Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactAsset Integrity Management · Pipeline integrity

What is direct assessment (ECDA, ICDA, SCCDA)?

·11 sources

Short answer

Direct assessment is a four-step process for assessing buried pipe for one threat: external corrosion, internal corrosion or stress corrosion cracking. Each version (ECDA, ICDA, SCCDA) runs pre-assessment, indirect inspection, direct examination in digs, and post-assessment. US gas pipeline rules set the requirements in 49 CFR 192.923 to 192.929.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

Near Carlsbad, New Mexico, in August 2000, a natural gas pipeline ruptured beside the Pecos River and the fire killed 12 people camping nearby 8. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found severe internal corrosion at a low point in the pipe where liquids had likely pooled, in a section that cleaning pigs could not reach because of where a liquid drip had been placed 8. Internal corrosion direct assessment (ICDA), as now written into 49 CFR 192.927, is built around predicting where liquids collect and digging there, starting with the low point nearest where liquid can first enter 3.

When is direct assessment used?

  • For three threats only. Gas transmission operators may use direct assessment as the primary method only for external and internal corrosion and for stress corrosion cracking (SCC) 1.
  • As a supplement. Confirmatory direct assessment, limited to external and internal corrosion, can be used inside a reassessment interval, for example when an operator sets an interval longer than 7 calendar years 5.
  • Where in-line inspection is impracticable. For liquid lines in high consequence areas, external corrosion direct assessment (ECDA) is one of the alternatives when in-line inspection is impracticable because of construction or operating limits 7.
  • On liquid lines, 49 CFR 195.588 sets requirements for ECDA and for SCC direct assessment (SCCDA) 7.

What are the four steps of ECDA, ICDA and SCCDA?

StepECDA (192.925)ICDA (192.927)SCCDA (192.929)
1. Pre-assessmentGather data, define ECDA regions, and pick at least two complementary indirect tools per region; stricter criteria the first time 2Document a feasibility check; define regions from where liquid can first enter to the next new input 3Collect data to judge whether SCC conditions exist and to rank segments 4
2. Indirect inspectionAbove-ground surveys; set criteria for which indications to dig and whether each is immediate, scheduled or monitored 2Flow modeling with actual pipeline data, never assumed: gas velocity including upsets, elevation profile, the inclination at which liquid holds up 3At least two above-ground surveys with complementary tools 4
3. Direct examinationDig and examine indications; set actions if defects exceed limits or the root cause shows ECDA is unsuitable 2First use: at least two digs per covered segment, at the low point nearest the region's start and farther downstream 3At least three digs at the sites judged most likely to have SCC 4
4. Post-assessmentJudge long-term effectiveness and whether to reassess sooner 2Within 1 year, judge effectiveness and check the flow model against corrosion actually found 3Reassessment plan based on susceptibility and how the cracks behave 4
Standard incorporated by referenceNACE SP0502-2010, with ASME B31.8S section 6.4 6NACE SP0206-2006 (dry gas ICDA) 6NACE SP0204-2008 6

Sources: 49 CFR 192.925, 192.927, 192.929 and 192.7 2,3,4,6.

When ICDA finds corrosion, the operator must evaluate its remaining strength, repair it under the integrity rules, widen the digging program across the region and check similar segments elsewhere 3. Regions where internal corrosion was found must then be monitored, with coupons, probes or ultrasonic sensors and liquid sampling at low points, at least twice each calendar year at intervals of no more than 7.5 months 3.

How does ECDA find coating and cathodic protection problems?

ECDA relies on surveys made from the surface. Federal rules name close interval surveys (CIS) of cathodic protection and voltage gradient surveys as methods associated with direct assessment, and name direct current and alternating current voltage gradient (DCVG, ACVG) surveys as ways to find coating damage 7,10. Readings that point to a coating fault or weak protection become indications, and the plan decides which to dig and how soon 2.

If ECDA finds coating damage, the operator must also use that data, with other integrated information, to evaluate the segment for third-party damage 2.

What can direct assessment not do?

