Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactCorrosion and Damage Mechanisms · Mechanical and metallurgical damage

What is graphitization in carbon steel?

·8 sources

Short answer

Graphitization is a change in carbon and carbon-molybdenum steel held for years at high temperature, as iron carbide breaks down into iron and graphite. Graphite nodules or chains can cut toughness. The Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) links it mainly to carbon steel above about 800 °F (427 °C) and carbon-molybdenum steel above about 900 °F (482 °C).

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

Decades of trouble-free service do not prove that a hot carbon steel pipe is sound. Graphitization develops slowly in service, and EPRI reported in 2013 that its members' experience showed the risk rising as the average age of fossil-fired plants increased 1. When one owner checked a 60-year-old piping system against EPRI's updated risk curves, it found moderate to severe graphitization, shut the plant down and replaced the piping, finding a large graphitization crack during the work 1. EPRI also notes a serious graphitization failure at a US power plant in 2011 1.

How does graphitization happen?

Graphitization is the breakdown of iron carbide, also called cementite, into iron (ferrite) and free graphite after long service at high temperature 3. In plain carbon-manganese steam lines, a 2017 University of Pretoria study describes it after more than about 20 years at about 400 to 450 °C (750 to 840 °F), and notes that it often forms close to welds, as heat-affected zone graphite 3.

The graphite usually appears as nodules 2. In the 2011 failure, though, graphite formed as chains along grain boundaries, and only in pipe bends that had been formed and not heat treated afterward, where forming strain was highest 2. An engineer involved in the investigation told the National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors in 2013 that little published literature described this grain-boundary form, which made it hard to recognize 2.

How much does it weaken the steel?

It depends on the form and extent. EPRI states that severe graphitization significantly reduces ductility and toughness and can lead to piping failures 1. In the 2011 case, tests on the failed bend confirmed lost toughness and much lower elongation, and the pipe broke without leaking first 2. Earlier through-wall cracks in the same system had appeared during hydrostatic tests in 1982 and 1990 and as an on-line leak in 2004, and most of these events never received a thorough root cause analysis 2.

Milder graphitization can matter less. In the Pretoria study, heat-affected zone graphite after about 35 years at 420 °C (788 °F) had no effect on tensile strength, impact toughness, hardness or elongation, although reduction in area fell from 72% to 44% 3. Where toughness does fall, the risk is brittle fracture, which needs a crack-like flaw, high stress and low toughness together 4.

Where does it occur?

  • Steam piping and high-temperature power plant components, where EPRI says it was identified in the 1950s 1.
  • Carbon-molybdenum superheater inlet pipe bends formed without heat treatment afterward 2.
  • Carbon steel steam lines near welds after decades of service 3.
  • Refinery steam systems. Refineries raise steam in boilers, heater-boiler units and waste heat units, including carbon monoxide boilers on catalytic crackers 8. The public cases reviewed for this page come from power and steam systems, not refinery process units 1,2,3.

How is it found?

  • Samples and metallography. In the 2011 investigation, removed bends and straight sections went through metallographic examination with hardness, tensile and impact tests; the grain-boundary graphite was found only in bends 2.
  • Risk curves to choose locations. EPRI's 2010 update drew on 281 graphitization data points from 20 sources, against about 40 before, to build time-temperature curves that rank the risk for carbon steel weldments and guide inspection and sampling 1.
  • Limits of non-destructive testing. A boiler maker's 2015 service bulletin stated that reliable non-destructive methods were not yet available and pointed owners to samples from bends and weldments 7,2. See What are the main non-destructive testing (NDT) methods in oil and gas?.

Where integrity problems show up

Where it occurs (unit or equipment)Conditions that drive itHow it is usually foundIn the Library
Carbon steel steam piping weldsDecades near 420 °C; graphite in the heat-affected zone 3Metallography of removed samples 3; EPRI risk curves to pick locations 1What should an inspection plan contain?
Cold-formed carbon-molybdenum bends not heat treated after formingForming strain plus long service; graphite chains on grain boundaries 2Removed bends tested by metallography, hardness, tensile and impact tests 2What is post-weld heat treatment (PWHT)?
Long-serving steam piping systemsTime above about 800 °F (carbon steel) or 900 °F (carbon-molybdenum) 1Risk ranking, then inspection and sampling 1,2What is a damage mechanism review?
Graphitized parts under pressure tests, start-ups or load changesLow toughness with a flaw and high stress 4,2Through-wall cracks in hydrotests or leaks, before diagnosis 2What is brittle fracture?

Sources: EPRI, 2013 1; National Board, 2013 2; Kruger, 2017 3; NIST SP 780, 1990 4.

Common questions

Is graphitization the same as graphitic corrosion?
No. Graphitic corrosion is a form of de-alloying in gray cast iron, seen for example in cast iron water pipe, that removes the metal and leaves a weak graphite residue. Graphitization is a change inside carbon and low-alloy steel caused by long exposure to heat.
Does graphitization thin the pipe wall?
No. It changes the steel's microstructure rather than removing metal, which is why it is found by examining samples.
Can heat treatment undo it?
Not reliably. The engineer who described the 2011 case reported that research had found graphitization damage returning faster after re-heat treatment, so the plant replaced the affected bends with chromium-molybdenum pipe instead.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Predictive Curves on Graphitization of Carbon Steel Enables NRG to Evaluate and Replace Plant Piping System (Success Story 1026906) · Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)
  2. 2.Recent Catastrophic Failures of High Temperature/High Pressure Power Boiler Components (G. Galanes, presentation at the 82nd General Meeting, edited transcript) · National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors
  3. 3.Repair welding of carbon steel pipe that has experienced partial graphitization during elevated temperature service (K. J. Kruger), MEng dissertation (record and abstract) · University of Pretoria, UPSpace repository
  4. 4.NIST Special Publication 780, Guidelines for Pressure Vessel Safety Assessment (S. Yukawa) · US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
  5. 5.Forms of Corrosion · NASA Kennedy Space Center, Corrosion Technology Laboratory
  6. 6.Corrosion control checklist (Guides to Good Practice in Corrosion Control No. 11), glossary · UK National Physical Laboratory (NPL)
  7. 7.Graphitization of Carbon-Molybdenum Steels, Plant Service Bulletin PSB-59, with PSB-59 Clarification and Discussion · Babcock & Wilcox (boiler manufacturer; vendor bulletin, supporting source only)
  8. 8.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2: Petroleum Refining Processes · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)