How do crude slate changes affect corrosion?
A crude slate is the mix of crude oils a refinery runs. When it changes, for example toward cheaper opportunity crudes, the sulfur, naphthenic acids, salts and nitrogen reaching the equipment change too, and with them the rate and location of damage such as sulfidation, naphthenic acid corrosion and chloride corrosion in crude unit overheads.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
Virtually all crude oils contain sulfur compounds, so sulfidation acts in every refinery that runs crude, at a rate set by total sulfur, the sulfur species, flow and temperature 1. The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) report on the 2012 Richmond, California, refinery fire quotes the refinery's own corrosion manual, which warns that process changes raising temperature or sulfur "can creep up over time and multiply corrosion rates" until a circuit believed to corrode slowly fails before the higher rate is noticed 1. A 1996 review already described lower-quality opportunity crudes as processed in most refineries, with the source sometimes changing daily 6. Each change of crude is also a change in the corrosion load on the equipment.
What changes in the equipment when the crude changes?
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Technical Manual describes where each crude contaminant acts 2:
| Crude property | Where it acts | Damage | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sulfur compounds: hydrogen sulfide (H2S), a primary contributor, plus mercaptans and elemental sulfur | Preheat furnace, bottoms exchangers, towers and furnace tubes; severe in furnace tubing and towers above about 450 °F (230 °C) | Sulfidation; cracking by wet H2S where water is present | What is sulfidation (high-temperature sulfur corrosion)?, What is wet hydrogen sulfide (H2S) damage? |
| Naphthenic (organic) acids | Hot sections above about 450 °F when the acid value is high, such as the atmospheric tower and the vacuum furnace and tower | Naphthenic acid corrosion | What is naphthenic acid corrosion? |
| Salts: sodium, magnesium and calcium chlorides | Turn into hydrogen chloride when the crude is heated; preheat exchangers and tower overheads | Hydrochloric acid corrosion; ammonium chloride fouling and corrosion | What is hydrochloric acid (HCl) corrosion in crude unit overheads?, What is ammonium chloride corrosion? |
| Nitrogen compounds | Break down in catalytic cracking and hydrocracking to ammonia and cyanides | Corrosion in the catalytic cracking and hydrocracking units | What is hydroprocessing (hydrotreating and hydrocracking)? |
Source: OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2 2.
What is an opportunity crude?
It is a crude bought at a discount because its quality makes it harder to process 7,8,9. A 2007 Department of Energy (DOE) profile of US refining notes that crudes are graded and priced on sulfur content, acidity measured as total acid number (TAN), density and the share of heavy residue, and that sour crude usually sells below sweet 5. The same profile puts sour crudes typically near 0.7 percent sulfur by weight, and as high as 5 percent, and notes that most US refineries were designed 20 or more years earlier for light, sweet crude 5. A 2018 article in Chemical Engineering Progress describes opportunity crudes as abundant and widely varying, often with a higher TAN than traditional crudes 9.
The desalter is the first unit affected 8. Heavier crudes are harder to desalt because oil and water differ less in density, and they can add significantly to corrosion, fouling and catalyst poisoning downstream 8. Refiners running opportunity crudes in the 1990s documented more chloride than expected in atmospheric tower overheads, and standard salt tests did not always predict the chlorides that later form hydrogen chloride 7.
Why don't sulfur and acid numbers alone predict corrosion?
- Thresholds are rules of thumb. A 1996 review found total sulfur and TAN thresholds inaccurate predictors: crudes of similar composition behaved very differently 6.
- The kind of sulfur matters. Corrosivity tracks how readily sulfur compounds break down to H2S at high temperature more than total sulfur 6; the CSB names H2S as the most aggressive sulfur compound 1.
- The kind of acid matters. TAN does not show which acids are present or where in the boiling range they fall, so two crudes with similar TAN can corrode differently 9.
- Flow, temperature and steel matter too 6. Carbon steel low in silicon can corrode by sulfidation up to 16 times faster than higher-silicon carbon steel in the same service 1.
How has the crude run in US refineries changed?
The Energy Information Administration (EIA) publishes the weighted average sulfur content and API gravity of crude oil fed to US refineries each year; API gravity is a density scale of the American Petroleum Institute (API), and a higher value means a lighter crude 2,3,4:
| Year | Sulfur (% by weight) | API gravity (degrees) |
|---|---|---|
| 1985 | 0.91 | 32.46 |
| 1995 | 1.13 | 31.30 |
| 2005 | 1.42 | 30.20 |
| 2008 | 1.46 | 30.21 |
| 2015 | 1.40 | 31.46 |
| 2025 | 1.30 | 33.76 |
Source: EIA, refinery crude oil input qualities, annual series released 30 Sep 2026 3,4.