  • Cover every threat. It cannot be the primary method for threats other than external corrosion, internal corrosion and SCC 1.
  • Work on wet gas without a special plan. Dry gas ICDA applies only to normally dry natural gas; a segment that normally carries liquids needs its own plan and notice to the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) 3.
  • Run on assumptions. ICDA may not use assumed pipeline or operating data, and if the flow model cannot be validated, ICDA is not feasible for the segment 3.
  • Replace other SCC methods in all cases. The rule describes SCCDA as complementary to in-line inspection and to hydrostatic testing with a spike test 4.

Where integrity problems show up

DecisionData it depends onWhat goes wrong without itIn the Library
Where to dig for internal corrosionElevation profile, liquid entry points, gas velocityCarlsbad, New Mexico, 2000: corrosion at a low point where liquids likely pooled, in a section pigs could not clean; 12 people died 8What is carbon dioxide (CO2) corrosion?
Whether external corrosion protection is workingCoating condition, cathodic protection readings, backfill typeSissonville, West Virginia, 2012: deteriorated coating and ineffective cathodic protection, worsened by rocky backfill, let corrosion thin the wall; the line had not been inspected or tested since 1988 9How does cathodic protection work?
Where to look for crackingCoating type and disbondment, cathodic protection history, pressure cyclingMarshall, Michigan, 2010: corrosion fatigue cracks grew under disbonded polyethylene tape coating 11; 192.929 lists coatings that shield cathodic protection as an SCC factor 4What is stress corrosion cracking in pipelines (high-pH and near-neutral pH)?
How severe a corrosion find isRemaining wall and pipe propertiesICDA findings must be evaluated for remaining strength and repaired under 192.933, or 192.485 and 192.714 outside covered segments 3Remaining strength factor

Sources: NTSB PAR-03/01 (2003) 8; NTSB PAR-14/01 (2014) 9; NTSB PAR-12/01 (2012) 11; 49 CFR 192.927 and 192.929 3,4.

Common questions

Is direct assessment the same as in-line inspection?
No. In-line inspection sends a tool through the pipe and measures the wall along its length. Direct assessment uses data, surveys or flow modeling to predict where damage is likely and confirms it by digging. See [What is in-line inspection (ILI) and pigging?](/library/in-line-inspection/).
What is confirmatory direct assessment?
A reduced form for external and internal corrosion. It allows one indirect tool, requires digging all immediate indications and at least one high-risk scheduled indication in each ECDA region, and one high-risk location in each ICDA region.
Why is direct assessment used on unpiggable lines?
Because it does not need a tool to pass through the pipe. The liquid rules list ECDA among the alternatives when tools cannot be run. See [How are unpiggable pipelines inspected?](/library/unpiggable-pipelines/).

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.49 CFR 192.923, How is direct assessment used and for what threats? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  2. 2.49 CFR 192.925, What are the requirements for using External Corrosion Direct Assessment (ECDA)? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  3. 3.49 CFR 192.927, What are the requirements for using Internal Corrosion Direct Assessment (ICDA)? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  4. 4.49 CFR 192.929, What are the requirements for using Direct Assessment for Stress Corrosion Cracking? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  5. 5.49 CFR 192.931, How may Confirmatory Direct Assessment (CDA) be used?, and 192.939, What are the required reassessment intervals? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  6. 6.49 CFR 192.7, What documents are incorporated by reference partly or wholly in this part? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  7. 7.49 CFR 195.588, What standards apply to direct assessment?, and 195.452(c) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  8. 8.Pipeline Accident Report NTSB/PAR-03/01: Natural Gas Pipeline Rupture and Fire Near Carlsbad, New Mexico, August 19, 2000 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ·
  9. 9.Pipeline Accident Report NTSB/PAR-14/01: Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation Pipeline Rupture, Sissonville, West Virginia, December 11, 2012 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ·
  10. 10.49 CFR 192.461, External corrosion control: Protective coating · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  11. 11.Pipeline Accident Report NTSB/PAR-12/01: Enbridge Incorporated Hazardous Liquid Pipeline Rupture and Release, Marshall, Michigan, July 25, 2010 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ·