH 1.
- Complete combustion. One refiner reported that moving many units to complete combustion in the 1980s pushed them into the cracking range 1.
The combinations of pH and carbonate concentration that bring cracking were mapped in research published in 1989, and refiners monitor sour water pH and carbonate content against them 1.
On buried pipelines. Where coating has disbonded, cathodic protection (CP) current raises the pH of trapped groundwater and a concentrated carbonate-bicarbonate solution forms 2. Cracking of this kind needs a pH above about 9 and a narrow range of CP potential, and grows faster in warmer pipe 3. US gas pipeline rules require operators using SCC direct assessment to analyze what promotes such an environment, including soil temperature, moisture, CO2 and CP 4.
Where does carbonate SCC occur?
- Overhead systems of the FCC main fractionator, and the wet gas compressor circuit, the locations named in the AFPM question 1.
- Gas concentration unit, but only where an aqueous phase can form, such as a high-pressure condenser, and not, for example, in a debutanizer 1.
- Sour water strippers. One refiner heat treats them because carbonate effects can appear there 1.
- Pipe supports. Cracking was found where pipes rest on supports in pipeways, away from any weld 1.
- Buried gas pipelines, most often within about 20 km downstream of compressor stations, as high-pH SCC 2,3.
- CO2 transport pipelines (research). Laboratory tests on X80 line pipe steel found SCC at 75 °C in bicarbonate and carbonate solutions containing nitrate and sulfite impurities 5.
What does it look like and how is it found?
Refinery carbonate cracks are intergranular (along grain boundaries), sometimes branched and filled with scale, usually black magnetite and sometimes iron carbonate 1. That scale is one way to tell it apart from sulfide cracking, which leaves iron sulfide 1. Pipeline high-pH cracks are also intergranular, narrow and tight 3.
In FCC overheads, enhanced inspection programs use wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing (WFMT) for environmental cracking 1. Process monitoring does the screening: pH, which is easiest to measure, and carbonate content of the sour water show whether a system is in the cracking range 1. Panelists noted that cracking at unexpected spots such as supports makes it hard to monitor every location at risk 1. On pipelines, crack-detecting in-line inspection, hydrostatic testing and SCC direct assessment are used 2,4.
How is carbonate SCC prevented?
- PWHT. Panelists judged it very effective when done properly and without unusual external stresses; one refiner applies a more severe heat treatment than the code minimum, with closer temperature measurement, and reported no incident in over 10 years since making it standard for new and changed systems 1.
- Stainless steel. Stainless steels are described as basically immune, and some facilities switched to them 1.
- Process changes. Options discussed include higher water wash rates and lower riser outlet temperature to cut ammonia; film-forming inhibitors were used successfully at several sites, while the benefit of ammonium polysulfide was disputed 1.
- Pipelines. Intact coatings prevent SCC, and some operators cool the gas to limit pipe temperature against high-pH SCC 2.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main fractionator overhead piping and wet gas compressor piping in FCC units | Alkaline sour water with ammonium carbonate; piping without PWHT 1 | WFMT; sour water pH and carbonate monitoring 1 | What is fluid catalytic cracking (FCC)? |
| Gas concentration unit sections with free water | Aqueous phase in contact with carbonate-bearing streams 1 | WFMT in enhanced inspection programs 1 | What is corrosion monitoring and which methods are used? |
| FCC units running hydrotreated, high-nitrogen feed | High nitrogen-to-sulfur ratio raises overhead pH 1 | Trending of sour water pH and carbonate 1 | How do crude slate changes affect corrosion? |
| Pipe supports in FCC pipeways | Cracking outside weld zones 1 | Hard to cover by monitoring; found at unexpected spots 1 | What is a damage mechanism review? |
| Buried gas pipelines downstream of compressor stations | Concentrated carbonate-bicarbonate under disbonded coating; warm gas 2,3 | Crack in-line inspection, hydrostatic testing, SCC direct assessment 2,4 | What is stress corrosion cracking in pipelines (high-pH and near-neutral pH)? |
| CO2 transport pipelines (research) | Carbonate-bicarbonate water with nitrate and sulfite impurities 5 | Laboratory slow strain rate tests 5 | How are carbon dioxide pipelines different from natural gas pipelines? |
Sources: AFPM Q&A 1; PHMSA SCC Study, 2005 2; NEB MH-2-95, 1996 3; 49 CFR 192.929 4; Sandana, Newcastle University, 2016 5.
Common questions
- Is carbonate SCC the same as wet H2S cracking?
- No. Both occur in FCC overhead systems, but carbonate cracks are filled with magnetite or iron carbonate scale, while sulfide cracking leaves iron sulfide.
- Does stainless steel suffer carbonate cracking?
- Refiners describe stainless steels as basically immune, and replacing carbon steel with stainless has been used as a fix.
- Is it related to high-pH SCC on pipelines?
- Yes. High-pH pipeline SCC grows in a concentrated carbonate-bicarbonate solution, but on the outside of buried pipe under disbonded coating rather than inside process equipment.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Question 3: Carbonate stress corrosion cracking (CSCC) in FCC main fractionator overhead systems (technical Q&A database) · American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM)
- 2.TTO Number 8, Stress Corrosion Cracking Study, Final Report (prepared by Michael Baker Jr., Inc.) · US Department of Transportation, Office of Pipeline Safety (now PHMSA)
- 3.Public Inquiry Concerning Stress Corrosion Cracking on Canadian Oil and Gas Pipelines, Report of the Inquiry (MH-2-95) · National Energy Board (now Canada Energy Regulator)
- 4.49 CFR 192.929, What are the requirements for using Direct Assessment for Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCCDA)? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 5.Stress corrosion cracking of pipeline steels in contaminated aqueous CO2 environments (D. Sandana), thesis · Newcastle University, School of Chemical Engineering and Advanced Materials