Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactCorrosion and Damage Mechanisms · General and localized corrosion

What is cooling water corrosion?

·5 sources

Short answer

Cooling water corrosion is metal loss in heat exchangers, piping and cooling towers caused by the water used to carry away process heat. Dissolved oxygen, salts concentrated by evaporation, temperature, flow and microbes drive it, often alongside scale and fouling. Water treatment, controlled blowdown and corrosion inhibitors keep it in check.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

When the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) reviewed failures of service water systems, the cooling water that serves safety equipment at US reactors, from 1980 to early 1987, it counted 980 events, of which 276 had potential generic safety significance 1. Corrosion and erosion accounted for 27% of those 276 events, the largest single fouling mechanism, ahead of biofouling and debris at 10% each 1. Twelve events in the period involved a complete loss of service water function 1. In 1989 the NRC asked plants to test the heat transfer capability of safety-related heat exchangers and to run routine inspection and maintenance of open-cycle piping against corrosion, erosion, coating failure, silting and biofouling 1.

What drives corrosion in cooling water?

Corrosion in cooling water is electrochemical: anodes and cathodes form on the metal surface where its electrical potential differs, and the water completes the circuit 3. Researchers at Carnegie Mellon University name water temperature, flow velocity and especially water quality as key conditions; within water quality, inhibitor concentration, aggressive species such as chlorine and ammonia, and microbes 3.

Open recirculating systems add two further factors, oxygen and concentration 2,4:

  • Oxygen. Water cooled by contact with air in a tower is saturated with oxygen, which OSHA notes raises the chance of corrosion 2.
  • Concentration. Evaporation carries heat away but leaves dissolved solids behind, such as calcium, magnesium, chloride and silica. As total dissolved solids (TDS) rise, they can form scale or lead to corrosion 4. EPA gives a rule of thumb that a tower evaporates about 1% of the recirculating flow for every 10 °F (about 5.6 °C) of cooling it achieves 4.

OSHA adds that impurities in refinery cooling water corrode and foul pipes and heat exchangers, that dissolved salts deposit scale, and that microorganisms damage wooden cooling towers 2.

Which equipment is affected?

  • Heat exchanger tubes and condensers. These are the main concern. Corrosion products cut heat transfer, and a penetrated tube lets cooling water into the other side; in power plants that means contaminating high-purity boiler water 3. OSHA notes the reverse risk in refineries: when an exchanger tube fails, fluid flows from the higher-pressure side into the lower 2.
  • Cooling water piping. Piping corrosion is less of a concern than exchanger corrosion, but there is far more piping to protect 3.
  • Cooling towers. If cooling water picks up hydrocarbons, flammable vapors can be released into the tower's discharge air and a fire can start if an ignition source or lightning is present 2.
  • Open-cycle systems. The NRC's reviews traced serious fouling to mud, silt, corrosion products and shellfish such as Asiatic clams and mussels, which blocked flow to safety equipment 1.

How is cooling water corrosion controlled and monitored?

Cycles of concentration. This ratio compares the conductivity of the blowdown water with that of the make-up water, and roughly equals the ratio of make-up to blowdown volume 4. Running more cycles saves water: DOE's Federal Energy Management Program notes that many systems run at two to four cycles, that six or more may be possible, and that going from three to six cuts make-up water by 20% and blowdown by 50% 5. The same source warns that higher cycles raise dissolved solids that can cause scale and corrosion unless carefully controlled 5.

Chemical treatment. Typical programs combine corrosion and scale inhibitors with biological fouling control 5. Corrosion inhibitors shield the metal surface with an extremely thin film 3. Acid is sometimes fed to convert alkalinity into more soluble forms and limit scale, but an acid overdose can severely damage a cooling system, so DOE's guidance calls for a timer or continuous pH monitoring 5.

Monitoring. EPA lists the water chemistry parameters reviewed and controlled: pH, conductivity, alkalinity, hardness, corrosion inhibitor and biocide levels, and microbial growth 4. A conductivity controller can automate blowdown at a set point 5. On the equipment side, the NRC's program combined heat exchanger performance testing with routine inspection and maintenance of open-cycle piping and components 1.

Changing water sources. Where treated municipal wastewater or other lower-quality water replaces fresh make-up water, corrosion behaves differently and control strategies based on freshwater experience may not carry over 3.

Where integrity problems show up

Where it occurs (unit or equipment)Conditions that drive itHow it is usually foundIn the Library
Water-cooled exchanger tubes and condensersOxygen-saturated water, impurities, scale, wall temperature 2,3Heat transfer performance testing; tube leaks into the other side 1,2What are the main types of heat exchangers in process plants?
Open-cycle service water pipingCorrosion, erosion, silt and shellfish fouling 1Routine inspection and maintenance for corrosion, erosion, coating failure, silting and biofouling 1How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work?, What is microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC)?
Recirculating loop at high cycles of concentrationRising calcium, magnesium, chloride and silica 4,5Conductivity ratio of blowdown to make-up; pH, alkalinity, hardness and inhibitor levels 4What is corrosion monitoring and which methods are used?
Acid feed pointsOverdose lowering pH sharply 5Timer or continuous pH monitoring at the feed 5Injection point
Cooling tower fill, basin and wooden structuresMicrobial growth; sunlight on open decks 2,5Microbial growth and biocide levels in water chemistry checks 4What is under-deposit corrosion?

Sources: NRC Generic Letter 89-13, 1989 1; OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2 2; Carnegie Mellon University 3; EPA, 2012 4; DOE FEMP 5.

Common questions

Is cooling water corrosion the same as microbiologically influenced corrosion?
No. Microbes are one of several water quality factors in cooling systems, alongside oxygen, dissolved solids and aggressive species. See [What is microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC)?](/library/microbiologically-influenced-corrosion/).
What does "cycles of concentration" mean?
It is how many times the dissolved solids in the make-up water have been concentrated in the recirculating water, measured as the conductivity of blowdown divided by that of make-up.
How is it related to oxygen corrosion?
Open cooling water is saturated with oxygen from the tower air, so oxygen is one of its drivers. See [What is oxygen corrosion in water systems?](/library/oxygen-corrosion/).

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Generic Letter 89-13: Service Water System Problems Affecting Safety-Related Equipment · US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) ·
  2. 2.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2: Petroleum Refining Processes · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
  3. 3.Corrosion (cooling water research pages, Civil and Environmental Engineering) · Carnegie Mellon University and University of Pittsburgh
  4. 4.WaterSense at Work: Best Management Practices for Commercial and Institutional Facilities, Section 6.3 Cooling Towers · US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
  5. 5.Best Management Practice #10: Cooling Tower Management · US Department of Energy, Federal Energy Management Program (FEMP)