Average sulfur rose by about 60 percent from 1985 to its 2008 peak, then eased to 1.30 percent in 2025, while API gravity fell to a low of 30.18 degrees in 2004 before rising to 33.76 3,4. A national average hides single refineries, whose feed can change far faster 6.
How is the effect of a crude change tracked?
- Desalting is the first refining step, run to cut corrosion, plugging and fouling and to protect catalysts 2.
- Overhead control. Ammonia may be injected into the overhead, or an alkaline solution into the hot crude, to control hydrochloric acid; with too little wash water, ammonium chloride deposits can cause serious corrosion 2.
- Operating limits. API RP 584 (2nd edition, December 2021) explains how to set up integrity operating windows 11; API RP 571 (3rd edition, March 2020) describes the damage mechanisms involved 11.
- Damage mechanism review. California's refinery rule requires the damage mechanism review (DMR) to check operating parameters that could speed up damage, and to be reviewed before approving a major change, which includes an operational change outside established safe operating limits 10.
Where integrity problems show up
| Decision | Data it depends on | What goes wrong without it | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accepting a new crude or blend | Assay of sulfur species, acid type and distribution, salts and chlorides that can form HCl | Refiners running opportunity crudes found more overhead chloride than salt tests predicted 7 | What is hydrochloric acid (HCl) corrosion in crude unit overheads? |
| Judging hot circuits after a change | Thickness data and silicon content for each component | Richmond, 2012: low-silicon steel corrodes up to 16 times faster, and rising sulfur or temperature can multiply rates unnoticed 1 | Richmond refinery fire (2012): what investigators found about sulfidation |
| Running the desalter on heavier crude | Desalter performance and brine quality | Poor desalting adds corrosion, fouling and catalyst poisoning downstream 2,8 | What is a crude distillation unit? |
| Setting overhead wash water | Wash water rate and neutralizer dosing | Too little wash water lets ammonium chloride deposit and corrode 2 | What is ammonium chloride corrosion? |
| Approving the change | A DMR review where the change counts as major | California requires the review before approval 10 | What is a damage mechanism review? |
Sources: CSB report 2012-03-I-CA, 2015 1; OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2 2; corrosion and refining conference abstracts, 1995 7,8; California Code of Regulations (CCR) Title 8, Section 5189.1 10.
Common questions
- Is sour crude always more corrosive than sweet crude?
- Not by name alone. OSHA notes that West Texas crudes are always called sour whatever their H2S content, while Arabian high-sulfur crudes are not, because their sulfur compounds react little.
- Is a crude slate the same as a crude benchmark?
- No. A benchmark such as Brent or WTI is a pricing reference (see [Brent vs WTI: what is the difference?](/library/brent-vs-wti/)); the slate is the blend a refinery actually runs, usually two or more crudes.
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Final Investigation Report: Chevron Richmond Refinery Pipe Rupture and Fire, Report No. 2012-03-I-CA · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
- 2.OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 2: Petroleum Refining Process · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- 3.U.S. Sulfur Content (Weighted Average) of Crude Oil Input to Refineries (annual series) · US Energy Information Administration (EIA)
- 4.U.S. API Gravity (Weighted Average) of Crude Oil Input to Refineries (annual series) · US Energy Information Administration (EIA)
- 5.Energy and Environmental Profile of the U.S. Petroleum Refining Industry (J. Pellegrino et al., Energetics Inc.), OSTI 1218665 · US Department of Energy, Industrial Technologies Program, via OSTI.gov
- 6.Review of critical factors affecting crude corrosivity (S. Tebbal, R. D. Kane), Corrosion/96, abstract record OSTI 271978 · NACE International conference paper, abstract via OSTI.gov
- 7.The impact of desalting opportunity crudes on corrosion precursors (M. S. Binford, P. R. Hart), Corrosion/95, abstract record OSTI 128693 · NACE International conference paper, abstract via OSTI.gov
- 8.Desalting opportunity crudes (M. A. Dion), NPRA Annual Meeting 1995, abstract record OSTI 93388 · National Petroleum Refiners Association conference paper, abstract via OSTI.gov
- 9.Implement an Effective Corrosion Mitigation Program, Chemical Engineering Progress (public excerpt) · American Institute of Chemical Engineers (AIChE)
- 10.California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Section 5189.1, Process Safety Management for Petroleum Refineries · California Department of Industrial Relations
- 11.2025 Publications Catalog (entries for RP 571 and RP 584) (RP 571, 3rd edition, March 2020; RP 584, 2nd edition, December 2021) · American Petroleum Institute (API)