Skip to content
Beaconby Winda

HAZOP vs HAZID: what is the difference?

·7 sources

Short answer

A hazard identification study (HAZID) screens early for major hazards; a hazard and operability study (HAZOP) examines process deviations in detail later. A HAZOP applies guide words to each section of the piping and instrument diagrams (P&IDs), while a HAZID uses broader prompts such as fire or dropped objects. IEC 61882 is the HAZOP application guide.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

A project with process flow diagrams but no P&IDs yet cannot run a full HAZOP. UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) guidance places the full study on frozen P&IDs, after earlier stages that identify major hazards and run a coarse HAZOP on the flowsheet 1. Australia's offshore regulator, NOPSEMA, likewise suggests a coarse HAZOP or a HAZID at concept stage 2. Order matters because, as HSE notes in its guidance on control systems, hazards found after design has begun are hard to design out, and harder and more expensive to deal with later in a system's life 3.

HAZOP vs HAZID at a glance

HAZIDHAZOP
Question it asksWhat hazards could this facility or activity present, and could any cause a major accident? 2How could each part of the process depart from its design intent, and what would follow? 5
Typical timingConcept stage, then repeated after changes, incidents and at set intervals 2Detailed design on frozen P&IDs 1; for US covered processes, revalidated at least every 5 years 4
Main inputsFacility diagrams, process information, existing conditions, procedures and hazardous material data 2P&IDs and the rest of the process safety information, including relief design basis and operating limits 4,5
PromptsGeneral hazard categories, such as overpressure, corrosion, leak, fire, explosion, gas release and external events 2Guide words paired with parameters, such as more pressure or reverse flow 5
Unit of studyAn area, process or activity, taken in turn 2A study node on the P&IDs, or a step in a procedure 5,6
OutputHazards and possible major accident events, passed to risk assessment and the safety case 2,7Deviations with causes, consequences, safeguards and actions 5
Known limitsLess detailed than a HAZOP 2Gives no likelihood 1; may miss interactions between nodes, mechanical integrity failures and external events 2
Rules and guidesMethod left to the operator by NOPSEMA 2; UK offshore rules require all major accident hazards to be identified 7IEC 61882:2016 application guide 6; a listed method for process hazard analysis under 29 CFR 1910.119(e) 4

Sources: HSE 1; NOPSEMA guidance note GN0107, 2012 2; 29 CFR 1910.119 4; University of Auckland 5; IEC 6; HSE L154, 2015 7.

When is a HAZID used?

  • At concept stage, before detailed drawings exist; NOPSEMA lists a HAZID or coarse HAZOP as suitable then 2.
  • To build the list of major accident hazards for a safety case. UK offshore safety cases must show that all hazards able to cause a major accident have been identified 7.
  • For hazards outside the process, such as dropped objects and vessel collisions, which NOPSEMA says HAZOP handles poorly 2.
  • Again over the life of the facility, after modifications, a major accident event or dangerous occurrence, when a control deficiency is found, and at set intervals 2.

When is a HAZOP used?

  • On frozen P&IDs during detailed design, as HSE's third stage 1.
  • As the process hazard analysis for a process covered by the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) rule, where HAZOP is one of the listed methods 4.
  • For plant modifications, with written rules deciding how much HAZOP each change gets 1.
  • For operating procedures, using procedural HAZOP, which IEC 61882:2016 illustrates with a case study 6.
  • On existing plants, for example when control and instrumentation systems are upgraded 5.

How do the two studies fit together?

HSE describes a sequence of six studies that runs from the earliest design to early operation 1. The first identifies major hazards and checks that key hazard data exist. The second is a coarse HAZOP on the flowsheet and block diagram, and the third the full HAZOP on frozen P&IDs. The last three check that actions were done, carry out a pre-commissioning check and audit safety a few months after startup.

A HAZID's output is a list of hazards and possible major accident events that then need risk assessment and controls 2. A HAZOP's output is a set of deviations and actions on a design that already exists 5. NOPSEMA notes that HAZOP results describe causes and consequences of deviations, so they may need reworking before they fit a major accident risk assessment 2.

A common mix-up

The abbreviation PHA means two different things. In US rules, process hazard analysis is the required study, and HAZOP is one of the methods allowed for it 4. In HSE guidance, a preliminary hazard analysis is the first step of a hazard assessment, done during early process development and again for modifications 1.

Where integrity problems show up

Element or stepIntegrity linkIn the Library
HAZID prompts on corrosion and overpressureNOPSEMA lists corrosion, overpressure and leaks among the general hazard prompts used at early stages 2What is a corrosion risk assessment in FEED?
HAZOP's weak spot on equipment damageNOPSEMA notes HAZOP is less suitable for mechanical integrity failures 2What is a damage mechanism review?
From identified hazards to safety-critical equipmentUK offshore safety cases must show that measures, including safety and environmental-critical elements, are chosen to control each major accident risk 7What are safety and environmental critical elements (SECEs)?
Accurate P&IDs and relief data for the full HAZOPA HAZOP is only as good as its drawings and data 5; relief design basis is required process safety information 4What does a pressure relief valve do?
Pre-commissioning checkHSE's fifth stage checks the plant before commissioning, including statutory requirements 1What is a pre-startup safety review (PSSR)?
Repeating the studies after changeNOPSEMA expects hazard identification to be repeated after modifications 2; HSE applies its stages to modifications too 1What is management of change (MOC)?

Sources: HSE 1; NOPSEMA 2; 29 CFR 1910.119 4; University of Auckland 5; HSE L154 7.

Common questions

Is a HAZID required by law?
Not by that name in the sources reviewed. UK offshore rules require all major accident hazards to be identified without naming a method, and NOPSEMA leaves the choice of technique to the operator. US rules require a process hazard analysis by a listed or equivalent method, and HAZID is not among those named.
Can a HAZOP replace a HAZID?
HSE's sequence begins with a major hazard identification before any HAZOP, and NOPSEMA notes that HAZOP is less suited to external events and mechanical integrity failures.
What is a coarse HAZOP?
A HAZOP run on the flowsheet and block diagram before P&IDs are ready; it is the second of HSE's six stages.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Plant modification / Change procedures (COMAH technical measures) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  2. 2.Hazard Identification, Guidance Note N-04300-GN0107, Revision 5 · National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority (NOPSEMA), Australia
  3. 3.Out of control: Why control systems go wrong and how to prevent failure, HSG238, second edition · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  4. 4.29 CFR 1910.119, Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals, paragraphs (d) and (e) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  5. 5.Hazard and Operability (HAZOP) Studies · University of Auckland
  6. 6.IEC 61882:2016, Hazard and operability studies (HAZOP studies): Application guide (webstore page) (IEC 61882:2016, edition 2) · International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) ·
  7. 7.The Offshore Installations (Offshore Safety Directive) (Safety Case etc) Regulations 2015: Guidance on Regulations, L154, first edition · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)