Skip to content
Beaconby Winda
FactOperations, Maintenance and Process Safety · Turnarounds and shutdowns

How is a refinery turnaround planned?

·5 sources

Short answer

A refinery turnaround is planned over about 1 to 3 years. Planners set the timing, collect and screen work requests into a fixed scope, take modifications through management of change, order long-lead equipment, book contractors, and build schedules and procedures. The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) describes the basic scope as settled about 10 to 12 months before shutdown.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

At a refinery in Richmond, California, recommendations to replace a carbon steel crude unit line in sulfidation service were denied for the 2007 and 2011 turnarounds, and the line ruptured on 6 August 2012 2. The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) found that the turnaround planning group judged requests against fixed criteria, and that inspection data taken on more corrosion-resistant fittings suggested the line could run until 2016 2. Nineteen employees were caught in the vapor cloud, and about 15,000 people from nearby communities sought medical treatment 2. Scope decisions are hard to reverse later: EIA notes that once labor, equipment and materials are committed, changing a turnaround plan is costly 1.

What are the main planning milestones?

EIA's 2007 report set out a generic timeline for a major fluid catalytic cracking (FCC) turnaround held every 5 years 1. The table restates it, with the points where US process safety management (PSM) rules apply.

Time before shutdownMain decisions
About 30 to 36 monthsDecide whether new technology or long-lead equipment is included; new vessels, compressors or turbines can take 2 years or more to design and build, and special cranes must be reserved 1
About 24 monthsDefine and approve the project concept and upgrades; start engineering for modifications and their management of change (MOC) review 1
About 18 monthsInspect equipment and review systems to define the work in detail; buy long-lead materials; begin contractor negotiations 1
About 10 to 12 monthsSettle the basic scope of maintenance and minor modifications; contract outside shops for work on compressors, turbines, control and relief valves, exchangers and critical piping 1
At least 6 monthsComplete final engineering and operating plans for each change so the MOC review can finish 1
Final monthsThe turnaround organization takes over schedules and often sets up on site; crude purchases and product supply are adjusted 1; shutdown procedures are reviewed before the event, as the Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS) recommends 5

Without major new equipment, EIA says main planning starts about 2 years ahead 1. At large refineries, EIA notes, the team that runs shutdowns can be a standing group that moves from one unit's turnaround to the next, using scheduling software that can coordinate thousands of jobs 1.

How is the work scope built and screened?

Requests reach the planners from several directions, including inspection and metallurgy recommendations, reliability programs and improvement projects 1,2. At Richmond, a document of predetermined criteria set which items were accepted automatically; less urgent work, and work that could be done with the unit running or at the next turnaround, was left out by default 2.

The CSB found three weaknesses in how that screening worked 2:

  • Data that could not show the risk. Thickness readings came from high-silicon fittings that corroded slowly; no condition monitoring location was placed on the low-silicon component that failed 2.
  • A rule that blocked data gathering. Discretionary work needed hard data from the equipment, even when its purpose was to produce that data through 100 percent component inspection based on industry guidance 2.
  • No owner for the exception route. An informal appeal to the unit manager existed but was never used, and no senior manager was assigned to see the sulfidation recommendations into the scope 2.

During the 2011 turnaround, thinning in a 12-inch section of the same line was severe enough to need immediate replacement, but only the parts with supporting data were replaced 2. After the rupture, inspecting all 4,600 crude unit piping components susceptible to sulfidation found 4 more with higher corrosion rates than the piping beside them 2.

What must be ready before the shutdown?

  • Changes. Changes made during a turnaround, other than replacement in kind, go through MOC, with drawings and procedures updated before startup 4.
  • Procedures. Written procedures must cover normal shutdown and startup following a turnaround, and operating procedures must be certified annually 4,5. At Superior, Wisconsin, the shutdown procedure used for the 2018 turnaround reversed the pressure balance that the FCC licensor's guidance required 3.
  • Contractors and permits. The PSM contractor paragraph covers turnaround work; employers must evaluate contractors' safety performance and tell them of the process hazards, and hot work needs a permit 4.
  • Startup checks. A facility modified enough to change its process safety information needs a pre-startup safety review before highly hazardous chemicals are introduced 4.

Where integrity problems show up

Element or stepIntegrity linkIn the Library
Scope criteriaRecommendations to fully inspect or replace the section that later failed were rejected under the criteria 2How is inspection scope set for a turnaround?
Inspection data behind scope decisionsReadings on slow-corroding fittings were applied to the whole line, including a faster-corroding component 2What are condition monitoring locations (CMLs)?
Findings during the turnaroundSevere thinning found in 2011 led to partial replacement only 2What is sulfidation (high-temperature sulfur corrosion)?
Condition data between turnaroundsThe CSB recommended that slide valve monitoring data be reviewed quarterly to support decisions such as shortening the turnaround cycle 3What is mechanical integrity (MI)?
Outside shop workRelief valves, control valves, exchangers and critical piping are contracted out about 10 to 12 months ahead 1What does a pressure relief valve do?
Modifications and startupMOC before the change and a pre-startup safety review before restart 4What is a pre-startup safety review (PSSR)?

Sources: EIA, SR/OOG/2007-01 1; CSB Richmond report, 2015 2; CSB report No. 2018-02-I-WI, 2022 3; 29 CFR 1910.119 4.

Common questions

What is a scope freeze?
It is the point after which new work is no longer added without special approval. EIA places the settling of the basic scope about 10 to 12 months before shutdown and notes that changes become harder and more expensive as the date nears.
Can a turnaround be postponed?
Large ones have little room to move. EIA cited the American Petroleum Institute's estimate that delaying a turnaround could raise its cost by 20 to 50 percent, and noted that delay makes unplanned outages of the unit more likely.
Do turnarounds usually finish on time?
Often not. In an industry survey of 28 FCC units cited by EIA in 2007, 16 of the 22 units that targeted 4 to 5 years between turnarounds achieved it, and turnarounds ran an average of 5 days longer than planned.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Refinery Outages: Description and Potential Impact on Petroleum Product Prices (SR/OOG/2007-01) · US Energy Information Administration (EIA)
  2. 2.Final Investigation Report: Chevron Richmond Refinery Pipe Rupture and Fire · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
  3. 3.Investigation Report: FCC Unit Explosion and Asphalt Fire at Husky Superior Refinery, Superior, WI (Report No. 2018-02-I-WI) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
  4. 4.29 CFR 1910.119, Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals (paragraphs (f), (h), (i), (k), (l) and Appendix C) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  5. 5.Process Safety Management for Petroleum Refineries: Lessons Learned from the Petroleum Refinery Process Safety Management National Emphasis Program (OSHA 3918) · US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)