Can existing gas pipelines carry hydrogen?
Existing gas pipelines can carry hydrogen or hydrogen blends only within limits set by their steel, welds, flaws, pressure cycling and connected equipment. Hydrogen speeds fatigue crack growth and lowers fracture resistance in pipeline steels, even at low concentrations. In the US, 49 CFR 192 covers flammable gas pipelines and ASME B31.12 covers hydrogen pipelines.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
Sandia National Laboratories summarized in 2022 that gaseous hydrogen speeds fatigue crack growth in pipeline steels by more than 10 times and cuts fracture resistance by more than half 3. The same summary found that even small amounts of hydrogen have large effects; in one series of fracture tests on X70 steel at 85 bar, a mixture with 1% hydrogen behaved only modestly differently from pure hydrogen 3. The US Department of Energy (DOE) states that blend limits depend on the design and condition of existing pipe materials, of pipeline equipment and of the appliances and processes that use the gas 1.
What does hydrogen do to pipeline steel?
Tested in gaseous hydrogen, pipeline steels grow cracks faster under cyclic load and resist fracture less, one form of hydrogen embrittlement (see What is hydrogen embrittlement?). Sandia's 2022 summary and the 2023 HyBlend results report the trends below 3,2:
- Faster fatigue crack growth. Growth rates rise by more than 10 times in gaseous hydrogen and depend on pressure and on the ratio of minimum to maximum load in each cycle 3. Sandia reported that a steel's pedigree had surprisingly little effect on crack growth, in tests that included grades X52, X65 and X80 and X52 steels from the 1950s and 1960s 2,3.
- Lower fracture resistance. Resistance falls by more than 50%, and hydrogen-assisted fracture scales with steel hardness and strength; modern steels were moderately more resistant 2,3.
- Welds. Welds of similar strength to the pipe body performed like the base metal once residual stresses were accounted for, a finding Sandia listed as emerging 3.
- Pipe-scale failure. HyBlend reported in 2023 that a subscale pipe specimen with engineered defects failed by hydrogen-assisted fatigue after more than 2,000 pressure cycles 2.
- Impurities. Oxygen reduced the effects in some accelerated tests but appeared less effective in long-term testing 3.
HyBlend reported that design curves for fatigue crack growth in hydrogen, sensitive to pressure and load ratio, were adopted in ASME B31.12 Code Case 220 2.
What about plastic distribution pipe?
Existing gas distribution lines are made mainly of medium-density or high-density polyethylene (MDPE, HDPE), according to a 2022 Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) review 4. The limited data it found showed no significant loss in burst strength, fracture energy or fatigue properties from hydrogen, but most data could not be traced to a specific resin, and heat fusion joints needed more testing 4.
Later HyBlend tests showed that effects depend on the polyethylene's chemistry 2. In slow crack growth tests at 250 psi, time to failure fell by 38% for one MDPE in hydrogen but rose for one HDPE, and another HDPE lost about 42% of its fracture energy in a blended gas, against 21% in methane alone 2. Butt fusion joints showed better tensile performance after hydrogen exposure 2.
How does blending change energy delivery?
Hydrogen carries less energy per unit volume than natural gas. Argonne National Laboratory's analysis for HyBlend found that pure hydrogen at the same volumetric flow delivers about 70% less energy, and that keeping energy delivery constant takes about 3 moles of hydrogen for each mole of methane replaced 2. In its pipeline case study, holding energy delivery constant limited the blend to about 30% hydrogen, giving roughly a 6% cut in life cycle greenhouse gas emissions 2. The leakage rate also rose with the hydrogen fraction 2.
Which rules and codes apply to hydrogen pipelines?
- Federal rules. 49 CFR 192 defines gas as natural gas, flammable gas, or gas that is toxic or corrosive, a definition broad enough to include hydrogen, which is flammable 5.
- Design code. ASME B31.12, Hydrogen Piping and Pipelines (2023 edition listed), covers piping and pipelines for gaseous hydrogen and its mixtures, with Part PL for pipelines; ASME states the edition is not intended to apply retroactively to existing hydrogen systems 6.
- Scale. DOE puts the US natural gas pipeline network at about three million miles, against more than 1,600 miles of pipeline built for hydrogen alone 1.
- Public tools. HyBlend released open-source software: HELPR, from Sandia, for structural integrity of pipelines carrying hydrogen and blends, and BlendPATH for system impacts and costs of repurposing 1.
Where integrity problems show up
| Decision | Data it depends on | What goes wrong without it | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether existing cracks and dents can stay | Crack and deformation inspection data, fatigue history | Crack growth more than 10 times faster in hydrogen 3; a defected subscale pipe failed after more than 2,000 pressure cycles 2 | How are crack-like flaws assessed for fitness-for-service? |
| Whether the steel is suitable | Grade, hardness and strength from mill records | Hydrogen-assisted fracture scales with hardness and strength 2,3 | What is a mill test certificate (EN 10204 3.1 and 3.2)? |
| How much pressure cycling to allow | Operating pressure history | Fatigue and fracture in hydrogen depend on pressure level and load ratio 3 | Remaining life |
| Whether plastic pipe and joints are compatible | Resin type, joint records | Effects vary by polyethylene chemistry; data on fusion joints are limited 2,4 | How are materials selected for oil and gas equipment? |
| How high a blend to run | Gas quality, flow and compressor capacity | Same energy needs about three times the molar flow of the gas replaced; leakage rises with blend fraction 2 | What is pipeline integrity management? |
Sources: Sandia SAND2022-10592 O (2022) 3; DOE H2IQ Hour, HyBlend (2023) 2; PNNL-33736 (2022) 4.
Common questions
- Does a small blend avoid embrittlement?
- Not necessarily. Sandia reported that even small amounts of hydrogen have large effects on fracture, although fatigue crack growth was slower in 3% hydrogen than in pure hydrogen.
- Is this the same as high temperature hydrogen attack?
- No. The effects here are hydrogen-assisted fatigue and fracture measured in gaseous hydrogen in pipeline steels. [What is high temperature hydrogen attack (HTHA)?](/library/high-temperature-hydrogen-attack/) covers a separate mechanism.
- How much dedicated hydrogen pipeline is there in the US?
- More than 1,600 miles, according to DOE's HyBlend page, modified January 2026.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.HyBlend: Opportunities for Hydrogen Blending in Natural Gas Pipelines · US Department of Energy (DOE)
- 2.The #H2IQ Hour: Pipeline Blending CRADA, A HyBlend Project Overview (T. Deutsch, C. San Marchi, K. Simmons, K. Topolski, A. Elgowainy), webinar slides · US Department of Energy, Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies Office ·
- 3.Study Group on Materials Testing and Qualification for Hydrogen Service, SAND2022-10592 O (includes C. San Marchi and J. Ronevich, current state of knowledge on hydrogen effects in pipeline steels) · Sandia National Laboratories ·
- 4.Gap Analysis on the Impacts of Hydrogen Addition to the North American Natural Gas Infrastructure Polyethylene Pipelines, PNNL-33736 (K. L. Simmons et al.) · Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), via OSTI
- 5.49 CFR 192.3, Definitions · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 6.B31.12, Hydrogen Piping and Pipelines (product page) (2023 edition listed (also 2011, 2014, 2019)) · American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME)