What is brittle fracture?
Brittle fracture is sudden, fast cracking of a metal with little or no plastic deformation, at stresses that can be well below yield. It needs three things together: a crack-like flaw, high stress at that flaw and low notch toughness, which in carbon steel falls as temperature drops. ASME Section VIII and other codes set toughness rules against it.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
On 2 January 1988, a 4-million-gallon oil storage tank at a terminal in Floreffe, near West Elizabeth, Pennsylvania, split open on the first occasion it was filled to the top after being rebuilt on the site 2. About 1 million gallons of oil reached the Monongahela River, contaminating the water supply of towns that draw from it 2. The National Bureau of Standards, now the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), found a brittle fracture that began at a 0.74-inch flaw left by cutting before the rebuild, in shell steel at about 0 °C (32 °F) that was too low in toughness to stop a running crack 2.
What causes brittle fracture?
NIST describes three conditions that must act together 1:
| Condition | Where it comes from | At Floreffe, 1988 2 |
|---|---|---|
| A crack or crack-like flaw | Fabrication flaws in areas not inspected or missed by inspection; cracks grown in service 1 | A flaw from a cutting operation, present before the tank was rebuilt |
| High stress at the flaw | Stress raisers in the geometry and residual stress from welding, especially welds never stress relieved 1 | Residual weld stress plus the load of the oil, close to yield at the flaw |
| Low notch toughness | Low metal temperature, a low-toughness grade, or steel embrittled by heat or service 1 | Steel hardened by cutting and welding next to the flaw, at about 0 °C (32 °F) |
Take away any one and a brittle crack cannot start, or cannot keep running 1. NIST noted that steel tough enough to arrest a crack lets a tank leak instead of bursting, behavior it described as leak before break 2.
Cracks are dangerous out of proportion to their size: a cracked piece fails at a much lower load than its loss of cross-section alone would suggest, because the stress concentrates at the crack tip 5. In tension, once the energy released by crack growth exceeds the material's resistance, growth becomes unstable, which is why brittle failures are sudden 5.
How does temperature change steel toughness?
Carbon and low-alloy steels are tough when warm and brittle when cold, with a transition between the two 1. For a typical carbon steel this transition spans about 55 °C (100 °F), and for some grades room temperature falls inside it 1. The steel's physical makeup does not change; only its response to a notch and load does 1.
The Charpy V-notch test measures this. For the Floreffe investigation, NBS broke small notched bars cut from the first two shell courses at six temperatures between 20 °F and 160 °F, and for each one recorded the energy it absorbed, how far it spread sideways and how much of its broken face had failed in shear 2. At 55 °F and below, every plate absorbed under 10 ft-lb and broke mostly without shear; the steel only became tough at around 100 °F, so a shell at about 32 °F sat well on the brittle side of its transition 2.
When does brittle fracture happen in service?
- On first loading or first cold exposure. NIST notes failures can come after a successful hydrostatic test, because service may be much colder than the test and cracks can form or grow in operation 1. The Floreffe tank failed on its first full fill after rebuilding 2.
- When process upsets chill equipment. At a gas plant in Longford, Victoria, in 1998, loss of warm lean oil chilled a reboiler to about -42 °C (normally about 100 °C), and it fractured when warm oil was reintroduced; 2 people died and the state's gas supply stopped for over 2 weeks, according to a summary by the Institution of Chemical Engineers (IChemE) 3.
NIST cites the World War II Liberty ships that split open and welded tank failures in the 1940s as earlier examples with similar steels, flaws and stresses 2.
How is the risk assessed?
Codes control toughness at the design stage; NIST pointed to notch toughness rules in ASME Section VIII, Division 1 1. In service, guidance from the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) notes that detected cracks can be evaluated with fracture mechanics, and that a safety judgment has to assume the biggest crack an inspection could have overlooked is present, rather than relying on the smallest one the method is able to detect 4. See Minimum design metal temperature (MDMT) and How are crack-like flaws assessed for fitness-for-service?.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Field-erected storage tanks, especially rebuilt or relocated ones | Pre-existing flaws, embrittled weld zones, low-toughness shell steel, cold weather at first full fill 2 | Toughness testing of the steel (Charpy and drop-weight tests) and weld examination; at Floreffe the flaw was not caught by weld quality tests 2 | API 653, Storage tank types |
| Cold heat exchangers in gas processing | Loss of warm process flow during an upset, then warm fluid reintroduced 3 | Hazard studies that identify low-temperature cases; IChemE notes cold embrittlement is sometimes overlooked 3 | Hazard and operability study (HAZOP), MDMT |
| Pressure vessels with as-welded seams | Residual stress in welds without PWHT, low temperature, incomplete inspection 1 | Weld examination, then fracture mechanics evaluation of any cracks found 1,4 | Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT), Non-destructive testing (NDT) methods |
Common questions
- What is the difference between brittle and ductile fracture?
- Ductile fracture follows visible stretching and absorbs much energy; brittle fracture runs with little deformation and absorbs little. In a Charpy test a brittle break absorbs little energy and shows little shear on its broken face.
- Does a successful hydrotest rule out brittle fracture?
- No. NIST notes service temperatures can be far colder than the test, and cracks can form or grow after it.
- Is brittle fracture the same as hydrogen embrittlement?
- No. Hydrogen embrittlement is one way steel loses ductility and toughness; brittle fracture is the sudden failure that low toughness allows. See [What is hydrogen embrittlement?](/library/hydrogen-embrittlement/).
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.NIST Special Publication 780, Guidelines for Pressure Vessel Safety Assessment (S. Yukawa) · US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
- 2.NBSIR 88-3792, Investigation into the Ashland Oil Storage Tank Collapse on January 2, 1988 (J. L. Gross and others) · US National Bureau of Standards (now NIST)
- 3.Lessons Learned Database: Deethaniser Reboiler Catastrophic Failure, Longford, Victoria, 25 September 1998 (P. Marsh) · Institution of Chemical Engineers (IChemE)
- 4.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 3: Pressure Vessel Guidelines · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- 5.Brittle Fracture (Teaching and Learning Package) · DoITPoMS, University of Cambridge