Sweet vs sour corrosion: carbon dioxide vs hydrogen sulfide
Sweet corrosion is attack on steel by carbon dioxide (CO2) dissolved in water, which forms carbonic acid and mainly thins the wall. Sour corrosion involves hydrogen sulfide (H2S), which also corrodes steel but lets hydrogen enter it, adding cracking. US offshore rules require cracking-resistant materials where H2S is present (30 CFR 250.490).
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
In flow-loop tests at Ohio University published in 2010, traces of H2S lowered the average corrosion rate of carbon steel compared with pure CO2, an effect the authors associate with a protective iron sulfide (mackinawite) film 2. That does not make sour service milder. In water, H2S generates hydrogen that can enter steel and cause blistering and cracking, and the risk rises with the hardness and strength of the steel 3. Two gas releases on platforms in the same field off California, in 1999 and 2012, both came from internal corrosion in wet sour gas 5.
Sweet vs sour corrosion at a glance
| Sweet corrosion (CO2) | Sour corrosion (H2S) | |
|---|---|---|
| What drives it | CO2 dissolves in water and forms carbonic acid 1,6 | H2S dissolves in water and forms a weak acid 6; hydrogen generated at the steel surface can enter the metal 3 |
| Corrosion product film | Iron carbonate. Below about 60 °C it does not stick; at about 60 to 150 °C a loose film goes with deep pitting; above about 150 °C tight films form (laboratory findings reported in 1998) 1 | Iron sulfides such as mackinawite; their protectiveness depends on which sulfide forms 2 |
| Main damage | Wall thinning, general or local, including pitting 1 | Wall loss plus hydrogen damage: blistering, hydrogen induced cracking and sulfide stress cracking 3 |
| Example of a US rule | For gas pipelines, any corrosive gas, CO2-bearing or not, may be transported only after its effect has been investigated and steps taken to minimize internal corrosion (49 CFR 192.475) 8 | Offshore, equipment must resist sulfide stress cracking when operating in a zone with H2S or where H2S in produced fluid may exceed 0.05 psi partial pressure; blowout preventer and pressure-control equipment must conform to NACE MR0175 (30 CFR 250.490) 4 |
Where does sweet corrosion occur?
- Production flowlines and pipelines carrying oil, gas and water together. CO2 in produced water forms carbonic acid, and multiphase lines from offshore fields can run many miles before the phases are separated 1.
- Wet gas pipelines at the top of the line. Where water condenses on the upper wall in stratified flow, inspections often find corrosion over wide areas where the iron carbonate layer broke down; condensation rate, gas temperature and flow, CO2 partial pressure and organic acids set the severity 2.
Where does sour corrosion occur?
- Sour gas production offshore. On the California platform cases, condensed water reacting with H2S thinned a flowline until it ruptured in 1999, releasing gas with about 18,000 ppm H2S; in 2012, oxygen entering wet sour gas formed elemental sulfur that drove local attack under deposits 5.
- Wells and pressure-control equipment. US offshore rules set material requirements for tubulars, casing, wellheads and blowout preventers in H2S zones 4.
- Refinery and gas plant vessels in wet H2S. OSHA reports cracking in liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) storage spheres, mainly in weld heat-affected zones, and notes that post-weld heat treatment appears to reduce cracking 3.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wet gas and multiphase pipelines with CO2 | Free water with dissolved CO2; iron carbonate film unstable at some temperatures 1 | Coupons or probes, wall thickness measurement, in-line inspection 6 | What is carbon dioxide (CO2) corrosion? |
| Top of the line in stratified wet gas flow | Water condensing on the upper wall; CO2 and organic acids 2 | Pipe inspections showing wide areas of attack across the top of the pipe 2 | What is top-of-line corrosion in wet gas pipelines? |
| Offshore sour gas piping at reducers and flanges | Oxygen ingress forming elemental sulfur under deposits; low flow 5 | Radiography where routine ultrasonic readings are unreliable 5 | What is under-deposit corrosion? |
| Offshore sour gas flowlines and vessels | Condensed water reacting with H2S 5 | Ultrasonic inspection programs for critical piping and vessels, adopted after the 1999 release 5 | How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work? |
| LPG spheres and other vessels in wet H2S | Hard zones at welds, higher-strength steel 3 | Early internal inspection of vessels more than five years in service; magnetic particle methods for surface cracks 3 | What is wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S) damage? |
| Sour well tubulars and pressure-control equipment | H2S above the regulatory partial pressure 4 | Prevented by material selection rather than inspection 4 | Sulfide stress cracking |
Sources: Rajappa and others, 1998 1; Singer and others, 2010 2; OSHA Technical Manual 3; 30 CFR 250.490 4; BSEE OCS Report 2012-104 5; NTSB PAR-03/01 6.
A common mix-up
"Sweet" and "sour" also describe hydrocarbon streams by their sulfur content. BSEE defines sour gas as natural gas contaminated with H2S or other sulfur compounds 5. In corrosion, what matters is H2S together with water at the metal surface 3. Researchers also note that the line between sweet and sour corrosion in mixed CO2 and H2S systems is not clearly drawn and probably depends on which corrosion product film forms 2.
Common questions
- Is sour crude the same as sour service?
- Not exactly. A sour crude or gas is named for its sulfur content, while sour service refers to equipment exposed to wet H2S, the condition that can generate hydrogen in steel. See [Sour service](/glossary/sour-service/).
- Which is worse, sweet or sour corrosion?
- Neither in general. Traces of H2S can lower the metal-loss rate compared with pure CO2, but H2S adds cracking that wall thickness checks do not measure.
- What happens when both gases are present?
- Both act at once, and researchers link the outcome to whether iron carbonate or an iron sulfide film forms on the steel. US gas pipeline rules treat any corrosive gas the same way: its effect must be investigated before transport.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Modeling the Diffusion Effects through the Iron Carbonate Layer in the Carbon Dioxide Corrosion of Carbon Steel (S. Rajappa, R. Zhang, M. Gopal), CORROSION/98 paper 26 · NACE International, hosted by Ohio University Institute for Corrosion and Multiphase Technology (ICMT)
- 2.Sour Top of the Line Corrosion in the Presence of Acetic Acid (M. Singer, A. Camacho, B. Brown, S. Nesic), CORROSION 2010 paper 10100 · NACE International, hosted by Ohio University Institute for Corrosion and Multiphase Technology (ICMT)
- 3.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- 4.30 CFR 250.490, Hydrogen sulfide · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 5.OCS Report BSEE 2012-104, Investigation of H2S Gas Release, Platform Hidalgo, OCS-P 0450, Pacific OCS Region · US Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE)
- 6.Pipeline Accident Report NTSB/PAR-03/01, Natural Gas Pipeline Rupture and Fire Near Carlsbad, New Mexico, August 19, 2000 · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ·
- 7.Fact Sheet: Internal Corrosion · US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA)
- 8.49 CFR 192.475, Internal corrosion control: General · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register