What is soil corrosion?
Soil corrosion is external corrosion of buried metal, such as pipelines and casings, caused by water, salts and oxygen differences in the surrounding soil. Its rate depends on moisture, aeration, resistivity, chemistry, bacteria and stray currents. US rules (49 CFR 192.455) require coating and cathodic protection on most buried gas pipelines installed since 1971.
By Jun Zhong, Editor·Researched and drafted by Beacon's AI newsroom·Checked by Jun Zhong, Editor·Last checked ·Next review
Why does it matter?
For ten years before it failed, cathodic protection readings at the test station nearest the rupture site, about 100 feet away, were satisfactory 1. Yet when a buried 20-inch gas transmission line ruptured near Sissonville, West Virginia, on 11 December 2012, its outside had corroded over an area about 6 feet long, leaving less than 30% of the original wall at the thinnest point 1. The US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found that rocky backfill had most likely damaged the coating and shielded the pipe from the protective current, and that the line had not been inspected or tested since 1988 1. The fire destroyed three houses and closed Interstate 77 for 19 hours 1.
Why does soil corrode buried steel?
Soil is an electrolyte. Where it touches steel, some areas of the pipe become anodes and corrode while others become cathodes, and current flows through the soil between them 3. The US National Bureau of Standards (NBS), which studied underground corrosion from 1910 to 1955 and buried more than 36,500 specimens of 333 materials at 128 US sites, grouped the causes under aeration, the soil electrolyte, electrical effects and other factors 2.
- Aeration and moisture. Areas starved of oxygen become anodic to well-aerated areas 2,3. Where the water table sits at the bottom of a pipe, the bottom corrodes more than the top 2. Over long distances, pipe in well-aerated ground can drive corrosion of pipe in poorly aerated ground several kilometres away ("long-line" corrosion) 3.
- Resistivity and dissolved salts. Low-resistivity soil lets corrosion current flow easily 3. NBS found that corrosivity tracks resistivity more clearly than it tracks pH 2, and NPL treats soils with electrical conductivity above about 1,000 microsiemens per centimetre as aggressive 8.
- Bacteria. Sulfate-reducing bacteria, active in airless compacted clay, can drive corrosion where oxygen is absent 2,3.
- Stray currents. Direct current from electric railways, power installations or other pipelines' cathodic protection causes attack where it leaves the pipe; parallel high-voltage lines can induce alternating current 3.
- Backfill. Stones or sticks touching the pipe have caused serious corrosion 2. Large rocks damage coatings and, as at Sissonville, can block cathodic protection current 1,3.
Which soils are most corrosive?
NPL's guide illustrates a route from a rocky hillside across a valley: well-drained, high-resistivity rock gives a low rate; poorly aerated, low-resistivity clay corrodes as an anode to the rocky section; ground under roads and in marshes tends to be anodic; and steel can corrode a few inches from where it leaves a concrete encasement 3. Wet clays, marsh soils and ground contaminated by chemical waste, agricultural chemicals or de-icing salt are the usual concerns 3. NBS also found that the deepest pit observed tends to grow with the area surveyed, so a small dig may not show the worst damage 2.
How is soil corrosion found?
- Before construction. A corrosion survey measures soil resistivity, tests chemistry and bacteria, and assesses stray currents before the route is fixed 3. A new US buried gas line may skip coating and cathodic protection only if such tests show no corrosive environment 4.
- Cathodic protection readings. Test stations and close interval surveys measure pipe-to-soil potential, the latter every few feet along the line 1. NTSB noted that close interval surveys do not cover 100% of the pipe and cannot detect shielding by rocks 1.
- Direct assessment. External corrosion direct assessment (ECDA) has four steps: pre-assessment, indirect inspection with at least two complementary tools, direct examination, and post-assessment 6.
- In-line inspection and pressure testing. NTSB concluded that in-line inspection or a pressure test of the Sissonville line, after nearby lines in the same corridor showed external corrosion in 2009, would likely have revealed the wall loss 1.
- Whenever pipe is exposed. Bare or poorly coated buried gas pipe that is uncovered must be examined, and the search widened if damage needing repair is found 5.
How is soil corrosion controlled?
- Coating plus cathodic protection. With limited exceptions, US buried gas lines installed after 31 July 1971 need an external coating and cathodic protection working within 1 year of construction 4. The coating is the primary barrier; cathodic protection protects the steel at coating damage, provided the current can reach it 1.
- Backfill control. Excluding large rocks, replacing contaminated soil and avoiding voids in clay backfill reduce coating damage and water collection 3.
- Electrical isolation from other buried structures and from metal casings, unless they are protected as one unit 7.
- Stray current control, usually by earthing or bonding, assessed by specialists 3.
- NPL puts the cost of effective corrosion control at about 1 to 2% of the cost of laying a pipeline 3.
Where integrity problems show up
| Where it occurs (unit or equipment) | Conditions that drive it | How it is usually found | In the Library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buried pipe in rocky backfill | Rocks damage the coating and shield cathodic protection current 1 | In-line inspection or pressure testing; close interval surveys miss shielding 1 | What is in-line inspection (ILI) and pigging? |
| Lines crossing changing soils, roads, rivers and marshes | Differences in aeration and resistivity, long-line currents 2,3 | Indirect inspection followed by direct examination (ECDA) 6 | What is direct assessment (ECDA, ICDA, SCCDA)? |
| Lines near electric railways, other pipelines or high-voltage power lines | Stray direct current and induced alternating current 3 | Stray current assessment with recording instruments 3 | Pipe-to-soil potential |
| Pipe in airless, compacted clay | Sulfate-reducing bacteria 2,3 | Bacteria tests in soil surveys; black, sulfide-smelling product when exposed 3,4 | What is microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC)? |
| Pipe inside metal casings at crossings | Contact between pipe and casing 7 | Inspection and electrical tests of isolation 7 | How does cathodic protection work? |
| Any buried section uncovered during work | Bare pipe or deteriorated coating 5 | Mandatory examination, extended beyond the dig if damage is found 5 | Coating holiday |
Sources: NTSB/PAR-14/01, 2014 1; NBS Circular 579, 1957 2; NPL Guide No. 4, 2020 3; 49 CFR 192.455, 192.459, 192.925 and 192.467 4,5,6,7.
Common questions
- Do good cathodic protection readings prove a buried pipe is protected?
- No. Readings at test stations, and surveys every few feet, measure potential at points; they cannot see where rocks or disbonded coating block the current from reaching the steel.
- Is soil corrosion the same as stray current corrosion?
- Stray current is one cause of corrosion in soil, driven by current from an outside source. Soil corrosion also happens without it, from aeration differences, salts and bacteria.
- Is soil corrosion the same as galvanic corrosion?
- Not always, but they overlap: new steel joined to old steel or iron pipe can corrode galvanically in the same soil. See [What is galvanic corrosion?](/library/galvanic-corrosion/).
Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.
Sources
- 1.Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation Pipeline Rupture, Sissonville, West Virginia, December 11, 2012 (NTSB/PAR-14/01) · US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)
- 2.Underground Corrosion, Circular 579 (M. Romanoff) · US National Bureau of Standards (now NIST)
- 3.Corrosion control for buried pipelines (Guides to Good Practice in Corrosion Control No. 4) · UK National Physical Laboratory (NPL)
- 4.49 CFR 192.455, External corrosion control: Buried or submerged pipelines installed after July 31, 1971 · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 5.49 CFR 192.459, External corrosion control: Examination of buried pipeline when exposed · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 6.49 CFR 192.925, What are the requirements for using External Corrosion Direct Assessment (ECDA)? · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 7.49 CFR 192.467, External corrosion control: Electrical isolation · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
- 8.Bimetallic Corrosion (Guides to Good Practice in Corrosion Control No. 5) · UK National Physical Laboratory (NPL)