What is hydrochloric acid (HCl) corrosion in crude unit overheads?
Hydrochloric acid (HCl) corrosion in a crude unit overhead is acid attack on steel where hydrogen chloride from heated crude dissolves in condensing water. The salts behind it are mainly magnesium and calcium chlorides. Desalting the crude, neutralizing chemicals and wash water are the main controls.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
Hydrogen chloride does not corrode steel while it stays a gas in the hot tower; the attack starts at or below the water dew point, where the gas dissolves into the condensing water and forms hydrochloric acid 2. A NACE International publication cited in the study names acid attack by HCl in condensing water as the primary concern in overhead systems 2. OSHA lists the overhead, carrying hydrogen sulfide (H2S), HCl and water, among the crude unit sections susceptible to corrosion 1. The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) describes the desalter as the step that keeps this acid from forming: it takes out chloride salts and water that would otherwise produce acid able to severely corrode equipment downstream 3.
Where does the hydrogen chloride come from?
Crude oil often carries inorganic salts, mainly sodium, magnesium and calcium chlorides, either suspended or dissolved in entrained brine 1. When the crude is heated in the preheat train and furnace, some of these chlorides react with water (hydrolyze) and release hydrogen chloride gas 1,2. The three salts behave very differently, as data summarized in the 2021 open-access case study show 2:
| Salt in crude | Hydrolysis starts at about | Share hydrolyzed at about 340 °C (650 °F) |
|---|---|---|
| Magnesium chloride | 120 °C (248 °F) | about 90% |
| Calcium chloride | 210 °C (410 °F) | about 10% |
| Sodium chloride | above 500 °C (930 °F) | about 2% |
Source: Ahmed, 2021, citing earlier studies 2.
Sodium chloride barely breaks down at normal furnace conditions, so it is generally not counted as a significant source of overhead acid 2. Magnesium and calcium chlorides supply most of the HCl. OSHA notes that HCl also forms in other units: in catalytic reformers from the hydrogenation of chlorine compounds, and in hydrotreaters, where it can condense as hydrochloric acid in the cooler parts of the unit 1.
Where in the overhead does it attack?
The HCl travels up the tower with the vapor. Above the water dew point it causes no corrosion, though it can react with alkaline species such as ammonia and form corrosive salts 2. At or below the dew point it dissolves readily, and the condensing water can carry a high concentration of acid 2. OSHA's list of corrosion-prone crude unit sections includes the preheat exchanger (HCl and H2S) and the overhead (H2S, HCl and water) 1.
Tower internals near the top are exposed as well. In the 2021 case study of a crude tower in the Kurdistan Region of Iraq, which had no desalter and received crude with salt above 119 pounds per thousand barrels (PTB) through 2020, a tray of nickel-copper alloy 400 near the top of the tower was perforated through and a 410 stainless steel tray lower down had large holes 2. The authors attributed the damage to combined HCl and ammonium chloride corrosion 2. They also note that alloy 400 corrodes faster when oxidizing agents such as oxygen or ferric ions are present 2.
How is HCl corrosion controlled and found?
Control works on the chloride first and the acid second 1,2:
- Desalting. Chemical or electrostatic desalting washes salts, solids and water out of the crude with hot water before distillation 1. The 2021 study reports that chloride above 20 ppm in desalted crude can lead to significant overhead corrosion and fouling 2.
- Caustic. Caustic is added to desalted crude to reduce the corrosive chlorides that reach the tower overhead 1.
- Neutralizers. Ammonia may be injected into the overhead before the first condensation, or an alkaline solution into the hot crude feed 1. Where ammonia is used, it is commonly limited to what pH control of the overhead drum water needs, because less ammonia lowers the salt formation temperature 2.
- Wash water. Injected wash water dissolves salt deposits 2; OSHA warns that without enough of it, ammonium chloride deposits can cause serious corrosion 1.
Finding the damage depends on watching the chemistry as well as the metal. The case study tracked salt in the crude feed month by month, and it describes estimating the salt formation temperature from chloride and ammonia measured in the overhead drum water 2. Internal inspection during a shutdown, with laboratory analysis of tray deposits, confirmed the damage in that case 2. For piping, inspection guidance allows wall thickness to be tracked at a small number of fixed condition monitoring locations 3; for HCl, the zone that matters is where water first condenses 2. API RP 571 (3rd edition, March 2020) covers over 60 refinery damage mechanisms, with inspection method guidelines for each 4.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crude preheat exchangers | HCl and H2S released as chlorides hydrolyze on heating 1,2 | Fouling and loss of heat transfer, which share the root cause of poor desalting 1 | What are the main types of heat exchangers in process plants? |
| Top trays and internals of the atmospheric tower | Condensing water with HCl; high salt in feed; no desalter in the 2021 case 2 | Internal inspection and deposit analysis at shutdown 2 | What is a crude distillation unit? |
| Overhead line, condensers and drum | First condensing water dissolves HCl 1,2 | Chloride, ammonia and pH of drum water 2; wall thickness at monitoring locations 3 | How does ultrasonic thickness measurement work?, What are condition monitoring locations (CMLs)? |
| Desalter and crude feed | Salts not removed; magnesium and calcium chlorides hydrolyzing 1,2 | Salt in crude feed (PTB) and chloride in desalted crude tracked over time 2 | How do crude slate changes affect corrosion? |
| Overhead injection points | Neutralizer and wash water rates; too little wash water lets salts deposit 1,2 | Drum water chemistry used to set ammonia for pH control 2 | Injection point |
Sources: OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2 1; Ahmed, 2021 2; CSB Report 2012-03-I-CA, 2015 3.
Common questions
- Is HCl corrosion the same as ammonium chloride corrosion?
- No, but they share a cause. HCl corrodes once it dissolves in condensed water, while ammonium chloride is a salt that HCl forms with ammonia, often before water condenses. See [What is ammonium chloride corrosion?](/library/ammonium-chloride-corrosion/).
- Does a desalter remove the risk?
- It reduces it but does not remove it. The 2021 study treats the desalter as the first barrier and still reports overhead corrosion risk when chloride in desalted crude exceeds 20 ppm; OSHA describes caustic and neutralizer additions after desalting.
- Why does sodium chloride matter less than magnesium chloride?
- Sodium chloride hydrolyzes only slightly at crude furnace temperatures, about 2% at 340 °C (650 °F), while magnesium chloride is about 90% hydrolyzed at the same temperature.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2: Petroleum Refining Processes · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- 2.Corrosion in Crude Oil Distillation Unit Overhead: A Recent Case Study (A. A. Ahmed), ARO The Scientific Journal of Koya University 9(1) · Koya University ·
- 3.Final Investigation Report: Chevron Richmond Refinery Pipe Rupture and Fire (Report 2012-03-I-CA) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB)
- 4.2025 Publications Catalog (entry for RP 571) (RP 571, 3rd edition, March 2020) · American Petroleum Institute (API)