Skip to content
Beaconby Winda

What is layer of protection analysis (LOPA)?

·6 sources

Short answer

Layer of protection analysis (LOPA) is a semi-quantitative method that checks whether the safeguards on one hazard scenario reduce its risk enough. It lowers the expected frequency of the scenario's cause by credit for each independent protection layer, then compares the order-of-magnitude result with a tolerable target. It can set the safety integrity level required under IEC 61511.

By , Editor·Researched and drafted by ·Checked by , Editor·Last checked ·Next review

Why does it matter?

Before the April 2018 explosion at a refinery in Superior, Wisconsin, a 2016 LOPA had examined 126 scenarios on the fluid catalytic cracking (FCC) unit, yet none of its 39 reverse flow scenarios covered startup or shutdown, and the unit exploded while being shut down 1. Most of those scenarios relied on automatic closure of catalyst slide valves, and one of those valves had eroded over five years of service until it left an open path for air 1. The US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) reported 36 workers injured and about $550 million in property damage 1. It found that the hazard reviews and the LOPA did not recognize that the slide valves alone were inadequate, and that leaving out startup and shutdown scenarios meant gaps for those modes were never examined 1.

How does a LOPA work, step by step?

The Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS) positions LOPA between two extremes, the qualitative reviews used in process hazard analysis and full quantitative risk analysis: it starts from an identified accident scenario and ends with a risk estimate meant to be right to within an order of magnitude 3. The UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) describes the aim as finding any shortfall between the risk reduction that existing safeguards give and the reduction needed to meet predetermined, risk-based criteria 2.

StepWhat the team doesResult
1. Choose a scenarioTakes one cause and consequence pair from a hazard review, usually one ranked severe 1Scenario and consequence category
2. Estimate the initiating event frequencyEstimates how often the cause, such as an equipment malfunction or human error, is expected 1,3Events per year, to an order of magnitude
3. Test each safeguardCredits only safeguards that qualify as independent protection layers (IPLs) 1Credited layers
4. Adjust where the method allowsApplies conditional modifiers or enabling events 2Adjusted frequency
5. Compare with the targetSets the remaining frequency against the organization's tolerable frequency 2Gap or no gap
6. Close any gapImproves or adds a layer, often a safety instrumented function with a required safety integrity level (SIL) 1,3Recommendation

The frequencies, credits and targets used in steps 2 to 5 come from each company's procedure or published guidance 1,2; this page does not reproduce any of them.

What counts as an independent protection layer?

The CSB report cites the CCPS glossary: an IPL is a device, system or action that can stop the scenario from reaching its consequence and is not degraded by the initiating event or by any other layer credited in that scenario 1. CCPS also lists seven attributes a layer must be designed and managed to meet: independence, function, integrity, reliability, validation with maintenance and audit, access security, and management of change 1.

  • Engineered layers. Automated shutdowns and safety instrumented functions are typical candidates 1. HSE names independence from shared utilities, from shared management systems and from other protective systems as conditions for relying on a safety function 5.
  • Alarms with operator response. The CSB notes that human response safeguards usually have a higher chance of failing than engineered ones, and that an operator response is not a valid IPL when the same operator who started the upset is the one expected to respond 1. HSE guidance treats a heavily credited alarm and operator response as a safety-related system needing its own SIL 5.

How does LOPA relate to HAZOP and safety integrity levels?

A hazard and operability study (HAZOP) or another process hazard analysis finds scenarios qualitatively; LOPA then takes the high-consequence ones and asks whether their safeguards are enough 1,3. The 2016 study at Superior stated both purposes: to confirm that adequate IPLs existed and to set the SIL requirements of any safety instrumented functions needed 1.

CCPS notes that instrument standards such as IEC 61511 endorse LOPA as a way to set the required SIL 3. IEC 61511-1 (edition 2.0, 2016, amended 2017) is the process-industry standard for safety instrumented systems, taking them from first specification and engineering through to their running and upkeep in service 6. In the UK, the Process Safety Leadership Group prepared guidance on using LOPA to set the SIL of overfill protection for large fuel storage tanks after the 2005 Buncefield explosion 2.

The US process safety management (PSM) rule does not name LOPA. It requires a process hazard analysis using what-if, checklist, HAZOP, failure mode and effects analysis, fault tree analysis or "an appropriate equivalent methodology," and the analysis must address the consequences of failure of engineering and administrative controls 4. It must be updated and revalidated at least every 5 years 4.

Where integrity problems show up

Element or stepIntegrity linkIn the Library
Valve or other device credited as a layerCredit assumes it closes or seals on demand; the credited slide valve at Superior had eroded into an open path for air 1What is mechanical integrity (MI)?
Inspection findings on credited equipment at a turnaroundErosion was found on that valve at the 2008 and 2013 turnarounds, yet it went back into service; the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) later cited the refinery for this 1How is inspection scope set for a turnaround?
Relief devices, emergency shutdown systems, alarms and interlocksThe US PSM rule places them in the mechanical integrity program, with inspection and testing that follow recognized good engineering practice and are documented 4What does a pressure relief valve do?
Safety instrumented functionIts chance of failing on demand depends heavily on how often proof tests are run and whether they reveal hidden failures 5What is a safety instrumented system (SIS)?
Sensors and process connectionsHSE lists protection of sensors and connections against vibration and corrosion, and end-to-end tests that prove impulse lines 5What is a safety integrity level (SIL)?
Scenario listLeaving out shutdown scenarios left the safeguards for that mode unexamined 1What is a turnaround (planned plant shutdown)?
Changes to a credited layerManagement of change is one of the seven attributes a layer must meet 1What is management of change (MOC)?

Sources: CSB report No. 2018-02-I-WI, 2022 1; 29 CFR 1910.119(j) 4; HSE COMAH technical measures, control systems 5.

Common questions

Is LOPA the same as HAZOP?
No. A [HAZOP](/library/hazop/) is a qualitative team review that finds deviations and their causes, while LOPA takes one identified scenario at a time and estimates whether its independent safeguards are enough.
Is LOPA a quantitative risk assessment?
Only partly. Its results are order-of-magnitude estimates, and HSE's course includes deciding when a full quantitative risk assessment is the better tool.
Can an alarm and operator response count as a protection layer?
It can if it meets the IPL attributes and the operator has enough time to recognize the problem and act. It does not count when the operator whose action started the upset is also the one expected to catch it.

Beacon explains these concepts in its own words for education. It does not reproduce or replace the standards cited, and Winda is not affiliated with or endorsed by the organizations that publish them. Engineering decisions need the current edition of the standard and a qualified engineer.

Sources

  1. 1.Investigation Report: FCC Unit Explosion and Asphalt Fire at Husky Superior Refinery, Superior, WI (Report No. 2018-02-I-WI) · US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) ·
  2. 2.LOPA: Practical application and pitfalls (training course description) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  3. 3.Layer of Protection Analysis: Simplified Process Risk Assessment (publisher page) · Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS), via John Wiley and Sons
  4. 4.29 CFR 1910.119, Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals (paragraphs (e) and (j)) · eCFR, US Office of the Federal Register
  5. 5.Control systems (COMAH technical measures document) · UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
  6. 6.IEC 61511-1:2016, Functional safety: Safety instrumented systems for the process industry sector, Part 1 (product page) (Edition 2.0 (2016); Amendment 1 (2017), consolidated as edition 2.1) · International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) ·