Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactInspection, Testing and Monitoring · In-line inspection and pigging

What types of in-line inspection tools are there (MFL, UT, EMAT, geometry)?

·7 sources

Short answer

In-line inspection (ILI) tools, or smart pigs, are grouped by the sensor they carry. Magnetic flux leakage (MFL) tools find metal loss, ultrasonic (UT) tools measure wall thickness or find cracks, electromagnetic acoustic transducer (EMAT) tools find cracks without a liquid, and geometry tools find dents. US rules tie ILI to API STD 1163, ASNT ILI-PQ and NACE SP0102.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

A tool finds only the damage its sensor is built to see. In May 2009 a natural gas transmission pipeline ruptured near Palm City, Florida, releasing an estimated 36 million cubic feet of gas without ignition 2. Five years earlier it had been inspected with a caliper tool for dents and an axial MFL tool for corrosion 2. The US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found environmentally assisted cracking along the longitudinal seam weld under disbonded coating, with stress corrosion cracking in the final stage of crack growth 2. It noted that axial MFL tools cannot accurately detect long, axially oriented defects such as stress corrosion cracking colonies, and that the tool choice followed a risk analysis giving the neighboring segments very low scores for that threat 2.

What does each type of tool detect?

Tool typeHow it sensesBest suited toMain limits
Axial MFLMagnets saturate the wall along the pipe axis; sensors measure flux that leaks out where metal is missing 1Metal loss from corrosion and gouges 1Cannot accurately detect long axial defects such as stress corrosion cracking colonies 2
Transverse MFL, or transverse flux inspection (TFI)Same principle, with the field turned 90 degrees to wrap around the pipe 1Long, narrow axial metal loss, including corrosion along seams 1Detects cracks, but less reliably than metal loss 1
Compression-wave UTPulses sent straight into the wall; the time between inner and outer surface echoes gives thickness 1Wall thickness and metal loss 1Needs liquid in the line 6 and a clean wall; paraffin must be removed, especially in crude lines 1
Shear-wave (circumferential) UTPulses angled through a liquid so that shear waves travel around the pipe wall at 45 degrees 1Longitudinal cracks, seam weld defects and stress corrosion cracking, which it detects most reliably 1Needs a liquid coupling medium 1
EMATA coil and magnet generate sound inside the steel, so no couplant is needed 7Cracks in gas pipelines without a liquid batch 6A 2003 report gave a minimum detectable crack of about 1 mm deep and 30 mm long 6
Geometry (caliper)Mechanical arms or electromechanical sensors measure the bore 1Dents, ovality and other deformation; in some cases bends; usable in liquid and gas lines 1Must report dent depth, orientation and location for US liquid line repair criteria to be applied 1

The NTSB also lists eddy current among ILI sensing methods 2, and a 2019 review by researchers at the US National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) mentions capacitive and electromagnetic sensors 5. A 2003 report for the US Minerals Management Service (MMS) noted that inspecting a riser with anything other than MFL meant bleeding it down and filling it with liquid 6.

How does an inspection run work?

A smart pig enters at a launcher, a special arrangement of pipes and valves at a station where the tool is loaded, sealed in and pushed into the main line by the flow of product. A receiver downstream catches it, and the stored data are downloaded for analysis 1. A cleaning pig is recommended before UT runs 1. Segments that can take these tools are called piggable 2, and US rules also accept tethered or remotely controlled tools that meet the applicable parts of NACE SP0102 4. See How are unpiggable pipelines inspected?.

The NETL review notes that runs typically happen every 5 to 7 years, set by regulation or company policy, names high cost as a main reason for the low frequency, and points out that ILI gives no continuous monitoring 5.

How are tools chosen?

PHMSA states that operators need to know the pipe type, wall thickness and material, the defects the pipe may suffer and the risk of the section before choosing a tool 1. For gas pipelines in high consequence areas, 49 CFR 192.921 allows an internal inspection tool only where it can detect the threats the segment is susceptible to, and lists corrosion, deformation, mechanical damage and crack-like defects such as stress corrosion cracking and selective seam weld corrosion 3. The same rule requires operators to account for uncertainties in reported results, including tool tolerance, detection threshold, probability of detection and sizing accuracy 3. Runs must follow API STD 1163, ASNT ILI-PQ and NACE SP0102 under 49 CFR 192.493 for gas and 195.591 for liquids 4.

The NTSB drew the lesson from Palm City that tool choice depends on threat identification: had the ruptured section been identified as susceptible to stress corrosion cracking, a spike pressure test would have been appropriate and might have found the defect 2.

Where integrity problems show up

What it finds wellWhat it can miss or get wrongIn the Library
Axial MFL: metal loss from corrosion and gouges 1Long axial defects such as stress corrosion cracking colonies, as at Palm City in 2009 2What is stress corrosion cracking in pipelines (high-pH and near-neutral pH)?, Metal loss
Transverse MFL: long, narrow axial metal loss and seam corrosion 1Cracks, which it finds less reliably 1Magnetic flux leakage
Compression-wave UT: direct wall thickness 1Readings in waxy or dirty lines, and gas lines without a liquid 1,6Ultrasonic testing
Shear-wave UT: axial cracks, seam weld defects, stress corrosion cracking 1Lines that cannot carry a liquid couplant 1What is stress corrosion cracking (SCC)?
EMAT: cracks in gas lines with no liquid 6Cracks below the tool's detection threshold, reported in 2003 as about 1 mm deep and 30 mm long 6Probability of detection (POD)
Geometry: dents, ovality and deformation 1Dent orientation, if only depth is reported; US liquid line repair criteria use both 1What happens after an in-line inspection run?

Sources: PHMSA fact sheet, revised 2014 1; NTSB Safety Study SS-15/01, 2015 2; US Minerals Management Service riser report, 2003 6.

Common questions

Is a smart pig the same as a cleaning pig?
No. Cleaning pigs scrape wax and other build-up from the pipe; smart pigs travel the same way but carry sensors that record corrosion, cracks, dents and other irregularities.
Which tool finds stress corrosion cracking?
PHMSA names shear-wave UT as the most reliable for longitudinal cracks and stress corrosion cracking, notes that transverse MFL may find some axial cracks that other tools miss, and EMAT tools find cracks in gas lines without a liquid.
How often are pipelines pigged?
The NETL review gives a typical interval of 5 to 7 years, set by regulation or company policy. See [What is in-line inspection (ILI) and pigging?](/library/in-line-inspection/).

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Fact Sheet: In-Line Inspections (Smart Pig) · US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)
  2. 2.Integrity Management of Gas Transmission Pipelines in High Consequence Areas, Safety Study NTSB/SS-15/01 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)
  3. 3.49 CFR 192.921, How is the baseline assessment to be conducted? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  4. 4.49 CFR 192.493 and 49 CFR 195.591, In-line inspection of pipelines · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  5. 5.Corrosion Sensors for Structural Health Monitoring of Oil and Natural Gas Infrastructure: A Review (R. F. Wright et al.), Sensors 19(18):3964 · MDPI, via PubMed Central (authors at the US National Energy Technology Laboratory) ·
  6. 6.Evaluation of Methods for Detecting and Monitoring of Corrosion and Fatigue Damage in Risers (M. Lozev, B. Grimmett, E. Shell, R. Spencer), final report, Technical Assessment Program project 433 · US Minerals Management Service (now Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement, BSEE) ·
  7. 7.Electromagnetic Acoustic Transducers (EMATs) (NDE-Ed) · Iowa State University, Center for Nondestructive Evaluation