Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactAsset Integrity Management · IOWs and corrosion loops

What is a damage mechanism review?

·4 sources

Short answer

A damage mechanism review (DMR) is a team study of an operating process unit that identifies how its equipment can degrade and under which conditions. It covers corrosion, cracking, embrittlement and other damage, and what prevents or detects each one. California requires DMRs at refineries; API RP 571 describes the mechanisms.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

On 2 April 2010 a heat exchanger in the naphtha hydrotreater of a refinery in Anacortes, Washington, ruptured from high temperature hydrogen attack (HTHA), and seven workers died 1. Damage mechanism reviews of that unit, there called corrosion reviews, had been carried out in 1990, 1999, 2003 and 2008, yet none found HTHA credible for the exchangers involved 1. The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) found that the reviews relied on design data rather than measured conditions, since those exchangers had no temperature instruments, and that each one recorded the whole shell as clad in stainless steel when only its hottest section was 1. A DMR is only as good as the operating data and equipment records it works from.

What does a damage mechanism review cover?

The most detailed public description is California's process safety rule for refineries, California Code of Regulations (CCR) Title 8, Section 5189.1. It requires each DMR to 2:

  • assess the unit's process flow diagrams; 2
  • identify every potential damage mechanism; 2
  • confirm that the materials of construction suit their service and resist those mechanisms; 2
  • set out ways to prevent or mitigate the damage; and 2
  • review the operating parameters that could speed damage up, or slow or stop it. 2

The review must also weigh the unit's inspection history and damage data, industry-wide experience, and the applicable codes and standards 2. The CSB describes industry practice in similar terms: reviewers annotate a process flow diagram with temperatures, pressures and flows, then evaluate it against current operating data and repair history for the mechanisms listed in American Petroleum Institute (API) RP 571 1.

Mechanism family named in the California ruleExamples the rule givesIn the Library
Mechanical loading failuresDuctile and brittle fracture, mechanical fatigue, bucklingWhat is brittle fracture?, What is mechanical and vibration fatigue?
ErosionAbrasive wear, adhesive wear, frettingCorrosion vs erosion vs erosion-corrosion: what is the difference?
CorrosionUniform corrosion, localized corrosion, pittingWhat are the main types of corrosion?, What is pitting corrosion?
Thermal damageCreep, metallurgical transformation, thermal fatigueWhat is creep damage?, What is thermal fatigue?
CrackingStress corrosion crackingWhat is stress corrosion cracking (SCC)?
EmbrittlementHigh temperature hydrogen attackWhat is high temperature hydrogen attack (HTHA)?

Source: CCR Title 8, Section 5189.1(k)(9), which lists these as examples, not a closed list 2.

Who does it and when?

Under the California rule 2:

  • Team. Members must cover engineering, inspection of equipment and piping, how damage and failures happen, and the running of the process, and one must know the review method; employees take part. 2
  • First round. At least half of the initial DMRs within three years and all within five years of the rule taking effect on 1 October 2017, in an order based on operating history, the process hazard analysis (PHA) schedule and inspection records. 2
  • Repeat. Revalidation at least every five years. 2
  • Triggers. Before approving a major change to a process that has a damage mechanism, or a change that may introduce one, and after any incident in which a damage mechanism contributed. 2
  • Output. A written report of the mechanisms, results and recommendations for mitigation and prevention, available to the PHA team and unit employees and kept for the life of the unit. 2

Where did the requirement come from?

The CSB recommended documented damage mechanism hazard reviews after two refinery incidents. After Anacortes it asked Washington State to make them an integral part of the PHA cycle for all process piping and equipment covered by process safety management 1. After the 2012 Richmond, California, fire it asked the State of California to require them, identifying mechanisms, consequences of failure and the safeguards that control them 3. California's refinery rule, with its DMR section, became operative on 1 October 2017 2.

How is a damage mechanism review used afterward?

  • Inspection planning. API RP 571 (3rd edition, March 2020) covers more than 60 mechanisms, each with susceptible materials, critical factors, guidance on choosing inspection methods and control measures, plus generic process flow diagrams of the main mechanisms in typical refinery units 4.
  • Operating limits. API RP 584 (2nd edition, December 2021) explains how to set up integrity operating windows as part of mechanical integrity 4.
  • Corrosion control documents. API RP 970 (2nd edition, April 2023) describes a document that records a unit's damage susceptibilities, the factors behind them and the recommended actions, tied to management of change, PHA and reliability-centered maintenance 4.

Where integrity problems show up

DecisionData it depends onWhat goes wrong without itIn the Library
Ruling a mechanism in or outMeasured temperatures and pressures across all operating modesAnacortes, 2010: reviews relying on design data judged HTHA not credible; the exchangers that failed had no temperature instruments 1Anacortes refinery explosion (2010): lessons on high temperature hydrogen attack
Taking credit for cladding or liningsThe verified, as-built extent of the claddingAnacortes: every review recorded stainless cladding on the whole shell; only the hottest section had it 1What are as-built drawings?
Approving a process changeA damage mechanism check before the changeAnacortes: a 1995 change that could raise hydrogen partial pressure was managed without considering HTHA 1; California now requires a DMR review before a major change 2What is management of change (MOC)?
Material suitability, component by componentComposition of each component, not only the line specificationRichmond, 2012: low-silicon carbon steel can corrode up to 16 times faster by sulfidation than higher-silicon steel 3What is sulfidation (high-temperature sulfur corrosion)?

Sources: CSB report 2010-08-I-WA, 2014 1; CCR Title 8, Section 5189.1(k) 2; CSB report 2012-03-I-CA, 2015 3.

Common questions

How is a DMR different from a corrosion risk assessment at the design stage?
A corrosion risk assessment in front-end engineering design is made before the plant exists, from its design basis; see [What is a corrosion risk assessment in FEED?](/library/corrosion-risk-assessment-in-design/). A DMR reviews a running unit against its operating history, inspection records and changes, as the California rule requires.
Is a DMR the same as a corrosion control document?
No. API describes a corrosion control document (RP 970) as the record that holds a unit's damage susceptibilities and recommended actions; the DMR is the team review that identifies them.
How often is a DMR repeated?
Under the California rule, at least every five years, before major changes and after incidents in which a damage mechanism contributed.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Investigation Report: Catastrophic Rupture of Heat Exchanger (Seven Fatalities), Tesoro Anacortes Refinery, Anacortes, Washington, April 2, 2010, Report No. 2010-08-I-WA · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
  2. 2.California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Section 5189.1, Process Safety Management for Petroleum Refineries · California Department of Industrial Relations
  3. 3.Final Investigation Report: Chevron Richmond Refinery Pipe Rupture and Fire, Report No. 2012-03-I-CA · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
  4. 4.2025 Publications Catalog (entries for RP 571, RP 580, RP 584 and RP 970) (RP 571, 3rd edition, March 2020; RP 580, 4th edition, August 2023; RP 584, 2nd edition, December 2021; RP 970, 2nd edition, April 2023) · American Petroleum Institute (API)