Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactOperations, Maintenance and Process Safety · Process safety management

What is management of change (MOC)?

·9 sources

Short answer

Management of change (MOC) is a written procedure for reviewing and approving changes to process chemicals, technology, equipment or procedures in advance. US process safety rules (29 CFR 1910.119(l) and 40 CFR 68.75) apply it to these changes, and to facility changes, except a replacement in kind: one that satisfies the design specification.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

At an olefins plant in Geismar, Louisiana, a reboiler ruptured in 2013, killing 2 workers; 167 injuries were reported 3. The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) traced the hazard to block valves installed in 2001: the change review was carried out only after the valves were in service, and it did not identify that they could cut the reboiler off from its pressure relief valve 3. A similar pattern appears in the 1974 explosion at Flixborough, England, where a temporary bypass pipe was fitted with no drawing, limited calculations and no pressure test; 28 workers died 4.

What counts as a change?

The US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) process safety management standard requires MOC for changes to process chemicals, technology, equipment and procedures, and for facility changes that affect a covered process 1. The only exemption is a replacement in kind, which paragraph (b) defines as "a replacement which satisfies the design specification" 1. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Risk Management Program uses the same wording in 40 CFR 68.75 2.

Type of changeExamples in public sourcesHow it is treated
New or altered equipmentValves added to reboiler piping (Geismar, 2001); a bypass pipe between two reactors 4MOC before the work 3,4
Operating conditionsRunning outside the set limits for pressure, temperature or flowMOC review and approval 1
Temporary changeTemporary bypasses; at California refineries, temporary pipe repairsMOC with a time limit and a return to the original design 1,7
Work done during a shutdownAnything other than a replacement in kind made during a turnaroundThrough MOC before startup 1
Organization and staffingAt California refineries: staffing cuts, changes to shift length, or added duties of 15% or moreA separate organizational change assessment 7
Like-for-like replacementA part that meets the design specificationReplacement in kind; no MOC 1

Sources: 29 CFR 1910.119 and Appendix C 1; CSB 3; HSE 4; California Title 8, Section 5189.1 7.

OSHA's nonmandatory guidance in Appendix C warns that temporary changes have caused several catastrophes and tend to become permanent unless their time limit is set and monitored 1.

What must an MOC review cover?

Paragraph (l)(2) lists five points to address before any change: its technical basis, its effect on safety and health, changes to operating procedures, the time it needs, and who must authorize it 1. Paragraphs (l)(3) to (l)(5) then require that affected operators, maintenance workers and contract employees are informed and trained before startup, and that process safety information (PSI) and procedures are updated 1. A modification that changes PSI also needs a pre-startup safety review, which confirms that MOC requirements were met 1,2.

Appendix C suggests a change form covering, among other items, inspection and testing, piping and instrument diagrams (P&IDs), maintenance procedures, training and the duration of temporary changes 1. A checklist signed by an authorized person may suit a minor, well-understood change; a complex design change may call for a formal hazard evaluation approved by operations, maintenance and safety 1. UK HSE guidance adds that a change can affect plant far from where it is made, and that written rules should decide what level of hazard and operability study (HAZOP) a modification gets 5.

Where do MOC programs fail?

The Geismar case shows three failure points 3. The valves went in during a shutdown in early 2001, the pre-startup review was signed on 1 February, but the MOC was opened only on 2 March and approved on 6 April. The reviewers answered a yes, no or not-applicable checklist without identifying the overpressure hazard, and the P&IDs did not show the new valves. The CSB concluded that MOC must be done before a change is made in the field and should not be treated as paperwork 3.

The problem is not rare. In the first year of OSHA's refinery National Emphasis Program, management of change was one of five elements that together accounted for nearly 80% of the violations found 8. In an HSE analysis of 34 control system incidents, 20% of the primary causes were changes made after commissioning 6. Sites in OSHA's Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP) track overdue, open and approved MOCs; one set a maximum of 180 days for any temporary MOC 9.

Where integrity problems show up

Element or stepIntegrity linkIn the Library
Reviewing overpressure protectionAt Geismar the new valves could isolate a reboiler from its relief valve, and the review did not catch it 3What does a pressure relief valve do?
Updating process safety informationPSI includes materials of construction, P&IDs and relief design basis, and must be updated after a change 1; the Geismar P&IDs did not show the new valves 3What is process safety management (PSM)?
Updating inspection and test plansAppendix C lists inspection and testing, and mechanical integrity programs, among the items a change review should address 1What is mechanical integrity (MI)?
Damage mechanism review before a major changeCalifornia refineries must review or carry out a damage mechanism review before a major change and file its findings with the MOC 7What is a damage mechanism review?
Operating outside set limitsAppendix C treats operation outside established pressure, temperature or flow limits as a change needing review 1What are integrity operating windows (IOWs)?
Temporary repairsCalifornia refinery MOC procedures must cover temporary repairs, including temporary pipe repairs 7What is fitness-for-service (API 579-1/ASME FFS-1)?
Changes to control and safety systems20% of primary causes in HSE's control system incident analysis were changes after commissioning 6What is a safety instrumented system (SIS)?

Sources: 29 CFR 1910.119 1; CSB Geismar case study, 2016 3; HSE HSG238 6; California Title 8, Section 5189.1 7.

Common questions

Does a like-for-like replacement need MOC?
Not if it is a true replacement in kind, meaning it satisfies the design specification. A replacement that does not meet the design specification is a change and goes through MOC.
What is the difference between MOC and a pre-startup safety review?
MOC reviews and authorizes a change before it is made; the pre-startup safety review checks, before hazardous chemicals are introduced, that the modified plant matches its design and that MOC was completed. See [What is a pre-startup safety review (PSSR)?](/library/pre-startup-safety-review/).
Do organizational changes need MOC?
The federal text names chemicals, technology, equipment, procedures and facilities. California's refinery rule adds a separate written assessment before staffing reductions and other organizational changes.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.29 CFR 1910.119, Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals, paragraphs (b), (d), (i), (l) and Appendix C · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  2. 2.40 CFR 68.75, Management of change, and 68.77, Pre-startup review · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  3. 3.Williams Geismar Olefins Plant Reboiler Rupture and Fire, Geismar, Louisiana, Case Study No. 2013-03-I-LA · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
  4. 4.Flixborough (Nypro UK) Explosion 1st June 1974 · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  5. 5.Plant modification / Change procedures (COMAH technical measures) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  6. 6.Out of control: Why control systems go wrong and how to prevent failure, HSG238, second edition · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  7. 7.California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Section 5189.1, Process Safety Management for Petroleum Refineries · California Department of Industrial Relations
  8. 8.Refinery NEP First Year Inspection Results · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  9. 9.The Use of Metrics in Process Safety Management (PSM) Facilities, Fact Sheet FS-3896 · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)